• Rich Barlow

    Senior Writer

    Photo: Headshot of Rich Barlow, an older white man with dark grey hair and wearing a grey shirt and grey-blue blazer, smiles and poses in front of a dark grey backdrop.

    Rich Barlow is a senior writer at BU Today and Bostonia magazine. Perhaps the only native of Trenton, N.J., who will volunteer his birthplace without police interrogation, he graduated from Dartmouth College, spent 20 years as a small-town newspaper reporter, and is a former Boston Globe religion columnist, book reviewer, and occasional op-ed contributor. Profile

Comments & Discussion

Boston University moderates comments to facilitate an informed, substantive, civil conversation. Abusive, profane, self-promotional, misleading, incoherent or off-topic comments will be rejected. Moderators are staffed during regular business hours (EST) and can only accept comments written in English. Statistics or facts must include a citation or a link to the citation.

There are 10 comments on Soldiering On

  1. “Racing to finish papers is a small sacrifice compared to being away at war and missing your daughter’s senior year in high school.”

    I cannot write as a veteran returning to school, but I can write as a daughter of two veterans. My mother is a general in the United States Marine Corps, and my father a Lt. Colonel. Not only have they learned so much from the military, I have learned so much from them being in the military. Both of my parents pursued a degree before bootcamp, so the Marine Corps was a career for them.
    I know from experience that everything seems smaller and less significant when a loved one is overseas. I just wanted to say thank you to all the veterans, especially my parents!!

  2. It’s great to know that we have people of such caliber on the BU campus. I respect the service and perspective of all of these veterans, but as one who has been close to many veterans of previous wars, I have a special sympathy and admiration for Ross Caputi’s experiences and choices. His pursuit of a degree in linguistics seems particularly appropriate and moving in the context of the current conflict and I wish him, and all the other veterans mentioned here, great success.

  3. Is Caputi accepting any military money to go to college? If he feels so horrible about everything he did in the service, he should probably not be taking their money.

    And if he failed to learn anything at all from his time in he must have had his eyes shut for the duration of his service.

    BU Today- I know he’s a favorite of yours, but how about you don’t ruin every article you write about military veterans on campus by making it a soapbox for Ross’ drivel.

  4. I am also an undergraduate, and Veteran U.S. Army soldier, here at B.U. (CAS’12). I must say that, while it is pleasing to read of his pursuit of education in linguistics, I completely disagree to the comments made by one particular veteran: Ross Caputi (CAS’11).

    Caputi states, “I don’t think I learned anything positive in the military. I certainly didn’t get any skills, unless sweeping and mopping are skills.” And, goes on further to call the war effort “genocide.”

    First, I want to state that I am sorry for the experience in Fallujah (2004)–that was a hot zone, and I don’t doubt for a second it is something he will always carry inside. I am sorry for what he had to witness or take part in. However, with that being said, if all he learned were how to mop and sweep floors, then I would say our perceptions and experiences in the military are worlds apart.

    Second, I have no personal quarrel with Caputi. I find his choice to serve as honorable, and, if anything, am saddened by the internal conflict he deals with as a result of such an experience.

    Personally, being given the opportunity to lead, train, develop, and educate soldiers was an honor. I learned more about myself, and leadership from the military than I ever would have learned anywhere else. I know the service demands tested my own mettle again and again, because people depended on me, but I had terrific leadership to teach me. I learned how to overcome adversity in any given situation, and how important effective management, duty, and team cohesion can be. I learned that respect can never be given, but always earned. I learned critical thinking skills, and many of the things the other aforementioned Veterans describe. I can go on and on, about the plethora of opportunities, schools, and skills the U.S. military supported in my development. However, that’s not the point of this commentary. I simply aim to point out a different experience and perception altogether, and a disdain for his use of the term “genocide.”

    I do agree with Caputi in one area: I certainly was not pro-war on the principles we went under, either. In fact, I didn’t even see combat! However, it wouldn’t have changed my perception of those around me, or the military even if I had. Being deployed is always a possible reality in the back of every soldiers mind. I never welcomed [philosophically] having to take arms against an enemy—whose side of the fence I could have just as easily been born on—any more than Caputi probably did. However, he did sign on the dotted line to serve his country and, regardless of my objections to his perception, he definitely earned the right to say it. The experience he mentions also helps provide a naysayer point of view—adding to the holistic appeal of the article.

    However, I think Caputi borders on a real thin line with his statements on “genocide.” For example, there was a recent picture which was dubbed “Photo of the Year,” and on the cover of TIME magazine. In this picture: a beautifully dignified looking girl from Afghanistan with her nose and ears cut-off. She had divorced her husband at 19, because he consistently beat her. As a result, the Taliban allowed him to cut off her ears and nose in retribution. It was American troops who took her in, gave her medical care, and she now is in the U.S. awaiting plastic surgery. While this is an extreme example, it dutifully serves its purpose in showing positives of the military.

