Bostonia is published in print three times a year and updated weekly on the web.
As director of the Nutrition & Weight Management Center at Boston Medical Center, Caroline Apovian is immersed in the science of dieting and weight management. Now the School of Medicine professor of medicine and pediatrics has written The Overnight Diet: The Proven Plan for Fast, Permanent Weight Loss (Grand Central Life & Style, 2013), with Frances Sharpe, advocating for a high-protein, vegetable-rich, “fat-burning” diet that she says can help people lose as many as nine pounds in the first week. Bostonia asked Apovian about what makes this diet different, why protein is so important, and whether it’s really possible to lose weight while sleeping.
Apovian: This diet combines two approaches for weight loss and does not eliminate any foods. The one-day power-up is based on intermittent fasting and is translated into a day of drinking calories in the form of smoothies, which combine protein and fruits and vegetables; the second method is a protein-rich program to build muscle mass and prevent the shrinking muscle syndrome, plus stay full all day.
We have realized that as you get older, you need more protein, not less—the body loses one percent muscle mass per year after the age of 30. As you lose muscle, your metabolic rate decreases and you cannot eat as much as you used to— therefore you gain weight.
You need eight hours of sleep per night. If you do not get that, the gut hormones, which produce hunger, are secreted in higher quantities, and you become ravenous. But you can lose two pounds overnight on the power-up first day of the diet. It is mainly water and salt, but you still feel great the next day, and revved up for the rest of the week.
The power-up day consists of three delicious smoothies and you drink those calories—they fill you up and you get enough protein to feed your muscles. The rest of the week you are on the six-day fuel-up with protein, fruits, veggies, and lean carbs.
All you need to build muscle and create afterburn, which means your metabolism stays up long after you stop exercising, is 21 minutes, 4 days per week. The exercises are short bursts of workload and keep your metabolism revved up.
As you eat less carbohydrates and sugars, less insulin is produced by the pancreas. Insulin causes salt and water retention, so less insulin means you excrete all that water and salt.
Keep on the same plan of one-day power-up and six-day fuel-up and you will keep the weight off. No foods are off-limits.
Fad? I don’t think so. This diet was created from the results of scientific research in preventing muscle loss while eating fruits and vegetables to prevent cancer or heart disease. It was created based on the Protein Sparing Modified Fast (PSMF), which was developed in the 1970s and proven to spare lean muscle mass if given to patients who are critically ill in ICU settings. I added fruits and vegetables to PSMF and created a plan that anyone can do in daily life.
As you lose muscle, your metabolic rate decreases and you cannot eat as much as you used to—therefore you gain weight.
As a diabetic, I’ve been warned about episodes of low-sugar, so a nutritionist said not to lose more than one pound per week.
I also have some auto immune disorders like hashimoto syndrome so I know I have a general systemic problem with inflamation. Clearly I will have to purchase your book.
Regarding smoothies, is it possible to do what other diets have suggested – have a protein shake for one meal a day (i.e. lunch), I only have oatmeal for breakfast, and I have a protein, i.e. chicken, a steamed vegetable and no carbs for dinner.
I could add a low amount of carbs for dinner, i.e. half a medium-sized potato to fill me up – but I haven’t been doing this to date. I am always very hungry late evening and so I go to bed early.
So, question: Is your diet good for diabetics, or should I make my adjustments as mentioned above?
My question is about the serving size of some of the dairy products. 1 cup is a serving of yogurt, milk, cottage cheese, etc, but what is the serving of low fat mozzarella cheese? 1 cup or 1 oz ?
Dear Jill,
Low-fat mozzarella cheese is one ounce. Sorry about the discrepancy.
Make sure all of your dairy is low-fat dairy.
Dear Professor Apovian,
RE: “Fast, Permanent” Weight Loss, Published in Bostonia, Summer 2013, Page 8
We are an over 65 couple, and received your Bostonia article from our daughter, who is a BU alumna. Thank you for your offer to answer questions about your diet.
Here are ours:
1) Do you recommend different diets for life extension vs. weight loss (only one of us seeks weight loss);
2) Protein in foods usually comes with lots of fat, and sometimes sugar, both of which we’re warned about as unhealthy (calories at 9 cal/gm for fats, Gary Taubes for sugar). What protein sources do you recommend? The best we can come up with is turkey and soybeans (edamame);
3) Please comment on the issue of managing diet for optimum sleep, (e.g., for older folks, the need for night urination can compromise sleep);
4) Please comment on burst workload exercise and joint health in older people. Many workout programs focus only on aerobics and muscle strength, and say nothing about possible joint damage;
5) What do you define as a lean carbohydrates? Lean usually means little fat, and carbohydrates contain no fats. Is it an issue of sugars versus starches?
Thank you for any information you can provide.
Best regards,
John Stiles
Dear John,
For life extension, lots of fruits and vegetables and lean protein –
once you are a lean body weight you can add whole grains.
Protein sources: yes, turkey, but also fish and chicken eggs (nothing
wrong with eggs), tofu, and other plant proteins as well – skim milk
products unless you cannot tolerate them.
Diet for optimum sleep – take in some milk, with a little carbohydrate
and tart cherry juice before bed – gets melatonin into your system and
then the tryptophan in the protein from the milk will get in later to
keep you asleep.
For older people – knees love running – running is good for knees but
only if you always run. So if you do not, start slowly. Elliptical is
always good; swimming is excellent for the body without hurting joints. And always lift weights for muscle strength.
Also, lean carbs are high-fiber carbs–correct!
Hi!
Question for you….
I have your book and I wonder if the diet will still produce results if I do the “power-up” day once a week and the rest of the week I
do not follow your exact diet but instead, count calories, avoid carbohydrates, and eat fruits, veggies, and proteins. In other words,
follow a low calorie diet and then “power-up” one day a week. I just don’t like having to eat a certain menu.
I exercise regularly.
Is there no point in a power up day if I don’t follow your plan the other 6 days?
Thanks!
Nancy
Nancy,
You describe the 6 days I am recommending, so go right ahead! Sounds the same as my plan. You will lose weight. With your exercise, make sure you are also lifting weights to build muscle mass.
Good luck.
I am interested in this notion that we need more protein as we age. I understand that most Americans get plenty of protein but are low in fiber from plants. I wonder if the current charts are correct.
I’m 5’3″, 61 years old, and weigh 128. I hike at least 4 days a week first thing in the morning approximately 3- 4 miles.
Thanks for your thoughts.
The protein recommendations are based on studies done in young lean people. We are conducting a study right now to prove that older people with sarcopenia need more protein to maintain muscle mass.
I would take in 1.5 gm of protein per kg of body weight.
I would also lift weights to build muscle mass and you will get the protein you need from the OVERNIGHT diet to build that muscle mass.
Good luck!
Caroline Apovian
Dear Caroline,
I am 53 y.o. male, 6 ft, 206 pounds.
I have been an Atkins user for several years.
My questions:
-How does your one-day power up compare to the Atkins induction phase, and could one stay on the one-day power up regime for longer than one day and achieve quicker results?
-Is there any harm in too much protein intake for my age?
-How many in your population study lost 9lbs, and the percentage that lost less, how much less?
-Is your book easy to read and adhere to the directions?
I look forward to finding it at my local bookstore and giving it a shot towards my goal weight of 190.
Thank you for taking my question.
-Randy
(Kendra SMG’14)
Dear Randy
No harm in protein at 1.5 gm per kilo of body weight at any age, as long as your kidneys are healthy.
You can stay on the smoothie day for longer, but you have to be careful because it is about 800 kcalories per day, so it is like a very low-calorie diet – make sure you hydrate well.
The Atkins diet is very high in fat – this diet is not. That is the difference essentially between the two diets.
It is very easy to follow!
The reason why we stress taking in lots of protein is so that you do not develop sarcopenia which is the loss of muscle mass as you age. To replenish muscle however you also need to exercise and lift weights.
Good luck.
Dr. Apovian,
I am a dietitian in Oregon and am currently planning a weight-loss class for breast cancer survivors, BMI > 35. I was curious as to how many calories you would suggest that people take in the smoothies on the power-up day. Is there a maximum caloric level that you suggest for the other days? Are you looking at calories per kilo of IBW? Also, how many grams of protein per kilo of body weight are you basing protein needs on?
In addition, I was wondering if you have data showing reduction in biomarkers that are risk factors for cancer patients, following this diet. So many questions. I apologize, but such an interesting topic. I hope to get my group going in the fall and currently I am looking at the 5:2 fast diet, and also the Genesis approach from Manchester UK, a Dr. Michelle Harvie.
Thank you for your time and any information you would like to share.
Ally F. Gottfried, MFN, RD, LD,
Ally
I use 1.5 gm per kilo of body weight for the protein.
Max for the smoothie days should be about 800 kcal, and the 6 days should be about 1,200 to 1,500 and more for men
all in the book.
For inflammation I just published an article – look me up on PubMed published in METABOLISM showing decreases in inflammation on a low-carb vs low-fat diet.
Also, calorie intake for the smoothie day should be 800-1000 kcalories, and the calorie intake for the 6 days fuel up is roughly 1,200-1,500 kcal, but the point is not to have to count calories because you are taking in foods that give you satiety.
Caroline Apovian
I bought The Overnight Diet at the Barnes & Noble Bookstore in Kenmore Square, before I received Bostonia, so I was very excited to see your article. I have been on the diet for two weeks now and am having trouble with constipation and great pain on the morning of the second day of the 6-day fuel-up phase. I have a feeling that it’s all the bananas in the smoothies during the one-day power-up. (I have been using the banana latte, pina colada island, and enchanted blueberry. That’s a total of 4 bananas for the day.)
I also wonder if I need more whole grains in the fuel-up days. I am eating the right amount of fruits and vegetables, protein, fat, and dairy. Suggestions? I weigh 215 and am eating 13 oz of protein. I have quite an apple belly/used to be a pear. So far, I have not lost anything, only gone up and down. I include a copy of the log sheet I use for days 2-6. I write in what I ate in each category and the amount.
Loretta
Day 2
Breakfast
3-4 oz. protein
1 grain
1 dairy
1 c veggies
Fruit
2 tsp. fat
Snack
fruit or veggies
Lunch
4 oz protein
1 c starchy vegetable
Leafy greens
1 dairy
Snack
Fruit or veggies
Dinner
5 – 6 oz protein
2 grains
Veggies or fruits
2 tsp fat
1 dairy
Dessert
Dear Loretta,
I think you are right about needing more whole grains but this comes with more calories.
Stop taking in so many bananas – choose smoothies with no bananas.
Also take in some fiber in the form of flax seed and bran mixed with some oatmeal in the morning.
That should take care of constipation.
Best regards,
Caroline Apovian
I am a 61-year-old man, 5-feet-9.5-inches, 154 lbs, and suffer from rheumatoid arthritis, which is well controlled with medication. I exercise regularly for about an hour a day, mostly cardio (elliptical, lap swimming, erg), with some stretch and strengthen as well. My sense is, I do need to do more strength training, but haven’t got into that routine yet. Finally, I am vegetarian, although I do eat eggs. I would like to lose a little more weight (have lost about 25 lbs over the last 2-3 years, but am finding it difficult to lose more now), particularly around the waist, while building more muscle mass.
My questions are:
1. How much protein (in gms) should I be eating every day?
2. Does the timing of my protein intake matter, especially in relation to when I exercise?
3. How can I improve my sleep pattern? I frequently can sleep only 5 to 6 hours, especially when I have exercised in the evening (as I normally do. Because of my RA, I am stiffer in the morning and find it difficult to exercise at that time).
Your suggestions on how I can boost my protein intake as a vegetarian would be appreciated.
Thank you!
Dear Pankaj,
You should take in about 105 gm of protein according to your current weight which is 1.5 gm per kg of body weight.
Timing of protein does matter – your supplements if you choose to take them in should be taken in 15-20 minutes after working out.
Boosting protein with our physicians protein smoothie line would be a good addition to a vegetarian diet.
For sleep, try our sleepy time smoothie –
Also you can try tart cherry juice before bed which has a lot of melatonin.
Best regards
Caroline Apovian
Thank you!