While high-stakes, summative assessments (e.g., final exams, term papers) remain a common feature of undergraduate education, a growing body of research and practice suggests that low-stakes, formative assessments are also powerful tools to support student learning.
Part of a larger category of formative assessment that engages with students during the learning process through ongoing feedback, low-stakes assessments, such as quizzes, clicker questions, or short assignments, are frequent, small-scale evaluations that contribute minimally to students’ final grades. Their primary purposes are to give students opportunities to retrieve and apply knowledge, practice skills, and learn from feedback in a low-pressure environment (Roediger III & Henry, 2013; Bain, 2004).
Educational Benefits
- Improves achievement: Often correlated with higher subsequent exam scores (Ontong, 2021).
- Promotes knowledge retention: Promotes retrieval practice, strengthens memory, helps calibrate students’ metacognition (Kenney & Bailey, 2021).
- Reduces anxiety: Improves learning and reduces overconfidence among college students (Kenney & Bailey, 2021).
- Creates deeper engagement: Helps students involve themselves more in the subject matter of the course (Stewart-Mailhiot, 2014).
In Practice
See how BU professors and instructors are incorporating low-stakes assessment in their courses!
Boston University Large Course Initiative Examples
In collaboration with several programs in BU’s College of Arts and Sciences, the Institute is engaged in a multi-year initiative to redesign the student experience in large classes that typically have 100 or more students. This initiative provides an opportunity to reimagine and develop new approaches to course redesign, student assessment, classroom teaching techniques and the creation of instructional resources that promote engagement and learning in some of BU’s largest introductory courses.
In this video, Dr. Lynette Strickland, Assistant Professor of Biology in the College of Arts & Sciences, explains how her team uses low-stakes assessments to help students feel more confident in their knowledge of the course material and to help students learn how they learn.
Biology 1 & Biology 2
Instruction Team: Kathryn Spilios, Kale Hartmann, Lynette Strickland, Sarah Klionsky
Activity: Quizzes and knowledge checks built into the Codon digital course
The Biology team selected Codon learning platform as an alternative to the standard textbook. Their Biology course focuses on shorter, more easily digestible readings with built-in low stakes assessments rather than long chapters without much engagement. They’ve also utilized Codon readings and questions to create structured learning pathways where students are encouraged to engage with the content frequently and more thoughtfully. The Biology team has designed pre-class, in-class, and post-class activities and assessments for students using this platform.
This aligns with their learning objective to actively engage students in structured rounds of self-testing and review. Between the pre-class, in-class, and post-class questions and activities, the Biology team is leveraging nearly 1400 auto-graded interactive assessment questions that include immediate feedback. Moreover, Codon provides each learner with a personalized learning path, highlighting their progress, due dates, next steps, and suggestions for review. Learning content can also be adaptive, where certain activities, such as a practice test or review module, can only be unlocked after completing pre-requisite activities.
General Chemistry 1
Instruction Team: Binyomin Abrams, Keying Chen, Caroline Muteti
Activity: Weekly Knowledge Checks and Clickers Questions
In Chem 1, weekly online knowledge checks through Blackboard serve as a low-stakes assessment. Each short assignment covers the week’s key concepts and “big ideas,”giving students a chance to consolidate their learning without any pressure to grade these. Because the checks allow unlimited attempts, they encourage self-assessment and reflection rather than anxiety. Scheduled midweek, these knowledge checks also prepare students to engage more deeply in subsequent Thursday and Friday discussion sections.
These knowledge checks are combined with immediate in-class retrieval activities (e.g.,clickers) with delayed weekly review. This course structure is based on research that shows how spaced retrieval strengthens memory and reinforces understanding overtime (Carpenter, 2022).
Basic Statistics and Probability & Applied Statistics
Instruction Team: Emily Stephen, Jonathan Huggins, Yongho Lim
Activity: Quizzes, labs, and mini projects
The Math LCI team uses low-stakes assessments to promote learning through frequent feedback and iterative learning. Auto-graded homework on learning platforms (in this case, Edfinity) allows unlimited retries, encouraging retrieval practice to allow for self-correction without penalty.
