Comments & Discussion

Boston University moderates comments to facilitate an informed, substantive, civil conversation. Abusive, profane, self-promotional, misleading, incoherent or off-topic comments will be rejected. Moderators are staffed during regular business hours (EST) and can only accept comments written in English. Statistics or facts must include a citation or a link to the citation.

There are 7 comments on From a Refugee Camp to BU

  1. I don’t think the statement made by Mishra is true. You have just look from one side of the story but have you really gone deeper into the issues to come up with such false allegations against Bhutan. In fact, you should also think from the point of view of Bhutan’s sovereignty, where 700,000 people are peacefully residing in Bhutan rather than getting one-sided views from thousands, self claimed Bhutan refugees.

    If you have gone into depth, an immigrant from Nepal, which have settled in Bhutan prior to 1980’s were all given the Bhutanese citizenship and they are serving at a various positions right from Minister, Secretaries to the subordinate level. In each and every organization, ministries, private and corporate sectors, the key officials are all those Lhosthampas (Nepali speaking community in Bhutan).
    But the one who were claiming as Bhutan refugee are all illegal immigrants, who have forcefully come to Bhutan due to demographic explosion in the region. Not only Bhutan, every country could have intervened, if such situation arouses and if such immigrants have potential threat to the sovereignty of the country. In fact, Bhutan has given the highest citizenship status to its immigrants, refugee in the world, in terms of its size and population to the people of Nepal and Tibet. This shows that Bhutan is also one of the supporters in the humanitarian society but it should be kept in mind that none of the country in the world could have given 100% citizenship to its refugees or illegal immigrants.

    Therefore, please look from both side of the story before coming up with such story. 100% of the 700,000 Bhutanese are happy without those illegal immigrants who have carried out series of bomb attack, destroyed government properties, killed innocent people, securities personnel and made the southern Bhutan unsafe to travel alone.

    Long live king of Bhutan and may peace prevail in Bhutan.

    1. Krishna,
      On a scorching summer day when a “butcher” throws a piece of a dry bone to a loitering street dog, you should know the degree of gratitude the dog expresses to the butcher. Reason- In attempt to bite and crush down the bone, the sharp edge of the bone cuts/stabs the dog’s gums to bleed. The dog enjoys its own blood from the gums and says in a false understanding, “Ah, the bone is full of blood and so juicy!”
      Your liners clearly reveal that you are enjoying enjoying the bone thrown at you by the butcher. Sorry, perhaps as a child you were taught the wrong culture, false figures and you are made used to wood-wink and fool the world with lies to conceal the truth or overturn a story.
      Either you do not have any idea or you are pretending to not having it that the butcher you are praising had slaughtered thousands of innocent lives during late 80s and early 90s. And now you are bragging out of the bones and blood from those of the dead.
      You know this honestly that Bhutan is yet the most isolated nation in the world despite of its rich mineral and hydro power resources. Reason- No radio broadcasts are/were allowed to the public except its mouth piece, the first television was introduced in 2005, No cameras were allowed for general public during 90s, Kyunsel, the government mouth piece print media was the only news paper until 2007 and the first ever democracy was self announced by the monarch in an extremely nominal nature by its implementation in 2008. So a situation like this in a country means a “black hole” in today’s world. Such steps are taken in so design manner to keep the slaughterhouse afloat, conceal the truth coding them with lies and made up ideas that are fed forcibly to the general public like yourself and myself.
      Do you know how many times Bhutan admitted that the Bhutanese refugees were its people and then later denied. Can you deny the fact that the Royal armies confiscated the citizenships of the southern Bhutanese and forced to sign a migration form, forcing to pose happy photographs under gunpionts? Those who denied were shot and plunged into the black hole. The fact is that those who managed to flee the persecution can still produce their citizenship cards even in the countries of their resettlement. Do you remember that during a verification process toward repatriation in one of the camps the Bhutanese team verified some as innocent citizens of Bhutan while categorized even a child as old as three years as criminal? Did you enjoy the young monk’s incarceration for using tobacco last year?
      To conclude: Bhutan is doing its best to conceal the brutal violation of human rights and democracy and trying to cover it up by the ad of GNH. Well, refugees by all means are the most vulnerable people that have undergone the worst torture and trauma. The world has clearly understood that those registered Bhutanese under the UN refugee act are the victims of ethnic cleansing policy, human rights violation and torture of death by the then tyrannic Bhutanese regime.
      Gopi

      1. You have certainly provided a glimpse of bitter truth of the Bhutanese refugees. Although words cannot express the pains suffered by our ancestor back in Bhutan, it does reveal the ultimate truth. Your response helps to visualize the cruel authority of the Bhutanese government implemented during late 80s and 90s.
        No offense, but i cannot remember single thing or a thing that matters to me is in Bhutan. Since i grew up in Nepal, there is neither a thing that belongs to me is in Bhutan nor i expect a thing from Bhutan. I feel like it is useless to debate on the issues that cannot be resolved. It is time to think about a new life being escaped from such a cruel regime. I believe the place where you stay is your home and your country. One which abandons you is not your country.

  2. Dear Mishra,

    Your story is a compelling story and I’m very sorry that you had to endure the hardships you faced. But I don’t see the Bhutanese refugee story as you do. What happened in the late 80’s and early 90’s is a lot more complex and complicated than you have painted it out to be. I think mistakes were made by all parties concerned, including the Losthampa leaders of that time. It is unfair to heap all the blame on the Bhutanese government.

    You will find now that with democracy in place, people in Bhutan are exercising their voices and the right to choose their leaders. You will find that there are more than 4 or 5 independent newspapers, each vociferous in their criticism about the current government. You will find that there are serious attempts to cultivate and find practical ways to achieving Gross National Happiness.

    You will find that people respect their kings and they do this not out of fear but because they genuinely love and feel gratitude to them for keeping our little tiny country that is sandwiched between the exploding populations (and the resulting problems of poverty and political insecurity) of China, India and Nepal, still intact.

    Bhutan has its problems, which nation doesn’t, but it is not a tyrannical country as you portray it to be.

    I wish you all the best.

Post a comment.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *