Important Announcement

2 February, 2021 at 8:21 AM

Visit Back2BU for the latest updates and information on BU's response to COVID-19. Students can find additional information in the Undergraduate Student Guide and Graduate & Professional Student Guide.

Skip to Main Content
Boston University
  • University Publications

    • Bostonia
    • BU-Today
    • The Brink
Other Publications
BU-Today
  • Sections
News, Opinion, Community

First a Soldier: CAS Prof. Andrew Bacevich

Part one: A veteran’s thoughts on America’s power

April 4, 2007
  • Chris Berdik
Twitter Facebook
Andrew Bacevich, a CAS professor of international relations and a retired Army lieutenant colonel, was an early skeptic of the war in Iraq. Photo by John Goodman

In March 2003, as the Bush administration beat the drum for regime change in Iraq, pundits predicted a cakewalk military campaign, and Iraqi dissidents gave assurances that American soldiers would be greeted “with sweets and flowers.” Andrew Bacevich saw things differently. Writing in the Los Angeles Times, the College of Arts and Sciences professor of international relations offered this warning: “If, as seems probable, the effort encounters greater resistance than its architects imagine, our way of life may find itself tested in ways that will make the Vietnam War look like a mere blip in American history.”

Four years after the U.S.-led invasion of Iraq, Bacevich has even less hope for military victory. “Iraq is a train wreck,” he said in January. “There’s no putting the train back on track.” His early skepticism about transforming the Middle East through military might has turned to withering criticism of nearly every aspect of the war’s prosecution, and he’s making his case in opinion pieces, up to three a week, in major newspapers and periodicals, ranging from the conservative National Review to the Washington Post to the wonky World Policy Journal. He’s also quoted regularly on Iraq in major broadcast and print news media.

But Bacevich is no dove. Indeed, he defies easy categorization. A retired U.S. Army lieutenant colonel, he generally votes Republican and espouses conservative values. But he also disdains neoconservative foreign policy. Most of all, he doesn’t believe that America is uniquely enlightened or righteous or that it is capable of transforming more troubled regions of the world with military force.

As a Midwestern boy in the 1950s, a West Point–trained soldier in Vietnam, a graduate student, and a professor and opinion leader, he has never feared self-reflection, no matter what personal failings it reveals or what core beliefs it shakes. Likewise, he states in his direct military style, “With regard to how you behave in the world as a nation state, first know who you are.”

Awash in moral ambiguity

Bacevich’s foreign policy creed crystalized when he read The Irony of American History, written in 1952 by the Protestant theologian Reinhold Niebuhr. The book, which proposes that statecraft be guided by moral realism, changed the way Bacevich looked at America.

“There is a tendency,” he says, “to view realism in foreign policy as simply cynical, calculating, and absent any kind of moral values.” But, he says, Niebuhr exemplifies a realist tradition that is, in fact, guided by conscience and an awareness of one’s own moral flaws. “Niebuhr had a profound awareness that there is evil in the world that must be resisted. But he wrote that to imagine that you yourself are innocent as you exercise power to resist that evil is a formula for disaster.”

Bacevich assigns Niebuhr’s book to his students every year, and “if I could get Americans to read one book today, to help us illuminate the way forward,” he says, “that would be it.”

When he discusses America’s role in history and current world affairs, he speaks of events, policies, and conflicts awash in moral ambiguity. America is no devil, oppressing the world’s poor and downtrodden, in his view, but neither are we a nation of bright-eyed innocents leading freedom’s march around the world.

“If you take the long sweep of American history,” he says, “we didn’t complete that journey without getting a certain amount of blood on our hands.”

To believe otherwise, to subscribe to the idea of American exceptionalism, he says, is both “silly and dangerous” and often steers us into catastrophe. In the 1990s, when Bacevich was a professorial lecturer at the Johns Hopkins School of Advanced International Studies, he criticized the idealistic military interventions of President Bill Clinton in places like Somalia and Haiti. But more recently, he has attacked the mind-set of neoconservative pundits and Iraq war architects, who, he wrote in the Montreal Gazette, frame history as a perpetual conflict between freedom and a totalitarianism that appears “in an ever-changing guise,” from Nazism to Communism to “Islamofascism.”

After September 11, 2001, when members of the Bush administration began to push for transforming the Middle East by force of arms, Bacevich recalls, “it seemed to me that efforts on the part of the United States to remake others in our image had more often than not produced all kinds of unexpected consequences.” He cites America’s “liberation” of Cuba and the Philippines in the Spanish American War. “In both cases, the argument was that we were going to bring freedom to these poor, benighted, backward peoples,” he says. “And in both cases, the result was less than promised and in some respects simply ugly.”

His alternative: treat violent Islamic radicalism as a “dangerous, international criminal conspiracy,” one that “all nations should band together to thwart with a concerted, relentless police action.”

To the criticism that such a strategy is inadequate to the task and overly reactive and was the discredited approach of pre-9/11 terrorism fighters, Bacevich responds that previous failures were the result of poor implementation. “We need to work harder, get smarter, and invest more resources,” he says.

He acknowledges that America is not the first country to believe itself blessed with a special providence among nations, but he notes that the idea has particularly deep roots in American identity. The first reading for his Ideas in American Foreign Policy class is the sermon given in 1630 by John Winthrop, governor of the Massachusetts Bay Colony, in which he proclaimed, “We shall be as a city upon a hill, the eyes of all people are upon us,” an echo of the Sermon on the Mount.

