For COVID-19 Patients, Could Breathing Easier Be as Simple as Flipping Over?
For COVID-19 Patients, Could Breathing Easier Be as Simple as Flipping Over?
BU pulmonology experts will team up with Boston Medical Center to investigate if lying facedown might improve lung function
One in four patients who arrive at Boston Medical Center (BMC) with COVID-19 go into the intensive care unit, says Nicholas Bosch, a pulmonary and critical care fellow at BMC and a graduate researcher in epidemiology at Boston University’s School of Public Health.
But there may be a way to keep more patients from needing the ICU’s limited space and ventilators. “It’s as simple as flipping on your stomach,” Bosch says.
Bosch is leading a randomized controlled trial at BMC to see if having COVID-19 patients start lying prone (that is, on their stomachs) soon after arriving at the hospital can help keep their symptoms from getting worse. The trial will begin as soon as possible, pending final regulatory approval.
The study team includes over 50 students, faculty, staff, doctors, nurses, and department heads from BMC and BU’s Schools of Medicine and Public Health. “From top to bottom, there’s been huge interest and so many volunteers, and I don’t think the study would work without that,” Bosch says. “There would be no time, without that.”
Years before the new coronavirus emerged, research showed that prone positioning reduced deaths among patients with acute respiratory distress syndrome—the condition that is now often the cause of death in COVID-19 patients.
The idea, Bosch explains, is that the part of the lungs that is best at pulling oxygen into the blood is along a person’s back. When a patient lies on their back, that part of the lungs gets too much blood and not enough oxygen. Prone positioning gives that back part of the lungs a better ratio. “It’s just gravity,” Bosch says.
In the current pandemic, many hospitals are now “proning” patients who already have severe COVID-19, including those on ventilators, and it seems to be helping.
“So much of what clinicians are doing with COVID right now is investigational, experimental,” but not in scientifically rigorous ways, Bosch says. As a low-tech and easily achieved clinical practice, proning seems worth studying properly, he says.
However, running a trial in a hospital right now is a major challenge, especially because there isn’t enough personal protective equipment (PPE) to spare for researchers.
That’s where Craig Ross comes in. Ross, a School of Public Health research assistant professor of epidemiology, created a smartphone-based system to gather data directly from patients remotely. The system includes directions with pictures for patients to flip onto their stomach (careful not to pull out all the wires and tubes they’re routinely connected to), and reminds them to do it three times a day for an hour and at night.
“A couple times a day, Craig is also pinging them to say, ‘Will you fill out this survey?’” Bosch says. These surveys ask patients whether they are proning, for how long, and whether they are having any issues.
COVID-19 research also needs to move quickly, so that clinicians can start using effective strategies as soon as possible. To help with this aspect, Gheorghe Doros, a School of Public Health professor of biostatistics, is providing expertise in adaptive study design for the trial. Adaptive study uses the data gathered in an ongoing trial to change certain aspects of the trial in predetermined ways, instead of needing a series of separate, iterative studies to test new possibilities and zero in on strong results.
It can also be more ethical, Doros says: “In this study, if we learn from accumulating data that there is some indication that one treatment is better than the other, we’re going to assign more patients to that particular treatment. And, if the indication is overwhelming towards one of the treatments, we can stop the trial and say, ‘We have the answer,’ rather than waiting until the end.”
Bosch, for his part, is new to randomized controlled trials, and says it is an incredible learning experience. He has spent the last three years as a research fellow at BMC with Allan Walkey, a School of Medicine associate professor of medicine and the faculty principal investigator for this trial.
“Nick exemplifies the best qualities of students in our program,” Ross says of Bosch. “SPH students are working very hard, using scientific rigor to do really creative projects, and showing extraordinary leadership. This has been an amazing thing he’s pulled together so quickly.”
Brilliant idea. Certainly, any innovations that will help patients during this horrible pandemic sould be utilized. The simpler, the better
Wonderful research, but please do not present it as “Pioneering research from BU University”. Nowhere in this article it is mentioned that other hospitals/doctors/researchers have been using this technique in COVID patients. Placing COVID patients on their back has been researched and implemented in Italy, Germany, New York, Chicago and Miami, just to name a few (and I am not mentioning a French study of 7 years ago). I am attaching two articles which describe this practice. This is a global pandemic involving all countries; hopefully researchers will join forces and coordinate their effort.
“Doctors are finding that placing the sickest coronavirus patients on their stomachs – called prone positioning – helps increase the amount of oxygen that’s getting to their lungs.” “Ever since, to varying degrees, doctors in the United States have been placing ventilated ARDS patients on their stomachs”. https://www.cnn.com/2020/04/14/health/coronavirus-prone-positioning/index.html (April 14, 2020).
“…a March 30 letter to the editor in the American Journal of Respiratory and Critical Care Medicine. The letter, which had been circulating in online emergency medicine communities and was written by an Italian anesthesiologist named Luciano Gattinoni, relayed findings from researchers in Germany and Italy…”
https://www.miamiherald.com/news/coronavirus/article242012816.html#storylink=cpy (April 15, 2020).
I sat upright with infection. I found out my thyroid was enlarged – diffuse goiter – not apparent from the front. It pressed against my tongue and when I was on my back, it caused sleep apnea (pressure on C7). I started therapy for chronic iodine deficiency (all thyroid tests normal). It reduced swelling of thyroid and cured sleep apnea. The virus had attacked my thyroid which made the problem more apparent. Could be alot of people die in their sleep from this viral complication. With me, I had a massive inflammatory response and that produced oxidative damage in lower part of both legs due to lymphatic congestion. Takes a long time to repair – Iodoral/ selenium therapy broke up the ROS from the oxidative damage with lots of nutritional support.
This prone technique is definitely going in the right direction , if not the answer. My strain of covid was the B117 and it starting filling my lungs while laying on my back. I did not go back to laying on my back at all for many days. My positions were sitting with my back against the wall or chair or just moving around. The prone position for me was effective for only so long as I could withstand the pain which the position caused in my lower back. Obviously I survived the ordeal, but am still dealing with repercussions of blood draining down through my sinuses and also no sense of no taste or smell.
Don’t stop the research, get it approved! It is definitely going to save lives.
How was your symptoms? I’m currently on day 9 and still have a fever. Hoping to turn the corner soon.