- 5 to 6 module quizzes (graded in Gradescope) include one question per learning objective and use an alternative grading strategy called specifications-based grading (e.g., “successful,” “revisions needed,” etc.) with opportunities for retake. (Read more about specs grading in a biology course).
- Skills labs (~7 per term) were completed by students in R (statistical software platform), auto-graded via Gradescope, and permit revisions until the next session.
- Two lab mini projects use specifications grading, allowing report or presentation revisions until satisfactory.
Together, these activities accommodate spaced retrieval and metacognitive reflection across modules. The goal of this approach is to lower anxiety while emphasizing persistence and conceptual understanding. Retaking opportunities and transparent rubrics are designed to reduce performance gaps and foster equitable outcomes.
BU Low-Stakes Examples
These select BU examples show how low-stakes assessment can work in a variety of educational contexts.
Supporting Technology
Low-stakes assessments can be administered in a variety of formats. Whether you are implementing them completely on paper, online, or some mix of both, here are a few tools that can help support the implementation and evaluation of low stakes assessments as used with your students:
Blackboard Tests and Pools
Blackboard
includes a feature that allows randomized question banks, repeated attempts, and automated feedback, ideal for weekly “knowledge checks” or self-paced quizzes that promote retrieval practice.
Classroom Response Systems
Integrated with Blackboard, class response systems like Top Hat enable in-class clicker questions, polls, and discussion prompts that can serve as quick, formative checks on understanding during lectures. PointSolutions is another option, but there is a higher student cost associated with it because it relies on physical clickers that students need to purchase. PointSolutions may be preferable for some classes, as students need to be physically present with their clickers to respond to its polls.
Feedback and Assessment Platforms
Feedback and assessment platforms like
GradeScope support grading of paper-based or digital assignments, provide structured rubrics, and allow instructors to give quick feedback on low-stakes problem sets or reflections.
Google Forms and Sheets (BU Google Workspace)
A lighter alternative for short reflections, exit checks, or peer check-ins; responses can be automatically organized and visualized to identify class-wide learning patterns.
Discussion Forum Tools
Piazza is a type of discussion forum tool integrated within Blackboard that supports Q&A and discussions and allows students to anonymously post questions, share solutions, and collaboratively clarify concepts. Used as a low-stakes engagement tool, it supports peer learning, reduces participation anxiety, and enables instructors to identify common misconceptions early.
Additional Resources
Teaching Resources
This section provides additional teaching resources on low-stakes assessment for classroom implementation.
Discipline-Specific Research
This section provides additional resources organized by discipline for further information.
Biology
- Smith, M. K., Wood, W. B., Adams, W. K., Wieman, C., Knight, J. K., Guild, N., & Su, T. T. (2009). Why peer discussion improves student performance on in-class concept questions. Science, 323(5910), 122–124.
- Donato JJ, Marsh TC. 2023. Specifications Grading Is an Effective Approach to Teaching Biochemistry. J Microbiol Biol Educ. 24:e00236-22. https://doi.org/10.1128/jmbe.00236-22
Chemistry
- Vyas, V. S., Nobile, L., Gardinier, J. R., & Reid, S. A. (2023). Impact of a low-stakes assessments model with retake in general chemistry: Connecting to student attitudes and self-concept. Education Sciences, 13(12), 1235.
Math
- Morales-Almazan, P., Pan, H., & Tom, J. (2021). High-structure and its impact on performance gaps in large-enrollment frosh courses. arXiv. https://arxiv.org/abs/2111.13788
Psychology
- Bain, Ken (2004). What the Best College Professors Do. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
- Iwamoto, D. H., Hargis, J., Vuong, K., & Taitano, E. J. (2017). Analyzing the efficacy of the testing effect using Kahoot on student performance. Turkish Online Journal of Distance Education, 80–90.
- Roediger III, Henry L. (2013). ”Applying Cognitive Psychology to Education: Translational Educational Science“ Psychological Science in the Public Interest. 14(1) 1-3
Connect with the Institute for Excellence in Teaching & Learning team with questions or to schedule a consultation at excellence@bu.edu.