| 1410.018 |
1410 |
Common Pleas |
Trespass against an innkeeper |
Trespas
Concessum
Concessum
Judicium |
| Hil. |
11 |
Hen. 4 |
18 |
45a-45b |
Skrene, William Sjt (for D)
Tildesley, Thomas Sjt (for P) (? died)
Hankford, William JCP
Skrene, William Sjt
Hill, Robert JCP
Thirning, William CJCP
Tremaine, John Sjt
Thirning, William CJCP
Tremaine, John Sjt
Hankford, William JCP
Thirning, William CJCP
Hankford, William JCP |
|
|
|
|
Statham Accions sur le cas 21
Fitzherbert Hostler 5
Brooke Briefe 521 (not 251), Generall briefe 16, Action sur le case 41, Office del court 12 & 22, Count 81, Errour 49 |
|
|
| Un home port briefe de Trespas vers un hostler, & countast coment que per la commen ley |
35 |
Defendant pleaded that he was not a common innkeeper, but gave plaintiff keys to his house and stable in defendant's absence.
Plaintiff replied that defendant gave plaintiff no notice of defendant's absence.
Held that plaintiff must declare that defendant was a common innkeeper.
Awarded that plaintiff take nothing by his writ, but be amerced. |
per la commen ley chescun hostler est tenus de savement garder les choses, queux son deins son hostel; il fuit herbage (= lodging) ovesque luy; son chival fuit emblee deins le hostel
Sjt Skrene: nouse ne sumus my commen hostler; le plaintiff vient a nous encounter nuit, & pria que il puit estre en nostre meason; nous covient estre lendemaine bien matin avant le Viscount; il nous pria luy liverer un Cliefe (= key) de son chambre, & un auter de son stable, ou le chival serra, & nous deliveramus a luy mesme les Cliefs, & alamus nostre chemin mesme le nuit
Hankford JCP: per authority del ley; un common hostler face promise de son test demesen de parler ove un Viscount ou ater home, s'il suffer home herberge ove luy, il respondre de ses biens, & il est tenus d'aver deputies & servants south luy, pur bien garder l'hostel en son absence
Hill JCP: Le bailer des cliefs en cest case n'est riens a purpose en discharge del hostler, come il fut adjudge devant ses heurs; le plaintiff prist herberge a son peril, il discharge l'hosteler
Thirning CJCP: ne riens de recorde est allege en proof de ceo, mes en le count il ad declare le commen custome del commen hostler; coment que un home que n'est my commen hostler, moy herberge en son hostel, il ne respondre pas de mes biens. Nota cest reason; Un action ne puit estre maintaine per argument, ne per entendement, mes per sufficient matter compris & declare; pursuer melior action
Sjt Tremaine: Quant j'ay declare, que jeo fuy herberge en son hostel, il est entend que il est commen hostele |
|
Sjt Tildesley died 21 Oct. 1409, so this plea may have been incorrectly dated or 'Til.' may have been misidentifed. |
|
|
Statham Accions sur le cas 21, a long entry, attributed a speech to Sjt Norton, and added that defendant pleaded that he went to the sheriff to be at the hundred (court) of the same day, and that Sjt Skrene rehearsed the custom by which it was to be understood that he was a common innkeeper |
Sjt Tildesley died 21 Oct. 1409, so this plea may have been incorrectly dated or 'Til.' may have been misidentifed. |
Innkeeper
Count
Common Law
Safeguard
Theft
Protest
Common Innkeeper
Lodging
Sheriff
Extent (Valuation)
King's Writ
Delivery
Judgment
Action
Maintenance of Action
Damages
Distraint
Authority of Law
Notice
Traverse
Promise
Speaking
Deputy
Servant
Absence
Inn
Bailment
Purpose
Discharge
Cause
Peril
Record
Proof
Answer
Argument
Intention
Sufficiency
Matter
Declaration
Acceptance
Amercement |
|