    My point is that people are doing a lot more than simply raiding and attacking a perceived “enemy.” The fault of U.S. policy for our involvement—or questionable use of a pretext for war—is another argument altogether. However, I feel his use of the term “genocide” is rather inflammatory rhetoric. A lot of great troops have died over there—many serving for what they, as individuals, felt were the right reasons. Furthermore, I doubt American families who lost their sons/daughters over there would appreciate their children being thrown into such a pool as “genocide.”

    While Caputi may not have directly been quoted as saying “troops perform genocide,” stating the “American war effort” certainly implies everyone into that category. I do not, personally, recall the mission of “genocide” written anywhere in U.S. foreign policy? I never briefed, nor was briefed, on any rules of engagement (R.O.E) allowing for excessive use of force when not under a direct and immediate threat. And while Caputi has every right to criticize certain aspects that occur, as a result of the war effort—perhaps even the choice to go to war itself—I feel it could be dangerous to imply, directly or indirectly, all who wear the uniform as utilities in seeking out a mission of “genocide.”

    There are harsh realities that service members face, and that is an absolute truth. However, B.U. students should not believe for one second that soldiers are not trained to use appropriate force and judgment, to disobey UNLAWFUL orders (e.g. “genocide”), or that they don’t acquire any skills. Such a concept would be a complete farce, and I feel it is very important to make said distinction. Many doctors, civil affairs, medics, engineers, diplomats, logistics personnel, and others serve intricate roles in helping people in Afghanistan and Iraq.

    Again, I am not saying that our presence over there is completely justified. However, those who have little concept of what service members do should not think that everyone serving in those theatres simply stand around either harming people or mopping floors. Combat operations are one-twentieth of a very complex pie. And, in my subjective opinion, Caputi’s comments undermine a great deal of the “positive” things going on over there. The media doesn’t necessarily show this to the public, because it may often be ruled as boring or not a big story. Basically, the absurdity that it might more interesting to show the world an apache helicopter gunning down personnel, rather than watch a school being built.

    I hope students can keep an open mind about what service members really do, despite Caputi’s negative generalizations.

  5. The ongoing occupations of Iraq and Afghanistan serve no purpose for the American people. They are hugely unpopular, yet the media rarely gives voice to the many victims – both American and foreign – to this bloody policy.

    The TIME magazine piece about the Afghani woman who had her nose and ears cut off was a shameful propaganda piece for justifying the war. The US is not there to protect women from domestic violence (we do a dubious job of that right here in the US), but we are dropping bombs and indiscriminately killing civilians from the sky. The fact that this image could be so cynically used to rally support for war just demonstrates how corporations and the state have captured the media and sheltered us from the real images of war.

    Ross Caputi is a true hero. He is obviously motivated by humanitarian values and follows his convictions whether they please those in power or not. If we had more soldiers like Ross we could put an end to war.

  6. We shouldn’t bash Caputi. I think he is going through a shock and is still trying to make sense of his experience in Iraq. Not everyone will think the war provided them with more good than bad. Frankly, I liked hearing his different perspective. I doubt all soldiers will think positively about their experience. His comments are also real – not brainwashed by the military and its training. I think he is a cognizant thinker; cognizant of the reality of the situation. Not all soldiers are in combat and some are just mopping floors. Like my grandfather, he never actually fought in the Vietnam war – he was in some other military base mopping floors. Furthermore, I don’t think we should belittle Caputi’s experience. It’s real and it’s his own. Someone posted a comment saying that he shouldn’t receive GI money for his education: I think he very much deserves it. He will have memories and nightmares most of us will never have to live with. An education at BU will help him make sense of the situation…guide him in his reincorporation into US society. We need alternate thinkers, like him, who are cognizant and vocal.

  7. Ross has more than a perfect right to both criticize the US military and use the benefits he EARNED by service. We should be grateful to him for reporting honestly about what he experienced in Fallujah.

    It may be hard for you to wrap your head around this, but under international law, the invasion of Iraq was an act of naked aggression and therefore the supreme crime that human beings can commit. More than 4 million Iraqis have been displaced from their homes and their livelihoods. Hundreds of thousands have been killed. Millions have been made orphans. Torture is rampant, now carried out under the auspices of the American government. Another civil war in Iraq is probably inevitable thanks to the bloody-minded arrogance, brutality and credulity of the Americans. The toxic weaponry we used, including DU munitions, will poison generations of innocent children.

    The suffering of those children will not be registered by the students of Boston University. But it will be registered by others. And when blow-back comes, as it inevitably will, you will express outrage at the scandalous violence of others. You will cringe at their “immorality,” oblivious to your own. You will not connect the violence with criminal acts committed by your own government — and the Blessed American Military.

    “The greatest purveyor of violence on Earth is my own government.”

    MLK was right then. And Ross is right now.

Post a comment.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *