| 1441.026 |
1441 |
Common Pleas |
Novel disseisin, Assize of |
Assise |
| Hil. |
19 |
Hen. 6 |
26 |
59a-61b |
Yelverton, William Sjt
Portyngton, John Sjt Portington
Fortescue, John Sjt (for P)
Newton, Richard CJCP
Fortescue, John Sjt (addressed)
Paston, William JCP
Fortescue, John Sjt
Newton, Richard CJCP (addressed)
Newton, Richard CJCP
Ayscough, William JCP Ascough
Fortescue, John Sjt (mentioned)
Yelverton, William Sjt
Newton, Richard CJCP |
K. (Kelomme) |
J. (James) |
|
|
| K., K., wife of J. & elder half-sister of tenant |
A., grantee & regrantor
D., V., donor
Irby, J., first husband of Alice & father of plaintiff wife K.
Alice, mother of defendant by her second husband & mother of K. by her first husband J. Irby
E.
Skelton, John, second husband of Alice and thather of defendant |
England (Angleterre) |
|
Statham Remittere 5, Garrantie 19
Fitzherbert Entre congeable 3 & 4, Garrantie 3
Brooke Entre congeable 33, Remitter 12, Garraunties 31 |
Later proceedings 1440.113 = Mich. 19 Hen. 6, pl. 95, fol. 45a-46a and 1441.050 = Trin. 19 Hen. 6, pl. 7, fol. 78b-79b
Related proceeding? 1442.094 = Trin. 20 Hen. 6, addit. pl. 34, fol. 45a-45b
21 Edw. 3, Lib. Ass. pl. 19
2 Hen. 5, fol. 12
Plowden, Commentaries 246
Infra, fol. 78
Littleton, Tenures 155, 158
Infra, fol. 61b
12 Hen. 6, fol. 7
Littleton, Tenures 148b
7 Hen. 5, fol. 6 (contra)
5 Hen. 7, fol. 29
Post, fol. 60, 61
Littleton, Tenures 164, 171, 172
Brooke, New Cases 66
Devant, fol. 45
34 Hen. 6, fol. 34
46 Edw. 3, fol. 21
45 Edw. 3, fol. 10
20 Hen. 6, fol. 25
11 Edw. 3, Lib. Ass. pl. 23
41 Edw. 3, fol. 18
Littleton, Tenures 158b
7 Edw. 4, fol. 7b (contra)
41 Edw. 3, fol. 30b
Infra, fol. 69
Devant, fol 59
44 Edw. 3, fol. 14
16 Edw. 3, Lib. Ass. pl. 16
Littleton, Tenures 171 (contra)
9 Hen. 6, fol. 24
40 Edw. 3, fol. 8b
43 Edw. 3, fol. 16, 17, 27
Littleton, Tenures 159
20 Hen. 6, fol. 29b
11 Hen. 4, fol. 19
14 Edw. 3, Lib. Ass. pl. 4
7 Hen. 7, fol. 11
39 Hen. 6, fol. 35
5 Edw. 4, Long Quinto fol. 4, 61
9 Hen. 4, fol. 24
12 Edw. 4, fol. 19
Post, fol. 79
20 Hen. 6, fol. 15
11 Hen. 4, fol. 19
Supra, fol. 46
3 Edw. 4, fol. 3
14 Hen. 4, fol. 39
48 Edw. 3, fol. 9 |
Westminster 2nd (1285), ch. 1 (cited in margin)
the statute = Gloucester (1278), ch. 3 (collateral warranty by tenant by the Curtesy) |
| Assise de novel disseisin fuit porte per J.K. & K. sa femme. Le tenant pleda coment Fin se leva perentre |
172 |
Tenant (defendant) pleaded that her father and mother levied a fine by which they granted to A. who granted back to them in fee tail, and after their deaths tenant entered as daughter and heir.
Plaintiff replied that a prior fee tail descended to plaintiff wife as daughter of tenant's mother and her first husband, and tenant (defendant) disseised plaintiffs.
Tenant (defendant) younger half-sister demurred on her title. |
tenant and plaintiff (mixed terminology)
Plaintiffs: le tenant entra deins age enclaimant a son oeps & al' oeps l' dit K sa soeur
Sjt Fortescue: Et les plaintifs pretendent a aver availe pur ceuo que ils on surmise que le tenant entra (ut supra) enclaimant a luy & a son coparcener, mes tiel surmis ne conclurant eux de claimeicy en Court de record quel estate, que ils veulent; Et si terre soit done a un homme en tail, qui luy dismet & reprend estate a luy & a sa femme en tail; nul demaine descend al plaintif; n' ad aucun demaine per descent, ceo sera mereilleux
Newton CJCP: mis en suspence come en cest Cas, le tenant en tail ad issue ij fits, l' eigne fait felony, purque il est attaint, mesque il soit in possession de l' terre al' temps de l' attaindre, uncore apres sa mort naturele l' fits puisne aura l' terre per Formedon, 'Quia nec per factum neque per feoffamentum'; Si jeo aliene terre ove garentie qui vault xl s, & puis per meme de lead ou tin trouve en meme le terre est fait de la value de xl l. per an, i le tenant soit emplede, & me vouche, & al Grand Capias ad valenc' viene, & ne peut barre l' demand, jeo prende issue ove le tenant de quel valu l' terre suit al temps de le garentie, & ne rendre plus en valu
Paston JCP: Et Sir, a le Common Ley chaqun garenty fuit farre, mes le Statut remedy collateral garenty fait per le tenant per Ley de Angleterre; a avoide un circuite en Ley; Ergo vostre entre tortieuse |
what appears to be a later stage of argument, without facts, reported earlier at 1440.113 = Mich. 19 Hen. 6, pl. 95, fol. 45a-46a
lead or tin mine
Sjt Yelverton and Sjt Fortescue argued for plaintiff's position; Sjt Portyngton and Paston JCP argued for defendant's position
Tenant (defendant): a fine was levied between tenant's father and tenant's mother Alice of one part, and A. of the other part, by which fine tenant's father and mother granted, etc. to A. who granted and rendered back to them in tail, and tenant's father and mother Alice died, and tenant entered as daughter and heir
Plaintiffs: long before this fine was levied, V.D. was seised, and gave the same land to J. Irby and Alice his wife, mother of tenant, and to the heirs of the said Alice engendered, among whom K. is issue, and then J. Irby died and tenant's mother Alice married tenant's father, and they had issue the tenant and they died, and the tenant entered within age claiming to her use and to the use of K. her sister, in which case this was remitter of the one half, by force of which the plaintiffs entered as in right of the wife (half-)sister of the tenant, claiming to hold this half in coparency, and thus were seised until disseised by the tenant
Newton CJCP: if I alienate late with a warranty, which is worth 40 shillings (= 2 pounds), and then by mining of lead or tin found in the same land the value is made 40 pounds per year, if the tenant be impleaded and vouch me, and I appear at Grand Capias, and cannot bar the demandant, I will take issue with the tenant for what value the land had at the time of the warranty, and not render more in value |
|
|
1440.113 = Mich. 19 Hen. 6, pl. 95, fol. 45a-46a and 1440.1441.050 = Trin. 19 Hen. 6, pl. 7, fol. 78b-79b
Statham Remittere 5, an extremely long entry, identified the plaintiffs as James Kelomme and his wife K., defendant as Eleanor (alianore), the father (of Eleanor) as W. and mother (of Eleanor and K.) as Alice, the donor as H., the earlier donor as D., the donee and first husband of Alice as J.; attributed a second speech to Ayscough JCP; stated that Sjt Fortescue said that if one half were discharged, all was discharged; and stated that all the Bench held clearly tha tthe entry of the plaintiff was not lawful, and the plaintiff, seeing this opinion, etc. was nonsuited, and brought Formedon in both their names, etc; well argued
Statham Garrantie 19, a long entry, identified this as the Assize of Kelomme; reported Newton CJCP's opinion; mentioned lands of which the value was increased by tin, lead, or coal (Tynne, lede ou coles); and added but yet query, because it seemed that the collateral warranty in the case above was defeated when the issue in tail was in by descent, as well as if the issue in tail brought a Formedon and recovered, where that collateral warranty was not pleaded in bar, then he was in (in) his own right and the warranty was defeated; and ended with a query. |
|
Disseisin
Assize
Wife
Pleading
Fine
Levying
Father
Mother
Part
Grant
Render Back
Fee Tail
Death
Entry
Daughter
Heir
Judgment
Seisin
Gift
Issue
Marriage
Within Age
Infancy
Claim
Use (oeps)
Use of Her Sister
Case
Remitter
Moiety
Force
Right of His Wife
Coparcener
Parcenry
Demurrer
Title
Descent
Tenant in Tail
Feoffment
Holding
In Common
Warranty
Collateral Warranty
Discontinuance
Formedon
Bar
Reason
Right
Termination
Understanding
Brother
Release
Plea
Finding
Recovery
Showing
Matter
Inconvenience
Execution
Possession
Simul & Semel
Issue In Tail
Purge
Refeoffment
Belief
Action
Writ of Right
Entitlement
Proof
Contrary
Male Heir
Elder
Younger
Summons
Severance
Summons and Severance
Non Est Ratio
Suit
Joint Tenancy
Prejudice
Foundation
Several Possession
Pretense
Pretending
Surmise
Conclusion
Court of Record
Record
Disclaimer
Country (Pais)
Tithe
Retaking
Dower
General Tail
Endowment
Ergo
Tortious Entry
Tort
Wrong
Ouster
Demesne
Marvel
Revival
Way
Distinction
Suspense
Felony
Attaint
Attainder
Nature
Natural Death
Quia Nec Per Factum Neque Per Feoffamentum
Defeat
Name
Advantage
Mischief
Loss
Deraignment
Knowledge
Recovery in Value
Better Reason
Insimul Tenuit
Demand
Grandparent
Speaking
Continuation
Common Law
Statute
Remedy
Curtesy
Law of England
Tenant by Curtesy
Mortdancestor
Assets
Circuity
Avoidance
Circuity in Law
Binding
Lien
Voucher
Value
Tenancy
Discharge
Chargee
Receipt
Ensue
Effect
Immediacy
Mention
Person
Chase
Inconvenience
Charge
Regard
Mining
Mine
Lead
Tin
Finding
Grand Cape
Grand Cape Ad Valenc'
Verdict
Inquest
Force
Avowry
Joinder
Mise
Discontinuee
Reversion
Punishment
Writ of Entry
Lineal Warranty
Allegation
Resort
Query |
|
