ECE PhD Dissertation Defense: Zahra Azad

Title: On Designing Hardware Accelerator-Based Systems: Interfaces, Taxes, and Benefits

Presenter: Zahra Azad

Advisor: Professor Ajay Joshi

Chair: TBA

Committee: Professor Ajay Joshi, Professor Ayse Coskun, Professor Rabia Yazicigil, Professor Tali Moreshet.

Abstract: Complementary MetalOxide Semiconductor (CMOS) Technology scaling has slowed down. One promising approach to sustain the historic performance improvement of computing systems is to utilize hardware accelerators. Today, many commercial computing systems integrate one or more accelerators, with each accelerator optimized to efficiently execute specific tasks.

Over the years, there has been a substantial amount of research on designing hardware accelerators for machine learning (ML) training and inference tasks. Hardware accelerators are also widely employed to accelerate data privacy and security algorithms. In particular, there is currently a growing interest in the use of hardware accelerators for accelerating homomorphic encryption (HE) based privacy-preserving computing.

While the use of hardware accelerators is promising, a realistic end-to-end evaluation of an accelerator when integrated into the full system often reveals that the benefits of an accelerator are not always as expected. Simply assessing the performance of the accelerated portion of an application, such as the inference kernel in ML applications, during performance analysis can be misleading. When designing an accelerator-based system, it is critical to evaluate the system as a whole and account for all the accelerator taxes.

In the first part of our research, we highlight the need for a holistic, end-to-end analysis of workloads using ML and HE applications. Our evaluation of an ML application for a database management system (DBMS) shows that the benefits of offloading ML inference to accelerators depend on several factors, including backend hardware, model complexity, data size, and the level of integration between the ML inference pipeline and the DBMS. We also found that the end-to-end performance improvement is bottlenecked by data retrieval and pre-processing, as well as inference. Additionally, our evaluation of an HE video encryption application shows that while HE client-side operations, i.e., message-to-cipher text and ciphertext-to-message conversion operations, are bottlenecked by number theoretic transform (NTT) operations,accelerating NTT in hardware alone is not sufficient to get enough application throughput (frame rate per second) improvement. We need to address all bottlenecks such as error sampling, encryption, and decryption in the message-to-ciphertext and cipher text-to-message conversion pipelines.

In the second part of our research, we address the lack of a scalable evaluation infrastructure for building and evaluating accelerator-based systems. To solve this problem, we propose a robust and scalable software-hardware framework for accelerator evaluation, which uses an open-source RISC-V based System-on-Chip (SoC) design called BlackParrot. This framework can be utilized by accelerator designers and system architects to perform an end-to-end performance analysis of coherent and non-coherent accelerators while carefully accounting for the interaction between the accelerator and therest of the system.

In the third part of our research, we present RISE, which is a full RISC-V SoC designed to efficiently perform message-to-ciphertext and ciphertext-to-message conversion operations. RISE comprises of a BlackParrot core and an efficient custom-designed accelerator tailored to accelerate end-to-end message-to-ciphertext and ciphertext-to-message conversion operations. OurRTL-based evaluation demonstrates that RISE improves the throughput of the video encryption application by 10X-27X for different frame resolutions.