Resolving the Near-Far Kinematic Distance Ambiguity

J.M. Jackson, T.M. Bania, M. Kolpak, R. Simon, D.P. Clemens, and M.H. Heyer1

Institute for Astrophysical Research, Boston University
 Five College Radio Astronomy Observatory, University of Massachusetts, Amherst

 

Abstract

    We have analyzed the first ten square degrees of the Boston University-Five College Radio Astronomy Observatory Galactic Ring Survey (GRS), a new, fully-sampled survey of 13CO emission over a large portion of the inner Galaxy. We compare the GRS 13CO maps to 21 cm H I maps from the Boston University-Arecibo Observatory Galactic HI Survey.  Toward many molecular clouds, we find a remarkable association between 13CO emission and HI self-absorption, both in velocity and morphology.  In particular, G45.6+0.3, a large filamentary cloud, shows deep HI self-absorption  throughout the 13CO emitting region. This cloud is also associated with pronounced optical extinction and thus lies at the near kinematic distance. Another cloud, G43.3-0.3, also shows a pronounced correlation between 13CO emission and 21 cm H I self-absorption.

Position-velocity diagrams also show a number of additional molecular clouds that correspond with HI self-absorption.

    Photodissociation theory suggests that the skins of typical molecular clouds exposed to normal Galactic UV radiation fields will exhibit H I self-absorption against strong H I backgrounds. Because H I emission is ubiquitous throughout the Galaxy, with sufficient angular resolution, the cold H I can be used to determine whether the molecular cloud lies at the near or far kinematic distance.  Clouds at the near distance will show H I self-absorption, whereas clouds at the far distance will show H I in emission. This technique can resolve the kinematic distance ambiguity by cleanly separating near clouds from far clouds.
 
 

Introduction

    We compare the GRS 13CO molecular data and 21 cm H I data taken from the Boston University-Arecibo Observatory (BUAO) Galactic H I
Survey. The BUAO Survey parameters are:

Table. 1: BUAO Galactic HI Survey
Galactic Longitude  30.5 to 60.5 degrees
Galactic Latitude -0.5 to 0.5 degrees
Angular resolution 4' HPBW
Angular sampling  2' or 4' intervals
LSR velocity range -264.0 to +264.0 km/s
Velocity resolution 0.52km/s
Sensitivity   0.5 K

 In the course of this comparison, we found that a number of clouds show a clear correspondence between 13CO emission and H I self-absorption, both in morphology and in velocity. Although H I self-absorption toward molecular clouds has been known for some time, this is the first clear correspondence between H I self-absorption and CO emission in both 2-dimensional morphology and in velocity. This correspondence suggests that these molecular clouds contain significant amounts of cold atomic hydrogen.
 
 

Breaking the Near-Far Kinematic Distance Ambiguity

    As a special consequence of the geometry of the inner Galaxy, any particular value of radial velocity corresponds to two distances along the line of sight, called the ``near'' and ``far'' distances. Thus, kinematic information alone cannot establish a reliable distance estimate, due to this so-called ``distance ambiguity.''

    The likelihood of detecting H I self-absorption, however, favors the geometry in which a molecular cloud lies at the near kinematic distance. Since H I is ubiquitous throughout the Galaxy, warm H I emits at essentially every velocity.  For clouds at the near kinematic distance, there is an ample amount of H I at the far distance against which a cold molecular foreground cloud can be seen in silhouette.  If the same cloud were placed at the far distance, there would be very little background H I, and the self-absorption feature would be absent. Even if a ``far'' molecular cloud were to have HI self-absorption, it would not be observed since its characteristic spectral signature would be filled in by emission from H I at the foreground near position. The geometry is illustrated in a face-on sketch of the Inner Galaxy in Fig. 1.
 
 

Fig. 1: Face-on sketch of the geometry of H I self-absorption in the First Quadrant of the Milky Way. Statistically, only H I associated with molecular clouds located at the near kinematic distance will show the characteristic spectral signature of H I self-absorption. This is seen schematically in the two plots which show gray scale H I spectra with 13CO spectra superimposed as either red or blue line profiles. 


G45.6+0.3 : A Case Study

The cloud with the deepest self-absorption line, G45.6+0.3, shows pronounced visual extinction, and is therefore unequivocally located at the near kinematic distance. A second cloud with deep H I self absorption, G43.3-0.3, probably also lies at the near kinematic distance. We suggest that, since the
geometry of self-absorption favors clouds located at the near kinematic distance, then the presence or absence of self-absorption may prove to be a powerful technique to resolve the near-far distance ambiguity.


Fig. 2: Overlay of GRS 13CO J=1-0 contours towards G45.6+0.3 integrated over the velocity range 25-30 km/s on a false color image of the appropriate region from the BUAO H I Survey. Black indicates H I self-absorption. The 13CO contours start at the 3sigma level of the map. Higher intensity contours are drawn in yellow to emphasize the locations of peak  13CO emission.


Fig. 3: Overlay of the GRS 13CO J=1-0 contours from Fig. 2 towards G45.6+0.3 on a false color optical image of the appropriate region from the POSS plate (Digital Sky Survey, DSS).


Fig. 4: A comparison of GRS 13CO J=1-0 (black line) and H I (solid gray) emission towards a selected position in  G45.6+0.3. To enhance the signal to noise and properly compare the data sets, the 13CO data have been resampled to the H I resolution and grid 4'. The presence (or absence) of H I self-absorption at the 13CO velocity places the cloud at the near (or far) kinematic distance.
 
 

Fig. 5: Shown is a comparison between GRS  13CO and BUAO H I emission in longitude-LSR velocity space.  Color indicates the H I brightness temperature distribution at three galactic latitudes for the longitude range 40 < l < 46.3. Red corresponds to the strongest H I emission, blue to the weakest. The GRS 13CO emission distribution is drawn as black to white contours as intensities increase. It is clear that 13CO features correlate both with H I peaks and H I valleys.  Analysis of the H I valley spectra shows that many have the characteristic signature of H I self-absorption, indicating that the CO cloud is located at the near kinematic distance.  CO clouds associated with H I peaks are located at the far kinematic distance (see Figs. 1 through 4). Based on H I self-absorption, we indicate here with the symbols ``N'' and ``F'' whether a given 13CO emission clump is located at the Near or Far kinematic distance.
 
 

Conclusions

In comparing the 13CO Galactic Ring Survey with the BUAO H I survey, we have found that many molecular clouds exhibit both 13CO emission and H I self-absorption.  We conclude the following:

A full size version of the poster can be obtained here (gzipped postscript file)


The GRS is supported by the NSF via grant AST-9800334 and AST-0098562 The BUAO H I Survey was supported by NSF grant AST-8511844