facebook pixel
Skip to Main Content
Boston University School of Law

  • Academics
  • Admissions & Aid
  • Faculty & Research
Search
  • Current Students
  • Faculty & Staff
  • Alumni
  • Employers
  • Journalists
Search
  • Academics
    • Find Degrees and Programs
    • Explore Your Options
    • Study Abroad
    • Academic Calendar
  • Admissions & Aid
    • JD Admissions
    • Graduate Admissions
    • Tuition & Fees
    • Financial Aid
    • Visits & Tours
  • Faculty & Research
    • Faculty Profiles
    • Activities & Engagements
    • Centers & Institutes
  • Experiential Learning
    • Clinics & Practicums
    • Externship Programs
    • Simulation Courses
    • Law Journals
    • Moot Court
  • Careers & Professional Development
    • Career Advising for JD Students
    • Career Advising for Graduate Students
    • Employment Statistics
    • Employment Sectors
    • Public Service Programs
  • Student Life
    • Advising & Student Support
    • Law Student Organizations
    • Living in Boston
  • Law Libraries
    • About the Libraries
    • A-Z Database List
    • Institutional Repository
  • About BU Law
    • Offices & Services
    • Meet the Dean
    • Diversity, Equity & Inclusion
    • Visit Campus
  • News & Stories
    • All Stories
    • Faculty in the News
    • Past Issues of The Record

Want to Support BU Law?Learn how you can give back


Latest Stories From The Record

A close up image of slot machines in a row
Public Policy

A Safe Bet

Read more
Pnina Lahav and image of book cover “The Only Woman in the Room”
Gender and Law

Golda Meir’s Persistence

Read more
A white gavel sits against a red background. A figure climbs up the inside of the gavel.
LAW150

Major Cases

Read more
Portrait of Associate Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson smiling in a black robe.
BU Law News

Associate Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson is BU Law’s 2023 Commencement Speaker

Read more
News & Stories from BU Law
  • Issues
  • All Stories

Close Encounters with Whistleblower Law

For a class with Lecturer Robert Thomas, BU Law student Andrew Tran (’22) wrote a research paper based on an extensive interview with Pentagon Papers whistleblower Daniel Ellsberg.

Daniel Ellsburg at the Capitol

Daniel Ellsberg, the former Defense Department researcher who leaked top-secret Pentagon papers to the press, reports at the Capitol on July 28, 1971 to an unofficial House panel investigating the significance of the Vietnam War documents. (AP Photo)

Experiential Education

Close Encounters with Whistleblower Law

For a class with Lecturer Robert Thomas, BU Law student Andrew Tran (’22) wrote a research paper based on an extensive interview with Pentagon Papers whistleblower Daniel Ellsberg.

March 17, 2021
  • Rebecca Beyer
Twitter Facebook

For his final paper in Boston University School of Law Lecturer Robert M. Thomas’ Whistleblower Law & Practice class, Andrew Tran (’22) decided to research one of the most famous whistleblowers in history: Daniel Ellsberg, who, in 1971, gave reporters thousands of copies of top-secret documents detailing America’s involvement in the Vietnam War.

BU Law Student Andrew Tran
Andrew Tran (’22)

Tran and Thomas conducted a Zoom video call with Ellsberg—whom President Nixon’s national security advisor once called “the most dangerous man in America”—in November. Tran also reviewed White House tapes from the Richard Nixon Presidential Library and Museum and interviewed other legal scholars. The resulting paper traces the history of the Espionage Act of 1917, which Ellsberg was charged with violating (charges were dismissed in 1973 after the judge revealed the government sought to bribe him in the case). The paper also argues—as proposed recently in a bill by US Representative Tulsi Gabbard—for changes to the law that would allow a whistleblower to present their motive or intent as a form of defense.

Thomas, co-founder of the Whistleblower Law Collaborative LLC, a Boston-based law firm, has covered whistleblowing in the context of healthcare fraud and abuse in a course he has taught for more than a decade at BU Law. But last fall was the first time the school offered a more general whistleblower law course. Thomas says he came up with the idea because some of the scandals of the Trump Administration—including Trump’s phone call with Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky, which led to the first impeachment trial—were revealed by whistleblowers.

Lecturer Robert Thomas
Boston University School of Law Lecturer Robert M. Thomas

“I thought it would be a crime not to teach that topic in this particular time frame,” Thomas explains.

Other students wrote papers on more recent whistleblowers. But Tran knew right away he would seek out Ellsberg, whom he had previously interviewed as a high school student in Orange County, California, for a short documentary on the Pentagon Papers. And Ellsberg isn’t Tran’s only encounter with a historic figure from the Vietnam era: as an undergraduate at Yale University, Tran took a seminar with Washington Post journalist Bob Woodward, who, among other major scoops, revealed the Watergate scandal (with the help of an anonymous whistleblower). Tran later helped Woodward write the script for his MasterClass on investigative journalism.

Tran and Thomas bonded over their shared personal interest in Ellsberg’s actions in the context of the Vietnam War, which they discovered in a conversation after their first class session. Tran’s grandfather had been the secretary of agriculture for the government of South Vietnam and had faced his own whistleblowing dilemma when American researchers brought him documentation of the harmful effects of Agent Orange exposure. Thomas wrote several undergraduate research papers on the Vietnam War, including one on the 1964 Gulf of Tonkin Resolution, which Congress passed to authorize the use of force in Vietnam and was based on misleading information—as subsequently revealed by Ellsberg.

“I was raised with the mythology of American greatness,” Thomas says. “And everything that was on the news [during the era of the Vietnam War and the civil rights movement] was challenging that mythology. So Andrew and I both came to the question of what really happened in Vietnam from deep levels of interest.”

They both say they learned a lot from Ellsberg about the so far unsuccessful efforts to make Espionage Act prosecutions fairer for defendants (such prosecutions increased under Presidents Obama and Trump). The problem, according to Tran’s paper, is that the law—passed by the 65th Congress in 1917—was meant to target spies but has also been used to punish and intimidate people who have sought to disclose classified information in the public’s interest.

Andrew Tran and Robert Thomas interview Daniel Ellsberg
Thomas and Tran interview whistleblower Daniel Ellsberg.

“The 65th Congress could not have anticipated that… the Act would eventually and inevitably be blind to the difference between whistleblowers and spies,” Tran wrote in his paper.

After taking Thomas’ class last fall, Tran is now working as an extern at Thomas’ Whistleblower Law Collaborative, which focuses on federal and state False Claims Act and other whistleblower cases. So far, he has worked on drafting responses to a defendant’s motion to dismiss and revising briefs.

Thomas accepts BU Law students as externs throughout the year.

“It’s an obvious fit for us,” he says. “They’re familiar with the content, and I’ve already had a sneak peek at their talent level.”

Tran calls Thomas a mentor.

“Bob would organize office hour sessions where we could just sit and talk about our careers, our lives, or anything else we wanted to discuss,” he says of the course last fall.

Up next for Tran is a summer associate position at Shearman & Sterling in New York. After that, he plans to spend a semester in Washington, DC. interning for NPR legal affairs correspondent Nina Totenberg. Thomas’ course touched on several of his interests, including journalism and media and First Amendment law.

“I had learned about whistleblowing from the historical perspective, but I had no idea what it was like from the legal perspective,” Tran says. “It was really worth my while to learn what happens when you decide to blow the whistle, the barriers you have to go through, and the potential rewards.”

Related

  • Protestors in Atlanta

    Human Rights

    BU Law Team Secures Release for Immigrants Who Allege Abuse by Doctor

    February 11, 2021

  • The White House

    Election

    Presidential Transitions and Midnight Regulations

    November 24, 2020

  • Don Calloway ('04)

    Election

    The Fight for Fair Elections

    October 20, 2020

Explore Related Topics:

  • Politics
  • Public Interest
  • Share this story

Share

Close Encounters with Whistleblower Law

Share this:

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn
  • Rebecca Beyer

    Writer Twitter Profile

    Rebecca Beyer

    Rebecca Beyer is a freelance writer and editor in Boston. Profile

  • Issues
  • All Stories
  • About & Contact

More about School of Law

Also See

  • ABA Required Disclosures
  • Licensing Disclosures
  • Statement of Nondiscrimination

Contact Us

  • JD Admissions
  • LLM & Graduate Admissions
  • Offices & Services
  • Faculty & Staff Directory
  • Instagram
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
© 2023 Boston University. All rights reserved. www.bu.edu
  • Current Students
  • Faculty & Staff
  • Alumni
  • Employers
  • Journalists
Search
Boston University

Boston University School of Law
765 Commonwealth Avenue Boston, MA 02215

  • © 2022 Trustees of Boston University
  • Privacy Statement
  • Accessibility
  • Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA)
Boston University Masterplate