• Corinne Steinbrenner

    Corinne Steinbrenner Profile

Comments & Discussion

Boston University moderates comments to facilitate an informed, substantive, civil conversation. Abusive, profane, self-promotional, misleading, incoherent or off-topic comments will be rejected. Moderators are staffed during regular business hours (EST) and can only accept comments written in English. Statistics or facts must include a citation or a link to the citation.

There are 9 comments on The People Demand Social Justice in Israel

  1. Very impressive. For some people, Arabs citizens’ status as second class citizens may dwarf other problems, but Takefman’s work incorporates all social justice concerns. Many more activists like Takefman are needed to bring about a better Israel.

  2. Fantastic! I feel we often have an idyllic vision of Israel here at BU much like Takefman admittedly had herself before visiting and finally seeing the harsh social injustices which exist in “the Holy Land.”

  3. The protest Takefman is talking about is aimed at economic justice,
    namely high living costs. People who are taking part in these protests
    are high school kids, students, scholars, politicians, young
    professionals, and activists from many different organizations and backgrounds.
    People are protesting for increasing costs of housing, education, health
    care and basically today’s increasing cost of living in every aspect
    of life while the salaries remain unchanged. I don’t think that the
    “harsh” social injustice is any different from any other country
    including the US. There are no ideal countries, and I agree that
    Israel should be portrayed in a more objective manner. However, AC, I
    am sure you will find Israel is a pleasant country to visit. Last
    summer, while visiting home, I went to see these protests. As
    Takefman portrayed her experience in Modiin, so was the general
    feeling in Tel Aviv as well. The protests were very cultural, with a
    lot of live music. Large groups of people can organize and protest in
    the heart of Tel Aviv. I don’t think you can do the same thing at the
    Central Park or here in the Commons.

    Regarding other Israeli minorities, the protests do not distinguish the benefits of one group over another. In other words, the call for social justice is equal for all Israeli citizens – Arab, Jews, Beduins, Russian immigrants and so on.

  4. What about the Jewish African immigrants the Israeli government is currently firebombing in an attempt to “expel” them from the country?

    1. That is something recently brought to light. As someone who grew up there, I know that from citizens’ standpoints, there is a lot of respect for African Immigrants mainly because most of them willingly choose to serve in the Army (Something that religious settler’s for example, do not do). The government may see them much like the US conservatives view illegal south and central American immigration. There is really no good reason for it and it is a shame that many issues are viewed by the government in one way and by most (Secular) citizens in another way.

  5. I researched the “Israeli Summer” protests for a project in the fall’11 semester. The social movement in Israel is important because it outlines problems that people are facing around the world: rising costs and declining benefits. However, we cannot forget the plight of the Palestinians, as Netanyahu recently announced that 300 more settlers will move to the West Bank. You can’t ignore the Israeli-Palestinian tensions while advocating for social justice…

  6. Sasha, that was very well said. The protests last summer were an expression of concrete, pure democratic values – you could stand on a box in the middle of the street, sing a song or deliver a speech and people would gather around patiently listening. Everyone had a free chance to speak there mind and talk about issues that concerned them. The shouting did not just dissolve into mid air, when something was said that felt right, people ran up from the streets (to their over-priced apartments) to draft pamphlets, write letters, make presentations and work together to outline their demands and emphasize their frustration. The police stood idly by — there was barely even a hint of violence—and they became part of this movement whether they liked it or not. Everyone was part of it. At the time, this was a sharp contrast to the brutal tyranny of the Assad government across the northern border in neighboring Syria, and The Israeli government’s reaction to the ‘social justice’ movement was an emblem of reason within the flaming Middle East!

    Here I am again, a year later and things don’t seem so easy. Sometimes people have a hard time understanding that reforms and change take time, but you cannot contain the frustration – and let’s be honest, the Netanyahu coalition has a hard time bringing significant issues to the table. People have returned to the streets, and I was sitting in a café on Rabin Square the other night watching some protesters holding up signs and chanting. It was not a large crowd, but suddenly things got out of hand. It was hard to decide who started first but the police definitely reacted with excessive aggression. The window of ‘Discount Bank’ adjacent to the café was smashed by one of the protesters, and from that point on the police could not offer any “discounts” and began beating the protesters. This night created some headlines, but one thing had become clear: This summer we do not have the police on our side, and the public will resist their tyranny.

Post a comment.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *