Editors' Note
We have made this issue a special issue because it has a certain thematic unity. Sometimes directly
and sometimes obliquely (but still pointedly), all the contributions deal with the history of liberalism; and
together they suggest new avenues of approach to that subject within a transatlantic framework. At issue
in the forum on Louis Menand's The Metaphysical Club is how we are to understand the significance of
American Pragmatism, which arguably has been critical to giving modern American liberalism its distinctive
profile. As Kenneth Cmiel makes clear, John Higham's work has been centrally concerned with the
potentialities and the pitfalls of liberal pluralism in the American context - and Higham has been an important
liberal voice in his own right. In J.W. Burrough's The Crisis of Reason, reviewed here by Suzanne Marchand,
we see European liberalism entering a crisis in the face of "the modern" even as it finds new groundings from
the mid-nineteenth century onward.
more.
Liberal Cultures and Their Critics: The Trials of a Transatlantic Discourse
Alan Ryan ~ Liberal Political Theory:
Always Unpopular
Sarah Maza ~ Anti-Bourgeois Consciousness
and French Identity in Historical Perspective
Gerald Izenberg ~ Reconciling
Individuality and Individualism in European Liberalism
George Kateb ~ A Glance at Democratic
Individuality
Ruth H. Bloch ~ Utopianism, Sentimentalism,
and Liberal Culture in America
James Kloppenberg ~ Aspirational
Nationalism in America
Dorothy Ross ~ Liberalism and American
Exceptionalism
Roundtable: Louis Menand's The Metaphysical Club and the Problem of Pragmatism
Bruce Kuklick ~ Menand and Self-Reliance
James Kloppenberg ~ Teaching
The Metaphysical Club
Giles Gunn ~ Reflections on Louis Menand's
The Metaphysical Club
Karen Hanson ~ Pragmatism in
Situ: Philosophical Accuracy and Historical Context
Thomas Haskell ~ Menand's Postdisciplinary
Project
Louis Menand ~ Reply
Book Reviews
Suzanne Marchand ~ The Old
Intellectual History and the New?
A review of J. W. Burrow's The Crisis of Reason: European Thought, 1848-1914
Kenneth Cmiel ~ John Higham:
The Contrarian as Optimist
A review of John Higham's Hanging Together: Unity and Diversity in American Culture
In Memoriam
Yehoshua Arieli, 1914-2002 ~ by
Stephen J. Whitfield