How Consumer Perceptions Affect Ethnic Restaurant Location Patterns

How Consumer Perceptions Affect Ethnic Restaurant Location Patterns image by LightAndShare on Shutterstock
By LightAndShare on Shutterstock

By Sean (Sangwon) Jung, Ph.D., Assistant Professor of Hospitality Analytics, Boston University School of Hospitality Administration

Introduction

Ethnic restaurants in the U.S. have been consistently growing. So much so that according to the U.S. census bureau, ethnic restaurants have increased by an impressive 45% from 2002 to 2012, while the total number of restaurants have only increased by 19%. More interestingly, the interest of non-mainstream ethnic food has been the main reason for this increase, where non-mainstream ethnic restaurants increased by 66% within the same timeframe. Though there are many reasons as to why we observe an upward trend in ethnic restaurant establishments, it is quite apparent that people are becoming more accepting of other cultures. Today, we often see a diverse group of people who spend their time amongst friends with different ethnic backgrounds and food is one aspect people enjoy sharing. This shift of perception has also changed the general acceptance of ethnic restaurants. The term “ethnic restaurant,” which is defined as restaurants that serve cuisines that are not common to the regional consumers (Leung, 2010), has experienced a change in tone where dining out in ethnic restaurants has become an enjoyable experience. 

When considering ethnic restaurant demand, this change in acceptance is coming from non-ethnic consumers (who are not the same ethnic group as the ethnic restaurant) who have unique perceptions that trigger acceptance which ethnic group consumers do not have. To name a few, consumers from the non-ethnic group carry the perception of the country of origin, the acceptance of exotic food, and acceptance of ethnic restaurants by a different culture. In contrast, the ethnic group that matches the ethnic restaurant theme do not have these perceptions. However, they live in clustered communities that share values and provide easier access to jobs (Ram et al., 2000). 

Acknowledging these two differences which are (1) difference in acceptance from non-ethnic groups and (2) different living patterns from ethnic groups, the decision to select a location near or away from competitors for ethnic restaurants should be quite different as opposed to decisions that non-ethnic restaurants make. For instance, the best strategy for ethnic restaurants that have low acceptance because of low perception would be to locate in clustered regions within the ethnic community. This would help reduce risk of having no demand, since demand from the ethnic group that matches the ethnic restaurant exists within the community. In addition, by having the same ethnic restaurants clustered in one region, it helps reduce search cost for non-ethnic consumers which aids in representing quality assurance (Marshall, 1890; Jung & Jang, 2019). However, the disadvantage of having all ethnic restaurants agglomerated in one region is competition eroding everyone’s profit (Hotelling, 1929). Nevertheless, ethnic restaurants have no choice but to cluster within their ethnic communities since non-ethnic consumers have low acceptance of the particular ethnic restaurant theme. In contrast, for ethnic restaurants that have high acceptance, the best strategy is to diffuse from each other since each ethnic restaurant will avoid competition from similarly themed ethnic competitors. This would provide the ethnic restaurant an opportunity to maximize their profits. 

The analogy suggests a theory that ethnic restaurant clustering patterns might be explained by non-ethnic group acceptance, where higher acceptance from this group will result in ethnic restaurant themes staying away from each other to reduce competition. The following results attempt to prove this research question: “Do ethnic restaurants try to locate away from each other when they have higher acceptance from non-ethnic consumers?”

Method

Identifying the ordering of perceptions for each ethnic restaurant theme using tweets

To identify acceptance, this study used Twitter to identify three types of acceptance which were food perceptions (FOOD), restaurant perceptions in general (REST), and perceptions of the country of origin (COO). The study used sentimental analysis through text mining to identify the three acceptances. Sentimental analysis uses words in a given sentence to identify how positive or negative a tweet is. For this reason, a word list of positives and negatives was required. For this study, Hu and Liu’s (2004) word list (https://www.cs.uic.edu/~liub/FBS/sentiment-analysis.html#lexicon) was used to identify the opinion for each ethnic restaurant theme. As an example of how sentimental analysis was used, if an individual wrote “I love Italian food” in a tweet, this would be considered as positive +1 since it consists of one positive word, “love,” with no negative word for Italian food perception. By using this method, we find perceptions of food, restaurants, and countries of origin for each ethnic theme restaurant that are then converted to numbers. Finally, using the numerical value for each ethnic theme, we find the average value of each ethnic restaurant theme as well as the order of perception which is presented in table 1.

Table 1

Identifying restaurant clustered intensity for each ethnic restaurant theme

To identify the intensity of clustered patterns, an index was created by identifying the percentage of restaurant agglomeration for each restaurant within a set number of miles over the total number of restaurants in the city, divided by the total number of restaurants in each theme. In other words, the index indicates how clustered the ethnic restaurant is in a region by identifying the density of similar ethnic-themed restaurants surrounding it, which represents competition intensity.

Results and Conclusion

The results on how perception affects ethnic restaurants cluster patterns

By using the ordering pattern and the index that was created for this study, we ran a model for radiuses between 0.2 mile and 1 mile. Results showed ethnic restaurant themes that had higher acceptance were more diffused than ethnic restaurant themes that had lower perception. Interestingly, this was observed across all acceptance, which further supports the claim that non-ethnic group perception determines how ethnic restaurants locate. For practitioners, this suggests that the decision to locate near similar competition should be determined by how comfortable non-ethnic consumers are with the ethnic food theme. If the region that was selected to establish an ethnic restaurant theme has consumers that are not aware of, or have low acceptance of an ethnic cuisine, restaurant atmosphere or country of origin culture, it is best to locate in regions where ethnic groups that match the restaurants theme reside, as well as near similar-themed competitors. However, if it is a well-established ethnic restaurant theme, such as Mexican or Chinese restaurants, the study results suggest it is best practice to diffuse away from competitors.

Acknowledgments 

I would like to give special thanks to Peter Bheda from Boston University School of Hospitality Administration for the helpful comments. The article was accepted by Mark Legg, Ph.D., Boston University School of Hospitality Administration.


PDF Version Available Here


23 comments

  1. MuleSoft MCD-Level-1 Dumps Questions are designed to help you prepare for the MuleSoft Certified Developer Level 1 (MCD-Level-1) Exam. The exam is designed to test the knowledge and skills of the MuleSoft developers in developing and deploying applications using MuleSoft Anypoint Platform. The MCD-Level-1 Dumps Questions cover topics such as API design, creating and debugging Mule applications, and deploying applications to MuleSoft Anypoint Platform. The dumps questions include multiple choice, true/false, and drag-and-drop questions designed to assess the candidate’s knowledge and skills in developing and deploying applications. The questions are designed to help the candidate understand the concepts and technologies related to MuleSoft and prepare for the MCD-Level-1 Exam.

    Visit Page: https://www.examsleader.com/MCD-Level-1-exam.html

  2. Hello everyone, I think it is always important to keep up with the times. When creating digital products with Voypost, always consider the customer as the focal point of your attention. Understanding their concerns, pain areas, and preferences will lead to solutions that address their needs completely. Conduct extensive research on the market and receive feedback from potential users to improve your product and make it relevant and practical.

  3. Enjoy only the most effective products from https://elvasallnaturals.com/ to take care of your body to the fullest. The excellent composition, which is 100% natural, will help you to take care of everything about your body to the full. It’s also worth noting that because of the recyclable packaging, you can also support the planet and make it a little cleaner if you start from yourself.

  4. Trenbolone is a powerful anabolic steroid that is widely used by bodybuilders and athletes in the US. Despite its effectiveness in building muscle mass and strength, trenbolone can also have serious side effects if not used properly. It is important for individuals considering the use of trenbolone in the US to consult with a healthcare professional and understand the risks associated with this steroid. Link: https://basicstero.ws/trenbolone

  5. When I’m a student in the United States, I earned my pocket money by participating in customer satisfaction surveys. Also, I got a $25 Gift Card & $75 of worth Free Hoagies & baskets from the Wawa Store after finishing the MyWawaVisit Survey at the official survey page https://www.mywawavisit.one/. the United States students and residents don’t miss the chance to win free gift card from Wawa Store by taking the My Wawa Visit Survey.

  6. L’un des avantages de faire appel à un service de réparation de sécheuse professionnel est que l’expertise qu’il apporte est inégalée. Ces professionnels ont une connaissance approfondie des différents appareils et peuvent rapidement diagnostiquer le problème. Cela permet non seulement de gagner du temps, mais aussi de s’assurer que le problème est résolu correctement.

  7. I just wanted to share my recent experience with professional plumbing and drain services I found here https://drainexpress.ca/experience-the-benefits-of-drain-express-for-all-your-backflow-plumbing-needs/ The plumber who came over was incredibly knowledgeable and friendly. He quickly diagnosed the problem – backflow issues due to a clogged drain. He explained that backflow can lead to contamination of the clean water supply with wastewater, which is not only gross but also a health hazard.

  8. I’ve struggled with chronic health issues for years, and traditional medicine just wasn’t cutting it. That’s when I stumbled upon Lody Health Klinik https://lodyhealth.com/ From the moment I walked in, I knew I was in the right place. Their team of experts took the time to understand my unique needs and crafted a personalized treatment plan just for me.

  9. This passage is very interesting and provides a lot of useful information about the development of ethnic restaurants in the US, as well as how these restaurants choose their locations where am i.

  10. The ISIS Consortium stands https://isisconsortium.org/ at the forefront of ocean research, focusing on the vital role of iron in mitigating atmospheric carbon dioxide. Through meticulous experiments and global adherence to standards, they deepen our understanding of ocean ecosystems, contributing to climate regulation. Join them in responsibly shaping a healthier planet.

  11. I think how consumers perceptions affect ethnic restaurants location patterns has to do with some myths surrounding cultures. They would rather accept things like 12zodiacsigns than these

  12. The WalgreensListens Survey, commonly known as the Walgreens consumer Satisfaction Survey, is primarily designed to gather consumer feedback about the goods and services they receive from its locations. You must go to the official Walgreenslistens.com website in order to finish the survey. WalgreensListens

  13. Decentralized exchange or DeFi Exchange in short means “decentralized tax exchange”. These types of exchanges work based on blockchain technology and artificial intelligence and operate without the need for central intermediaries or central servers.
    Decentralized exchanges allow users to trade directly with each other and exchange their cryptocurrencies, بهترین صرافی غیر متمرکز برای ایرانی ها without the need to trust a specific legal entity or the integrity of a central server. These exchanges are often built on the basis of artificial intelligence and smart contracts thatThey enable transactions and exchanges without the need for intermediaries.
    The main advantage of decentralized exchanges is that they provide users with higher security, as their information and assets are publicly available and monitored by the blockchain network. Also, these exchanges often have lower transaction feesprovide and increase access to global markets. However, it should be noted that decentralized exchanges still face some challenges such as technical, security and support flaws that need to be addressed.

Post Your Comment