Winthrop’s line has been repeated throughout the centuries by American leaders, including Presidents John F. Kennedy and Ronald Reagan. And when it comes to America’s response to September 11, Bacevich suspects that this belief in our innate righteousness as a nation has blinded us to the larger questions raised by the war on terrorism and the invasion of Iraq.

“Is a global war on terror the correct response to the threat that we identified on 9/11?” Bacevich asks. “Is it possible that the idea of a global war to change the way they live in the Middle East is a bad idea, one that, in fact, lies beyond our capability?”

See tomorrow’s BU Today for part two of “First a Soldier.”

This article appears in the spring 2007 edition of Bostonia.

Chris Berdik can be reached at cberdik@bu.edu.

Explore Related Topics:

  • Faculty
  • Global
  • Share this story

Share

First a Soldier: CAS Prof. Andrew Bacevich

Share

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Reddit
  • LinkedIn
  • Email
  • Print
  • Chris Berdik

    Chris Berdik Profile

Related Stories

  • U.S. Marines stand guard at Task Force Southwest military field in Shorab military camp of Helmand province, Afghanistan
    Voices & Opinion

    Professor Emeritus Andrew Bacevich Cofounds a Think Tank Promoting Diplomacy, Funded By Ideological Opposites George Soros and Charles Koch

    July 23, 2019
  • The Fall of the Berlin Wall, 1989.
    Books

    Andrew Bacevich on Winning the Cold War, Then Blowing the Cold Peace

    January 14, 2020
  • Portait of Ibram X. Kendi in a gray suit with his hands on a desk in front of him. Kendi is a leading historian and author of the bestselling 'How to be an Antiracist.'
    Accolades

    Ibram X. Kendi Awarded BU’s Andrew W. Mellon Professorship in the Humanities

    July 1, 2020
  • 1958 portrait of Julia Pratt in her office.
    Tributes

    Tributes: Julia C. Pratt, Andrew Dibner, George O. Zimmerman

    October 23, 2019
    Shared from
    Bostonia

Latest from BU Today

  • Student Life

    Students Gather Virtually to Share, Discuss How BU Handles Sexual Assault

  • Varsity Sports

    Women’s Basketball’s Katie Nelson on Team’s Historic Season

  • COVID-19 Vaccine

    How to Fight Vaccine Misinformation

  • Food & Dining

    10 Black-Owned Restaurants to Check Out in Boston

  • Black History Month

    Nine Movies, Podcasts, and Books to Check Out for Black History Month and Beyond

  • University News

    Jeffrey Hutter, Dean of BU’s Goldman School of Dental Medicine, to Retire

  • Voices & Opinion

    POV: An Open Letter to Doug Emhoff, the Second Gentleman of the United States

  • Public Health

    How Long Will It Take You to Conceive after Stopping Birth Control?

  • Earth & Environment

    Texas Deep Freeze Is a Reminder That Bad Weather Is Getting Worse

  • Safety

    BUPD Investigating Thefts, Lewd Exposure at South Campus Dorms

  • Public Health

    University Updates Mask-Wearing Guidance

  • Film & TV

    Schitt’s Creek Star Dan Levy Shares Memories of the Award-Winning Show with BU Students

  • Coronavirus

    Is Pro-Trump Bias Leading Some US Counties to Lowball COVID-19 Deaths?

  • Student Life

    Want Some Tips on Making Friends in College? Our Student Vlogger Has It Covered

  • Admissions

    University Extends Standardized Test Optional Policy for Another Year

  • COVID ON CAMPUS

    Weekly COVID Compliance Report: February 19

  • Varsity Sports

    BU Athletics Is Playing Black National Anthem before Many Home Games for Black History Month

  • Food & Dining

    Kenmore Square Favorite Eastern Standard Closes Permanently

  • Coronavirus

    WBUR Ramps Up COVID Coverage as Vaccine Rollout Increases

  • Arts & Culture

    Two Poets, Drawn by History, Headline Thursday’s Lowell Poetry Reading

Section navigation

  • Sections
  • Must Reads
  • Videos
  • Series
  • Close-ups
  • Archives
  • About + Contact
Get Our Email

Explore Our Publications

Bostonia

Boston University’s Alumni Magazine

BU-Today

News, Opinion, Community

The Brink

Pioneering Research from Boston University

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Youtube
  • Linked-In
© Boston University. All rights reserved. www.bu.edu
© 2021 Trustees of Boston UniversityPrivacy StatementAccessibility
Boston University
Notice of Non-Discrimination: Boston University policy prohibits discrimination against any individual on the basis of race, color, religion, sex, age, national origin, physical or mental disability, sexual orientation, gender identity, genetic information, military service, pregnancy or pregnancy-related condition, or because of marital, parental, or veteran status, and acts in conformity with all applicable state and federal laws. This policy extends to all rights, privileges, programs and activities, including admissions, financial assistance, educational and athletic programs, housing, employment, compensation, employee benefits, and the providing of, or access to, University services or facilities. See BU’s Equal Opportunity/Affirmative Action Policy.
Search
Boston University Masterplate
loading Cancel
Post was not sent - check your email addresses!
Email check failed, please try again
Sorry, your blog cannot share posts by email.
First a Soldier: CAS Prof. Andrew Bacevich
0
share this