Stretch Before Exercise? Not So Fast.
BU experts on how you should warm up
Once upon a time, stretching was to exercise what proposing is to marriage: an essential ritual that had to be done before the main event. Athletes of a certain age were warned to stretch their muscles before exerting themselves to avoid a debilitating pull or injury.
Recent studies caution people away from stretching before workouts, suggesting it actually impedes your body’s performance. According to this research, runners run more slowly, jumpers jump less high, and weight lifters lift more weakly by stretching, without significantly ensuring against injury during their exercise.
With the new semester well under way and (at least some) people still vowing to exercise as their New Year’s resolution, we asked three BU fitness experts to describe how they warm up before sweating, and what they’d advise others. Here are their answers.
James Camarinos, Ryan Center for Sports Medicine and Rehabilitation physical therapy center clinic manager
I recommend stretching after exercise or even at nonexercise times—for example, stretch in the middle of an eight-hour day sitting at your desk—instead of the typical stretch-before-you-work-out strategy that many employed for years. Stretching a muscle should be done when the muscle is short, meaning the length is not sufficient for the task that a person is trying to do. A person who competes in hurdles needs a long hamstring muscle to clear their leg over the hurdle; however, most typical runners with shorter strides will not need this, so endlessly stretching one’s hamstring to prep for a 10K might not get them far.
Most people stretch to loosen up. However, this would be much better accomplished with a more dynamic warm-up. Things like high knees, front kicks, back kicks (hit your glutes with your feet by bending your knee back), hip circles (roll your leg out and to the front with a bent knee), squats, lunges, or even lightly biking or elliptical will much better lengthen a muscle, but will do so with movement so as to increase the tissue temperature of the muscle and better prepare it for exercise.
Mike Lagomarsine, Fitness and Recreation Center director of fitness
The biggest issue is the confusion between flexibility training and warming up for exercise. Stretching, defined as gently bringing your joint to its end range of motion, is how you increase flexibility. So for someone looking to gain flexibility, I would recommend static stretching, holding the stretch for usually between 30 and 90 seconds. On the other hand, for someone doing a typical gym workout, the warm-up should not be static stretching, but instead a more dynamic, or moving, stretching. This will warm up the body by getting the heart rate elevated and move the body through a range of motion, but will do so actively. That can be anything from cardio machines (treadmill, elliptical, bike) to jumping jacks to jogging to jump rope. Anything that is of moderate intensity and uses major muscle groups.
Glenn Harris, Boston University Athletics head strength and conditioning coach
I suggest that people go through a dynamic stretching routine instead of a static stretching routine prior to exercising. Bringing the body through a range of motion can actually prepare it for the demands of the exercise session. For prepractice or pregame warm-up, we will go through a continuous warm-up, which is a series of running drills. The drills increase in difficulty and demand until the body is warmed up. After the warm-up series is complete, we will then perform some dynamic stretching for different parts of the body, including arm circles, leg swings, spider-man stretch, and inchworm walks.
This is in more lamen terms however essentially it states how static stretching reduces your performance. There are a lot of articles about how stretching does not prevent injuries as well.
I will second what Stacey said. My group was told to stretch, so I did, even though I don’t normally. We did Indian runs up a hill, and I had to be excused early…due to a pulled muscle. I always ignore trainers who say to stretch before the workout. That’s just plain stupid.
I don’t know how you can take this information seriously with things such as ‘ According to this research, runners run more slowly, jumpers jump less high, and weight lifters lift more weakly’. I could string better sentences together in primary school.
You made such a great argument, that I’ll never trust this website anymore – just kidding. Grow up ;)
I find that when I do not do static stretching before a sport or activity, I am far more likely to get sore muscles. However, when I do stretch before an activity, I rarely get sore muscles the next day, or if they do get sore, it is far less severe. It does seem that right after stretching, I do feel slightly weaker so there might be some merit here. For reducing sore muscles and injury, I would highly recommend static stretching; especially if you’re doing a workout that you haven’t done in a while.
have you tried dynamic stretches instead of static before exercising?
I work for a large fulfillment center in Texas. We do pre-shift and post lunch mostly static stretches. About the only thing “dynamic” we do are the squats. There is a lot of walking.
In my position I use my arms and go up and down a “ladder” a lot, including being on my knee[s] on the floor. Other positions do not seem to need the ladder [really a tall step-stool] as much, but they do use it but they use their arms a lot more. The stowers have a need for speed.
The counters [my position] accuracy is more important than speed, but speed is still somewhat important, but I don’t need to be near as fast as the stowers of which I was once one, but was no good at it, so they trained me in counting at which I excel, when I concentrate.
So, what are the best stretches for us stowers and counters?
what are stowers and counters?
why does this article have conflicting statements?
“Recent studies caution people away from stretching before workouts”
“I suggest that people go through a dynamic stretching routine instead of a static stretching routine prior to exercising.”
Alright, if i have to choose between thousands of years of documented martial arts all agreeing on stretching before class and which come from cultures where proactive prevention is prioritized over merely addressing symptoms as they occur.
Same reason I do not believe in punching with glove. Boxing warn that punching may damage phalanx while all other martial arts have been punching bags, boards and other surfaces for millenium and actually strengthened their punches (Wolff’s law) rather than damaging them.
Lesson is: it’s about knowing the proper technique. Sure, if one does not know how to punch he may damage himself punching gloveless and likewise, if someone doesn’t know how to properly stretch depending on the type of workout that he wants to perform, he may not benefit. However, if one knows what he is doing it would be beneficial.
I remember being In grade school being told to stretch before track and field. I noticed as a child that it slowed me down so I stopped and remained active without stretching.
I’ve never had a body related injury and I’m in my mid 30’s.
I compose music and chart choreography for dancers. What I saw as stretching and warming up for dancers was a lot simpler than exercise guru thoughts. So I adapted it to my weekly fun running stretch. Becoming a dancer a little bit for running (5k every weekday) made it a lot more fun. Imagine occasionally effortlessly putting a foot down as the track rolls along while you pass those who have tried to push over trees for “warmup”.