The Outstanding Teaching Fellow Award is annually awarded to one Graduate Writing Fellow in the Arts & Sciences Writing Program.
| YEAR | NAME | DEPARTMENT |
| 2024 | Rosana Hernández Nieto | Romance Studies (Spanish) |
| 2022 | Cari Babitzke | History |
| 2021 | Megan Lebarron | American & New England Studies |
| 2020 | Ken Alba | English |
| 2019 | Ben Suitt | Religion |
| 2018 | Emily Gowen | English |
| 2017 | Laura Heath-Stout | Archaeology |
| 2016 | Sam Shupe | American & New England Studies |
| 2015 | Heather Barrett | English |
| 2014 | Liam Meyer | English |
| 2013 | Karen Guendel | English |
| 2012 | Jessica Kent | English |