CTE Found in 99 Percent of Former NFL Players Studied

Data suggest disease may be more common in football players than previously thought

Ann McKee, director of BU’s CTE Center, is co-author on a new JAMA study that found CTE in 99 percent of brains obtained from National Football League players. Photo by Asia Kepka

A new study suggests that chronic traumatic encephalopathy (CTE), a progressive, degenerative brain disease found in people with a history of repeated head trauma, may be more common among football players than previously thought. The study, published Tuesday in the Journal of the American Medical Association (JAMA), found CTE in 99 percent of brains obtained from National Football League (NFL) players, as well at 91 percent of college football players and 21 percent of high school football players.

Jesse Mez
Jesse Mez, MED assistant professor of neurology and lead author on the new study, says: “The data suggest that there is very likely a relationship between exposure to football and risk of developing [CTE].” Photo by Cydney Scott

“The data suggest that there is very likely a relationship between exposure to football and risk of developing the disease,” says Jesse Mez, a Boston University School of Medicine (MED) assistant professor of neurology and lead author on the study.

The study has several important limitations, most notably the lack of a control group, and selection bias in the brain collection itself—families of players with symptoms of CTE are far more likely to donate brains to research than those without signs of the disease. Despite these limitations, researchers note that the study—the largest and most methodologically rigorous CTE case series ever published—offers important information and direction for further research.

“The fact that we were able to gather so many instances of a disease that was previously considered quite rare, in eight years, speaks volumes,” says corresponding author Ann McKee, a MED professor of neurology and pathology and director of BU’s CTE Center. “There’s just no way that would be possible if this disease were truly rare.”

“I think the data are very surprising,” she adds. “We’ve sort of become accustomed to it, but it is very shocking.”

McKee, who is also chief of the Neuropathology Service at the VA Boston Healthcare System, first encountered CTE in 2003, identifying its telltale mark—tiny tangles of tau protein clustered around blood vessels—in the dissected brain of a boxer. In 2014, grants from the National Institute of Neurological Disorders and Stroke and the National Institute of Biomedical Imaging and Bioengineering—both part of the National Institutes of Health—allowed McKee to begin a study called UNITE (Understanding Neurologic Injury and Traumatic Encephalopathy), a retrospective analysis of brains donated to the VA-BU-CLF Brain Bank, the results of which comprise much of the current JAMA article.

Microscopic images of tau, stained red, embedded in samples of normal, mild CTE, and severe CTE brain tissue
A sample of normal brain tissue (left), alongside samples showing mild and severe CTE. The brown stain indicates tangles of tau protein. Defective tau is associated with CTE, as well as Alzheimer’s disease and Parkinson’s disease. The bottom row shows microscopic images of tau, stained red, embedded in brain tissue. Photo by Ann McKee

For the study, the researchers began with the donated brains of 202 football players. Pathologists, knowing nothing of a patient’s history or symptoms, examined each brain for evidence of CTE. At the same time, clinicians—blinded to each brain’s pathology—used medical records and interviews with family members to collect detailed information about each patient’s medical history and symptoms. The group met for regular consensus meetings, where the pathologists and the clinicians presented their findings. They limited the study to football players, providing a somewhat homogeneous sample.

Of the 202 brains studied, the group diagnosed 177 with CTE, including 110 of 111 from the NFL players (99 percent); 7 of 8 from the Canadian Football League (88 percent); 9 of 14 semi-professional players (64 percent); 48 of 53 college players (91 percent), and 3 of 14 high school players (21 percent). (The group also studied the brains of two pre-high-school players, neither of whom was diagnosed with CTE.) The brains of former high school players showed only mild pathology, while the majority of college, semi-professional, and professional players showed severe pathology.

Dave Duerson on football field
Dave Duerson, a former safety for the Chicago Bears, committed suicide in 2011 at age 50. His suicide note read, “Please, see that my brain is given to the NFL’s brain bank.” McKee analyzed his brain and diagnosed moderately severe CTE. Duerson’s brain is among the 202 included in a study published Tuesday in JAMA. Photo by Owen C. Shaw/Getty Images

Mez notes some puzzling findings from the study. Most striking, the researchers observed clinical symptoms such as depression, anxiety, disinhibition, memory loss, and other mood and behavior impairments even in patients with fairly mild CTE pathology. “Why do you still see symptoms even without that much CTE pathology?” asks Mez. “It suggests that there might be even more going on than just the tau pathology; there might be other things that we need to look at, like inflammation or axonal injury, or there might be regions of the brain that we’re not looking at sufficiently.”

The findings also suggest that there may be other environmental factors at play, like substance abuse, other head traumas, or a genetic component. Mez says that clues may come from outliers in the study, like the one NFL brain that did not show evidence of CTE or the brains from high school players that did.

“Those people are probably genetically protected from this disease or they’re genetically predisposed to it, depending on which extreme you’re looking at,” says Mez. “I think you can certainly learn a lot from them. And as we move forward and we collect more of those extremes, they will be really informative.”

The researchers emphasize that the data represent a new tool for scientists. “This is an enormous advance in a resource, because we have developed this brain bank of frozen and fixed tissue on these individuals who have been affected by this disease,” says McKee. “Our goal is to try to understand the disease from its earliest beginnings in the brain, what molecular pathways are involved, how it spreads, which regions it affects most severely—all to give us ideas how to diagnose this disease during life, and also to give us information about how to treat it.”

Published

12 comments

  1. Roger the Clowns hopes and dreams of Tuesday Night Football are evaporating as we speak. The Weak Coward makes 44,000,000 a year and run is M I A when it comes to players Brain Injuries. The Commish needs to loose the Skirt and be a man and address the Issue. What an absolute fake Human Being.

  2. The heading of this story is completely misleading. The study bases its research off of donated brains, which are most likely from families that saw signs of CTE. Thus the sample size of brains is skewed towards people who showed indications of CTE. When developing these stories, you should be more conscientious of providing a full picture of the story in the header rather than providing a partial picture.

    1. Agree with Andrew Freed — and the NYT article on this suffers from the same sensationalization. Also like the NYT, it’s great that you devote a paragraph to limitations of the study, but this effort is totally undermined by an overstated headline. This is not to cast any doubt on the prevalence of CTE among football players, but speaking more generally, science journalists need to take responsibility for their potential to mislead the public. Nobody wants more Baby Einstein scenarios…

    2. I am absolutely stunned, honestly, that a press release like this would be published before the study is even complete. Because the study is *not* complete until data from control groups is collected. If this had been a middle school science fair project that I was judging, and they didn’t even have a control group, it would get a terrible grade.

      How can a full-blown research-grade study at a major university get publication like this with such a glaring omission? This is irresponsible.

    3. Even if the brains donated were the only brains in the entire NFL with CTE, this would give a low-estimation of about 15% of NFL players with CTE. That’s the low end, that’s the starting point. 15% is disturbingly high, that number should be in the decimal places. This is probably why they went for a sensational title.

    4. You’re exactly right, it’s actually stated in the article that these brains were donated from former player’s families and several of them were already suspected to have CTE.

  3. As a former college football player these findings are very troubling. I agree with Andrew Freed that this only represents a population with “bread crumbs” leading to a CTE confirming autopsy. That being said, I believe to deny that concussions/repeated head trauma has a direct relationship with football and eventually CTE is similar to denying that smoking causes lung cancer. This wouldn’t be the first time that something popular in our culture turned out to have negative health consequences. Begs the question: will societal and economical benefits outweight the long term effect of this disease? What does that say about the values of our culture? Those are heavy questions I do not have an answer to.

    1. I’m not sure that anyone is trying to deny that there isn’t a direct relationship between CTE and football, but I don’t think anyone needs to just think that football may be the only sport that can have these kind of issues. Any sport that you play runs risks of head injuries. A question I would like to know the answer to would be how many hits to the helmet can a batter take in baseball because of wild pitches before they too might see this same kind of issue. There are good and bad surrounding everything, and risks involved with everything you do, if you truly tried to weigh the long term effects of diseases, or of medical complications of just about anything you do, or enjoy such as any kind of sports entertainment, against the economical or societal benefits, you’re going to come up short in every single area. There’s always going to be something else come about, it’s a never ending process, as long as you have scientist who want to do research, and can do research and find things that weren’t found 50-100 years ago. Everything can be tied to something. Everything can cause cancer, everything can cause death or injury, if at some point everyone doesn’t stop with all the things that we shouldn’t do as a society in whole, we’re all going to end up needing to live in a bubble.

  4. There is a true need for former NFL players and former college football players, without any signs or symptom of CTE, to donate their brains to Boston University upon their death. Thus, there can be a comparison between those that had signs and symptoms and those that did not.

  5. Cousin Wayne was a howitzer instructor between the Korean and Vietnam wars, standing right beside the big guns. On one particular day, he could no longer cope with people, paperwork or much of anything else. When I met him twenty years later at his care home, he could intelligently carry on conversations, but with little enthusiasm. Just smoked one coffin nail after another, very slowly, staring vacantly, self-medicating in addition to the dozen pills that commonly treat brain problems.

    Basically dark, quiet bars, thousands of VFW halls were in every suburb until recently. Our heroes who jumped continents and changed the world in a little over three years needed decompression, some more than others, and booze and cigs were shame-free medication. Hey, everyone did it, right? Office boys and the guys in manufacturing transitioned better, jumped into the postwar swim of things and mostly did not need that kind of solace. My father’s happy run, slide rule in hand, was radar to atom bombs to reactors to mainframes to Wall Street security software. Never a down day for Dad.

    Boston University recently published preliminary notes studying chronic traumatic encephalopathy within deceased NFL players’ brains, found 99% clearly show permanent physical damage. Families had to deal with depression, anxiety, disinhibition, memory loss, and other mood and behavior impairments [lacking a control group, the study has only begun].

    Perhaps 30 years ago, average age of death for doctors and pro football players alike was 58. Banging one’s noggin a thousand times may have scrambled jock brains, but why doctors? Decades of cramming, stress and chemical exposure, or just, “I only smoke Old Gold. Not a cough in a carload”? Self-medicating, again.

    Some of my favorite time in music (back when it really was an industry) was spent in front of stacks of equipment so loud that plucking was optional: The speakers would play the strings and vice versa. We liked it loud. Shook our gizzards and probably our brains. Self-medicating, burned-out bands in that era are a cliche, too.

    Maybe the self-medicating pattern I see following repeated brain insult is no more real than the callow worldview of our current crop of brainiac professors ranting against isms, phobias, hegemonies, corporations, and free markets. But for at least some of the head hits, I was there.

  6. If this is as true as it looks, We need to give players better helmets and abolish Thursday night football. This is a shock to me!

Post Your Comment