Skip to Main Content
Boston University
  • University Publications

    • Bostonia
    • BU-Today
    • The Brink
Other Publications
BU-Today
  • Sections
News, Opinion, Community

What drove Harriet Miers to withdraw?

Barnett, Zelizer, Roberts weigh in

President Bush’s Supreme Court nominee Harriet Miers, who was tapped to replace Justice Sandra Day O’Connor, withdrew her nomination yesterday amid criticism from both Democrats and Republicans and questions from senators and the media about her level of qualification. Miers, Bush’s top legal advisor, says she withdrew because releasing the White House documents requested by the Senate confirmation committee would jeopardize the confidential relationship between president and advisor. Miers has never been a judge. BU Today asked three BU professors to weigh in on the forces that drove her to withdraw and its possible effects on the political future of the Bush administration.

Randy Barnett, Austin B. Fletcher Professor of Law, School of Law, and senior fellow at the Cato Institute, who has argued cases before the U.S. Supreme Court:

“Like the demise of Dan Rather, the withdrawal of Harriet Miers’ nomination is a tribute to the power of the new media — especially the blogs — where information and opinions were swiftly exchanged, leading to a consensus among knowledgeable persons of all political views as to her lack of qualifications. Once this conclusion could not credibly be contested, the President made the right decision to accept her resignation. To his credit, the President acted more rapidly than did CBS.”

CAS History Professor Julian Zelizer, a political historian and author of On Capitol Hill: The Struggle to Reform Congress and Its Consequences, 1945–2000 (2004):

“When a president nominates someone for the Supreme Court who does not have an enthusiastic constituency behind them, events can go one of two ways. The person can divide the opposition and sail through the hearings. Otherwise, the person can draw so much opposition, from a variety of sources, that it creates an intense coalition of strange bedfellows that destroys the confirmation. In this case, Harriet Miers angered the right and the left, thereby adding to a disastrous week for an imperiled president.

“Today Harriet Miers joins a long list of failed nominees, such as Robert Bork, Douglas Ginsburg, Harold Carswell, and many others, that dates back to the withdrawal of William Patterson on February 28, 1793. In the past, failed nominations become explosive material for opponents to criticize broader problems with a presidential administration. In this case, the failed nomination of Harriet Miers will play into two central charges — in the post-Katrina and post–CIA leak world — that this is an administration plagued by incompetence and cronyism.”

Dana Robert, Truman Collins Professor of World Mission, School of Theology:

“Harriet Miers’ personal religious faith became an issue because she is a woman. Conservatives needed the assurance that she was virtuous and pious enough to be trustworthy — i.e., not a feminist liberal in disguise. Liberals worried that as a woman and an evangelical Christian, she would be unable to separate her personal, spiritual, and emotional side from her professional obligations. If she had been a man, people would have assumed her capable of taking professional distance from her personal faith. But because she is a woman, and we have an intensely patriarchal political culture, people questioned her intellectual integrity. The way her nomination was handled is a blow to every professional woman in this country, especially those like Miers who sacrificed the possibility of family life in order to have a career in a ‘man’s world.’”

Explore Related Topics:

  • Faculty
  • Global
  • Share this story

Share

What drove Harriet Miers to withdraw?

Share

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Reddit
  • LinkedIn
  • Email
  • Print

Latest from BU Today

  • Watch Now

    Video: Boba Showdown, Round Two

  • University News

    As BU Launches Inquiry into Center for Antiracist Research, Interim President Freeman Explains Goal and Reasoning

  • University News

    Six Tips for Getting the Most Out of Blackboard Ally

  • Cybersecurity

    Three Essential Cybersecurity Tips for Students

  • Things-To-Do

    Getting to Know Your Neighborhood: Newbury Street

  • Student Life

    Lobster Night, One of BU Dining’s Most Popular Events, Is Tonight

  • Things-to-do

    The Weekender: September 21 to 24

  • Campus & Facilities

    Buzz, Buzz: BU Creates a New Pollinator Garden

  • Mental Health

    Showing Up for My Wellbeing: A Self-Reflection on How I Manage My Personal Wellness at Boston University

  • Literature

    Booker Prize–Winning Author Ben Okri to Deliver Ha Jin Lecture Tonight

  • Arts & Culture

    In Huntington Theatre Company’s Prayer for the French Republic, BU Alum and Current Student Play Same Character, 70 Years Apart

  • Campus & Facilities

    14 BU Construction Projects, from Updated Classrooms to a New Robotics Space to Fresh Paint and Carpeting

  • University News

    BU Will Offer COVID Vaccine Boosters to Students, Faculty, and Staff

  • RECIPE SERIES

    Easy Vegetable Quiche

  • Campus Safety

    Do You Think Your Drink Was Spiked? How to Recognize the Symptoms and Take the Right Steps

  • Center for Computing & Data Sciences

    BU Faculty of Computing & Data Sciences Grows by Four

  • Watch Now

    Video: Stress ReLeaf: Weekly Tea Workshop Offers a Place for Students to Relax, Unwind

  • Building Relationships

    25 Ways to Make Friends at BU

  • Government & Law

    Does Impeachment Mean Anything Anymore?

  • DEAN OF STUDENTS

    Dean of Students Jason Campbell-Foster Is Rarely at His Desk. And That’s How He Likes It

Section navigation

  • Sections
  • Must Reads
  • Videos
  • Series
  • Close-ups
  • Archives
  • About + Contact
Get Our Email

Explore Our Publications

Bostonia

Boston University’s Alumni Magazine

BU-Today

News, Opinion, Community

The Brink

Pioneering Research from Boston University

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Youtube
  • LinkedIn
  • Instagram
  • Weibo
  • TikTok
© Boston University. All rights reserved. www.bu.edu
© 2023 Trustees of Boston UniversityPrivacy StatementAccessibility
Boston University
Notice of Non-Discrimination: Boston University policy prohibits discrimination against any individual on the basis of race, color, natural or protective hairstyle, religion, sex, age, national origin, physical or mental disability, sexual orientation, gender identity, genetic information, military service, pregnancy or pregnancy-related condition, or because of marital, parental, or veteran status, and acts in conformity with all applicable state and federal laws. This policy extends to all rights, privileges, programs and activities, including admissions, financial assistance, educational and athletic programs, housing, employment, compensation, employee benefits, and the providing of, or access to, University services or facilities. See BU’s Equal Opportunity/Affirmative Action Policy.
Search
Boston University Masterplate
loading Cancel
Post was not sent - check your email addresses!
Email check failed, please try again
Sorry, your blog cannot share posts by email.
What drove Harriet Miers to withdraw?
0
share this