Legal History: The Year Books

Record Detail


	Previous Record	Next Record

Image
For an image of this report text from the Vulgate Year Books Reprint, click here.

Seipp Number:	Year	Court	Writ	Marginal Heading
1481.089	1481	Common Pleas	Debt on an obligation

Term	Regnal Year	King:	Plea Number	Folio Number
Mich. (2nd)	21	Edw. 4	21	53b

Serjeants/ Justices	Plaintiff Surname	Plaintiff First Name v.	Defendent Surname	Defendent First Name
Calow, William Sjt Collow (for P) Choke, Richard JCP Starkey, Humfrey Sjt (for D) Bryan, Thomas CJCP Brian

Other Plaintiffs	Other Names	Places	Other Defendents
	Bor, Sir J., Lord of Bor'

Abridgements	Cross-References	Statutes
Brooke Condicions 175 (not fol. 54), Obligation 59 (not in margin)

Incipit (First Line)	Number of Lines
Det sur obligation, le defendant monstra que l' obligation fuit endorce sur tiel condicion, que si le defendant garde le plaintiff sans damage vers	7

Defendant pleaded that the obligation was endorsed on such a condition that if defendant kept plaintiff without damage against a lord knight of 10 pounds of which plaintiff was obliged to defendant in two obligations that then this obligation would be void, and defendant pleaded that plaintiff was not damaged by the lord knight for the 10 pounds.
Plaintiff demurred on the plea because the condition was impossible and thus void.
Choke JCP was of the same opinion.
Defendant prayed advice.
Bryan CJCP said that it was a bad case.

J. Bor. Chivaler Seignior de Bor- de x. l. des queux le plaintiff est oblige al defendant en ij obligations que adonques cest obligation serra void, & dit que le plaintiff ne fuit damage per le dit J.B. pur les dits x l. &c.
Sjt Calow (for P): Demurt sur le plaintiff, car semble que le condicion est voide, car come appiert le dit Seignior n' ad rien a faire ove les dits obligation, ne per ascun possibility poit aver, pur que le condicion est impossible, & issint void
Choke JCP fuit de meme l' opinion
Sjt Starkey (for D) pria avisement
Bryan CJCP dit que il fuit male cas

Abstract	Context

Sjt Calow (for P): it seems that the condition is void, because as it appears the lord (knight) had nothing to do with the obligations, nor could have by any possibility, so the condition was impossible, and thus void
possibly same case 1482.037 = Hil. 21 Edw. 4, pl. 8, fol. 75a

Manuscripts	Mss Notes	Editing Notes	Errors

Plea Roll	Record Year	Record Plaintiffs	Record Defendants	Last Update
	0			2006-08-10

Obligation
Showing
Endorsement
Coondition
Keeping (garde)
Without Damage
(Holding Harmless)
Knight
Lord
Voidance
Void Obligation
Damage
Demurrer
Plea
Demurrer On The Plea
Seeming
Void Condition
Appearance
Nothing
Nothing To Do
Possibility
Impossibility
Impossible Condition
Opinion
Advice
Advisement
Case
Bad Case


	Previous Record	Next Record

Return to Search