Data Security in Human Subjects Research
Purpose
The purpose of this guidance is to provide general considerations for BU researchers on managing data security in human subjects research, reviewed and approved by the Charles River Campus (CRC) IRB.
Data Security Requirements
University Data is information generated by, owned by, or otherwise in the possession of Boston University that is related to the University’s activities, including research data. University Research data is subject to BU’s Data Protection Standards. Under the University’s Data Classification Policy, data are categorized as Public, Internal, Confidential or Restricted Use with varying standards for protection that must be applied.
Researcher Responsibilities
- Researchers who collect or utilize research data are responsible for accessing, storing, transferring and processing data on systems that have appropriate security measures for the classification of data being used.
- Researchers should itemize the kinds of data being collected and/or utilized as part of their research and determine what level of security is needed for their data.
- Researchers should consult with IS&T and/or their local IT support groups to determine the best way to access, store, and use their data, particularly for data categorized as Confidential or Restricted Use.
Examples of Research Data and Corresponding BU Data Classification
- While most research data at BU are not subject to the HIPAA Privacy Rule, the HIPAA de-identification standard (removal of 18 data elements – e.g. email addresses, phone numbers, dates of birth, dates of treatment, cities, zip codes, etc.) is still the gold standard. When data are de-identified in in the manner of the HIPAA Privacy Rule, there are no specific requirements for platform-use at BU, as the data are categorized as Public.
- Similarly under the HIPAA Privacy Rule are data that are considered Limited Data Sets, meaning, they contain protected health information* that excludes direct identifiers, effectively anonymizing data by limiting the elements to dates, cities and zip codes. When human subject health information is anonymized in the manner of the HIPAA Limited Data Set standard, the BU Shared Computing Cluster can be used, since the data is categorized as Confidential.
- The research is health-related* and includes some personally identifiable information such as email addresses, phone numbers, facial images in pictures/videos (even if there is no name associated with the image), etc. making the data categorized as Restricted Use. At BU, several services are cleared for Restricted Use data, including the following:
- BU Restricted Use network drive (nas-RU1 or BUMC Y Drive);
- BU Office365 apps, such as SharePoint, OneDrive, Teams, and Bookings With Me;
- BU REDCap advanced survey tool
- BU Qualtrics survey tool
Considerations for IRB Applications
As part of the IRB’s role in protecting the rights and welfare of human subjects, researchers must identify which electronic platforms, data transfer methods, data/document storage plans etc. are being proposed in the research. This information can be documented in the Confidentiality of Data section of the IRB application. BU’s InfoSec has provided sample language that can be used in the Confidentiality of Data section of the IRB application.
Researchers are encouraged to consult with IS&T on the use of third-party data collection, storage or analysis applications proposed for their research. Providing the IRB with correspondence with BU IS&T verifying the appropriateness of novel or third-party applications can facilitate the IRB’s review of the Confidentiality of Data plan.
FAQs, Answered By BU’s Information Security
Data Storage & Security Questions
- I have completed my research study and need to save the data for 7 years. How do I do this?
- I want to store my data on a password-protected computer that will be stored in a locked office, but someone mentioned BU requires encryption as well. Is that true?
- When can I use BU Google Apps?
The purpose of the 7-year retention requirement for research data is both to (1) comply with a federal requirement and (2) enable the University to respond to litigation/legal/subpoena requests. As such, the data should be maintained at BU. BU’s IS&T offers several storage options, including BU network drive.
Yes, the BU Data Protection Standards require encryption for all non-Public data, including Confidential and Restricted Use data, even when a computer or device is stored in a locked office.
Generally, researchers should be using BU managed computers that come with encryption, patch management, and advanced threat protection that will alert BU Information Security if an attack is suspected. Students can use personal computers to work with anonymized data on the Shared Computing Cluster or another location, but data should never be stored on a personal computer.
If the data is identifiable but not health related (e.g., decision making, texts/day), BU Google Apps can be used. And if the data is anonymized and not considered a HIPAA Limited Data Set from a HIPAA Covered Entity, subject to a data use agreement (DUA), BU Google Apps can be used. For more information on DUAs, please contact BU’s Office of Industry Engagement.
Data Transfer & Communications Questions
- As part of my field research, I am recording interviews using my cell phone and uploading to the BU networked shared drive. However, my collaborators do not have access to the BU networked shared drive and wish to text me audio recordings of interviews they have collected. Is there a better way to handle this?
- What platforms can I use to share health-related* information?
- BU desk phone or BU cell phone (texting explained below)
- BU Cisco softphone app with purchased phone number or used to extend a BU desk phone to a personal device https://www.bu.edu/tech/services/cccs/phone/linesequip/softphone/
- BU Microsoft SharePoint or OneDrive can be used to share a folder of files or individual files with BU and non-BU collaborators https://www.bu.edu/tech/support/information-security/security-for-everyone/share-sharepoint-files-or-folders/
- BU Microsoft Teams and Zoom chat function can be used to share identifiable health information
- BU REDCap advanced survey tool can be used for sending participant information (such as videos) as well as typical research needs (e.g., consent forms, surveys, reminders, etc.) via email or text (using Twilio).
- What platforms can I use to send appointment updates with no disclosure of health-related information?
- BU Microsoft Outlook can be used for scheduling and sending Teams and Zoom invites.
- BU cell phones can be used by researchers who are not part of a BU HIPAA component to text appointment information and reminders.
- Google Voice can be used by researchers who are not part of a BU HIPAA Component to send and receive text messages for scheduling and appointment reminders. HIPAA Components cannot send text messages because cell phone carriers do not sign HIPAA Business Associate Agreements. Cell phone carriers become a business associate when they store text messages, to or from patients.
- WhatsApp, Gmail Chat, or iMessage can be used for appointment setting or updating – by researchers who are not part of at BU HIPAA Component – but cannot be used to request or send health-related information. WhatsApp is a Meta product and while the messages are sent with encryption, Meta has access to information on phones that use their products. Companies such as Meta, Google, and Apple use and share information about their users. For this reason, a study should not require use of these apps unless the Consent outlines how data is collected and shared by the company with third party companies.
Consult with IS&T for the latest recommendations, however, most recently they have recommended researchers use BU Office365 SharePoint or OneDrive folders for data transfer. The SharePoint or OneDrive folder can be shared with collaborators using their professional email account (personal addresses should not be used). Collaborators can download the SharePoint, Teams, or OneDrive app to their phones.
To avoid study staff using their personal cell phones to call research participants, BU has several recommended options:
Consent Participants Remotely
- Can I use BU REDCap for electronic consent that will contain questions about health-related matters?
- Yes, and we have shared BUMC IRB and CRC IRB guidance on setting up e-consent here: https://www.bumc.bu.edu/crro/resources-library/e-consent-tools-and-guidance/
- Please note, BU’s REDCap can be used for FDA (21 C.F.R. Part 11) compliance, but additional requirements need to be implemented. Send an email to rchelp@bu.edu to start the process.
- I would like to use Google Forms to consent participants, is that ok?
If you are not conducting health-related* research, Google Forms may be OK to use. However, if you are conducting health-related research we suggest using BU Adobe Sign or BU Microsoft Forms to share a Consent form. Another Restricted Use/HIPAA compliant option is to collect participant consent using BU Qualtrics.
Additional Resources
- BU InfoSec for Researchers page
- Data Storage Options offered by IS&T
- BU HIPAA Policy outlines how Bu Covered Components must protect HIPAA data
*Health-related information is very broad, including stress or anxiety related to school, but does not typically include social engagement, decision making, number of texts sent per day, or educational practices, strategies, or effectiveness.