Comments & Discussion

Boston University moderates comments to facilitate an informed, substantive, civil conversation. Abusive, profane, self-promotional, misleading, incoherent or off-topic comments will be rejected. Moderators are staffed during regular business hours (EST) and can only accept comments written in English. Statistics or facts must include a citation or a link to the citation.

There are 6 comments on Teach for America’s Wendy Kopp Is Commencement Speaker

    1. Thanks for sharing this link Andrew.

      Too bad the BU administration did not consider the ongoing critique of TFA. Seems like a teacher or principal at one of Boston’s neediest schools would have been a more valuable and inspiring as the commencement speaker.

    2. Having read the article you linked (and I’m previously unfamiliar with TFA beyond hearing the name), I can’t say I share the moral outrage of the author. It sounds a lot like how the Peace Corps operates- give people some training, give them an assignment for a few years, and then let them move on to something else. The people who want to be career teachers are the people who went to SED (or the equivalent at other universities). And as long as they have a continuous revolving door of applicants, it sounds like they would still be able to reach a lot of schools and students. As for preferring Ivy League candidates to other schools, I can understand the author’s frustration but I can’t really blame TFA for attaching themselves to as many “prestige candidates” (unsure how else to word that) as possible.

      Feel free to convince me otherwise. I’ll keep an open mind.

      1. TFA recruits are not volunteers. TFA is essentially a head-hunter and does a very modest amount of training. Districts, not TFA, still have to pay recruits a regular salary like any other teacher. Plus, districts (remember these districts are typically struggling financially) have to pay TFA fee of ~$2-5K for every placement, regardless of how long recruits stay. And, most recruits are gone after 2 years (one recent study found that only 36% remained after 2 years and 16% remained after 3). This exacerbates the high churn of inexperienced, ill-trained teachers that low income students too often get.

        TFA is only successful because it’s ideologically aligned with business interests which have provided TFA with almost $1 billion over the last 3 years.

        Check out http://reconsideringtfa.wordpress.com/ for more on TFA

  1. The big reveal of the commencement speaker was “greeted with polite applause”

    AKA “well that’s pretty lame but I guess we’ll clap for you and try not to make this awkward but really it’s your fault for mentioning Morgan Freeman like 5 seconds before this”

  2. Not to mention that it’s hugely insulting to graduating SED students.

    “Hey you spent four years and thousands of dollars for a teaching degree? This lady says someone with 5 weeks training is more qualified than you!”

    Disgraceful.

Post a comment.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *