facebook pixel
Skip to Main Content
Boston University School of Law

  • Academics
  • Admissions & Aid
  • Faculty & Research
Search
  • Current Students
  • Faculty & Staff
  • Alumni
  • Employers
  • Journalists
Search
  • Academics
    • Academic Enrichment Program
    • Find Degrees and Programs
    • Explore Your Options
    • Study Abroad
    • Academic Calendar
  • Admissions & Aid
    • JD Admissions
    • Graduate Admissions
    • Tuition & Fees
    • Financial Aid
    • Visits & Tours
  • Faculty & Research
    • Faculty Profiles
    • Activities & Engagements
    • Centers & Institutes
    • Faculty Resources
  • Experiential Learning
    • Clinics & Practicums
    • Externship Programs
    • Simulation Courses
    • Law Journals
    • Moot Court
  • Careers & Professional Development
    • Judicial Clerkship Program
    • Career Advising for Graduate Students
    • Employment Statistics
    • Legal Career Paths
    • Public Service Programs
  • Student Life
    • Law Student Well-Being
    • Law Student Organizations
    • Boston Legal Landscape
  • Law Libraries
    • About the Libraries
    • A-Z Database List
    • Institutional Repository
  • About BU Law
    • Offices & Services
    • Meet the Dean
    • Diversity, Equity & Inclusion
    • Visit Campus
  • News & Stories
    • All Stories
    • BU Law in the Media
    • BU Law News
    • Collections
    • Past Issues of The Record

Want to Support BU Law?Learn how you can give back


Latest Stories From The Record

Research

Alumni Giving Supports Students’ In-Depth Research with BU Law Faculty

Read more
Healthcare

From the ICU to BU Law

Read more
LLM in American Law

Returning to Where It All Began

Read more
Student Life

Involved and Uplifted

Read more
The Record
News & Stories from BU Law
  • Issues
  • All Stories

Legalize, Tax, and Regulate Marijuana?

Jay Wexler discusses the Massachusetts Marijuana Legalization Initiative—Question 4 on the Massachusetts ballot.

Faculty Q&AOn November 8, voters in Massachusetts will decide on four ballot initiatives. Among them is the Massachusetts Marijuana Legalization Initiative or, Question 4. The question relates to the legalization of marijuana for medical and recreational use. Voters in four other states, California, Nevada, Arizona, and Maine, will weigh in on similar ballot measures. Professor of Law Jay Wexler, who will teach a seminar on the Law & Regulation of Cannabis in Spring 2017, answered our questions about the proposed Massachusetts statute.

Q What does Question 4 on the Massachusetts ballot propose?

A Question 4 is a full statute, entitled “The Regulation and Taxation of Marijuana Act.” The statute includes a lot of details, but most importantly, it would: (1) legalize the possession of small amounts of marijuana and the growing of fewer than six plants for personal use; (2) create an agency known as the Cannabis Control Commission that would promulgate regulations governing the licensing of marijuana establishments; and (3) provide for an additional 3.75 percent sales tax on the sale of marijuana products, with cities and towns having the option of adding up to an additional 2 percent on top of that.

Jay Wexler quoteHow is marijuana currently regulated in Mass.? How will that change if question 4 passes?

Marijuana possession, manufacture, and distribution has historically been illegal in Massachusetts. In 2008, possession of small amounts of marijuana was decriminalized and is now punishable only by a civil fine. In 2012, Massachusetts legalized the use of marijuana to treat certain medical conditions; patients must obtain a registration card to purchase marijuana for medical purposes. If Question 4 passes, small amounts of marijuana may be purchased and possessed for recreational purposes as well as medical ones, and such possession will not be punishable in any way, including by civil fine.

What measures will be put in place to ensure the age limit is enforced?

The statute very clearly provides that possession of marijuana would be legal only for those 21 years of age and older, and it also makes clear that the knowing transfer of marijuana or marijuana accessories to those under 21 years of age will remain illegal. The statute specifically authorizes the Cannabis Control Commission to adopt regulations “to prevent the sale of marijuana and marijuana products to persons under 21 years of age.”

How does Question 4 compare to other state laws legalizing and regulating the use of marijuana?

If Question 4 passes, Massachusetts would become fairly similar in how it treats marijuana as other states that have legalized recreational use of the drug, namely Colorado, Washington, Oregon, Alaska, and the District of Columbia. The 3.75 percent tax rate specified by Question 4, however, is significantly lower than the tax rate in some of these other states. The District of Columbia is somewhat anomalous, in that while possession of small amounts of marijuana is legal in the District, selling marijuana remains illegal.

How do these laws conflict (or not) with federal law?

This is the real rub. Marijuana possession, manufacture, and distribution remain illegal under federal law. The US Justice Department has issued guidelines that indicate it will focus its enforcement efforts on certain types of marijuana-related conduct that threaten federal values. Although this guidance suggests that the federal government will typically not attempt to enforce federal law against small users and distributors, the guidance is non-binding and subject to change at any moment. Even with the guidance, moreover, the fact that marijuana remains illegal under federal law has enormous impacts on the marijuana industry in states that have legalized it for medical or recreational use. For instance, banks have been largely unwilling to deal with marijuana-related businesses for fear of violating federal laws on money laundering and the like; as a result, the marijuana industry is largely cash-based. Federal tax law also prohibits the deduction of most business-related expenses related to marijuana, thus rendering the effective tax rates of marijuana business far higher than similar businesses in other industries. Federal trademark law and bankruptcy law is also inapplicable to marijuana businesses as a result of continuing federal prohibition.

Explore Related Topics:

  • Cannabis Law
  • Share this story

Share

Legalize, Tax, and Regulate Marijuana?

Share this:

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn
  • Issues
  • All Stories
  • About & Contact

More about School of Law

Also See

  • ABA Required Disclosures
  • Licensing Disclosures
  • Statement of Nondiscrimination

Contact Us

  • JD Admissions
  • LLM & Graduate Admissions
  • Offices & Services
  • Faculty & Staff Directory
  • Instagram
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
© 2025 Boston University. All rights reserved. www.bu.edu
  • Current Students
  • Faculty & Staff
  • Alumni
  • Employers
  • Journalists
Search
Boston University

Boston University School of Law
765 Commonwealth Avenue Boston, MA 02215

  • © Boston University
  • Privacy Statement
  • Accessibility
  • Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA)
Boston University Masterplate