Volume 90, Number 2 – April 2010
CONTENTS
SYMPOSIUM
JUSTICE FOR HEDGEHOGS: A CONFERENCE ON RONALD DWORKIN’S FORTHCOMING BOOK
Editors’ Foreword
Page 465
KEYNOTE ADDRESS
Justice for Hedgehogs
Ronald Dworkin
Page 469
PANEL I: TRUTH AND METAETHICS
The Possibility of Metaethics
Russ Shafer-Landau
Page 479
Moral Skepticism for Foxes
Daniel Star
Page 497
Dworkin on External Skepticism
Michael Smith
Page 509
A Historian’s Comment on the Metaethics Panel at Justice for Hedgehogs: A Conference on Ronald Dworkin’s Forthcoming Book
Aaron Garrett
Page 521
PANEL II: INTERPRETATION
Two Takes on Truth in Normative Discourse
Benjamin C. Zipursky
Page 525
Is Moral Reasoning Conceptual Interpretation?
Richard H. Fallon, Jr.
Page 535
The Unity of Interpretation
Lawrence B. Solum
Page 551
Material Rights, Underenforcement, and the Adjudication Thesis
Lawrence Sager
Page 579
Moral Limits of Dworkin’s Theory of Law and Legal Interpretation
David Lyons
Page 595
PANEL III: ETHICS AND FREE WILL
Varieties of Responsibility
T.M. Scanlon
Page 603
Responsibility and Free Will in Dworkin’s Justice for Hedgehogs
Robert Kane
Page 611
Mental Disorders and the “System of Judgmental Responsibility”
Anita L. Allen
Page 621
Dworkin’s Living Well and the Well-Being Revolution
Christine Jolls
Page 641
Dworkin on Ethics and Freewill: Comments and Questions
Amartya Sen
Page 657
PANEL IV: MORALITY: AID, HARM, AND OBLIGATION
Dignity and Global Duty
Kwame Anthony Appiah
Page 661
Liberal Responsibility: A Comment on Justice for Hedgehogs
John C.P. Goldberg
Page 677
What Ethical Responsibility Cannot Justify: A Discussion of Ronald Dworkin’s Justice for Hedgehogs
F.M. Kamm
Page 691
Dworkin’s Two Principles of Dignity: An Unsatisfactory Nonconsequentialist Account of Interpersonal Moral Duties
Kenneth W. Simons
Page 715
State Legitimacy and Political Obligation in Justice for Hedgehogs: The Radical Potential of Dworkinian Dignity
Susanne Sreedhar & Candice Delmas
Page 737
PANEL V: POLITICS AND JUSTICE I
In Hedgehog Solidarity
C. Edwin Baker
Page 759
Rights, Harms, and Duties: A Response to Justice for Hedgehogs
Robin West
Page 819
Taking Responsibilities as Well as Rights Seriously
James E. Fleming
Page 839
Dworkin’s “One-System” Conception of Law and Morality
Hugh Baxter
Page 857
Justice and Elegance for Hedgehogs – In Life, Law, and Literature
Linda C. McClain
Page 863
In Favor of Foxes: Pluralism as Fact and Aid to the Pursuit of Justice
Martha Minow & Joseph William Singer
Page 903
PANEL VI: POLITICS AND JUSTICE II
Equality of Resources, Market Luck, and the Justification of Adjusted Market Distributions
Samuel Freeman
Page 921
Foxy Freedom?
Frank I. Michelman
Page 949
Human Rights for Hedgehogs?: Global Value Pluralism, International Law, and Some Reservations of the Fox
Robert D. Sloane
Page 975
Procedure, Participation, Rights
Robert G. Bone
Page 1011
Against Majoritarianism: Democratic Values and Institutional Design
Stephen Macedo
Page 1029
A Majority in the Lifeboat
Jeremy Waldron
Page 1043
RESPONSE
Response
Ronald Dworkin
Page 1059