BU Today

In the World

PBS and Prothero Probe God in America

Religion prof helps guide show’s survey of four centuries of church and state


Photo by Vernon Doucette

Spending five years on any project requires an act of devotion. But for Stephen Prothero, a College of Arts & Sciences professor of religion, the half-decade he’s been an editorial consultant to the PBS documentary God in America has been something more—a rare opportunity to teach us something about the role religion’s played in shaping us as a nation.

“You can’t understand American history without understanding religion,” says Prothero, who appears in the series, along with Ralph Reed, Jr., former executive director of the Christian Coalition, Ronald White, a Lincoln biographer, and John McGreevy, a professor of history at Notre Dame University. The group is described in a New York Times review of the show as “an impressive and interesting bunch.”

The six-hour documentary, concluding tonight at 9 on WGBH (Channel 2) and on PBS stations around the country, is a collaboration between the series American Experience and Frontline. Beginning with the first European settlers in the New World and ending with today’s nexus between politics and conservative evangelical efforts, this is an epic about the role of faith in American public life, as opposed to a study of different religions.

Prothero has written several books about religion in the United States; his Religious Literacy was a New York Times best seller. BU Today spoke with him about the show.

BU Today: Why was this show necessary, and what is its theme?

Prothero: It grew out of a conference five to six years ago that WGBH held that was, in part, a response to 9/11: What can public television do to educate Americans about religion? The people who did the series thought about it as a way to entertain, of course, but also to educate Americans about this incredibly important thing in American history. Whether you’re religious or not, religion matters.

The theme is about religion in American public life: throughout history, the role religion has played in American public space, religious intolerance, the role of religion in America’s politics.

Is it a good thing or a bad thing that religion is so central to American public life?

I don’t know about that. The issue for me was to get rid of some popular stereotypes: the United States is a secular country so religion doesn’t matter, the United States is a Christian country so non-Christians don’t matter, or George Bush was doing something horrible when he mixed religion and politics. They’ve mixed ever since George Washington put his hand on a Bible. I would say religion has done horrible things, and it’s done great things. How did we get slavery? In part, because people used the Bible to justify it. How did we get rid of slavery? In part, because people said it was an affront to God and justice.

Does the show break new ground or summarize existing scholarship for a lay audience?

I think it probably summarizes existing scholarship, for the most part. I think what the show does that a lot of contemporary scholarship doesn’t is tell a story.

What’s the single greatest challenge facing American religion today?

I think one of the challenges is our religious illiteracy, and that is a problem the series is trying to address. We live in a country that has always been religious, and yet we know little about our own religion and the religions of others. I was gratified after the premiere that I got a lot of email from educated people saying, “I didn’t know that.”

Is it really possible to generalize about God in America in six hours?

Yes. It’s possible to do it in a tweet. You can do it in a lifetime; you can do it in six hours. What changes as you change the time frame is the type of story you tell. The focus here is the particular moments that are emblematic—the First Great Awakening, the Second Great Awakening, the Civil War, Lincoln’s crisis—that provide some kind of window onto the greater story.

Watch a trailer for the three-part series God in America, which concludes tonight at 9 on PBS. 

Rich Barlow can be reached at barlowr@bu.edu.


3 Comments on PBS and Prothero Probe God in America

  • Anonymous on 10.13.2010 at 2:41 am

    Name of the Messiah

    – VIDEO: Rabbi Reveals Name of the Messiah… Jesus will return by 2050, say 40pc of Americans… Prophecy Unfolding? Turkey’s New Role in Mideast… THE BIBLE AND THE THIRD WORLD WAR – THE 1000 YEAR KINGDOM… Secrets of the Vatican – UFO’s in the Ancient Art:

  • Frank Bishop on 10.13.2010 at 7:41 am

    God in America

    Boston University, Mr. Prothero,

    I am quite dissapointed in this documentary, How can you do a documentary like this without mentioning the “1657 Flushing Remonstrance”. How can you do a documentary like this without including Quaker influences in Colonial America.
    How can you do such a documentary without including the William Penn Doctrine, George Fox and more. There is a stark
    diffrerence in the approach the Quaker took with the Native people in America vs the Anglican approach in Jamestown. One group came with tools and plow sheers, and one came with guns and the quest for material wealth. Personally I think you should do it all over again…Frank Bishop

  • Larry Linn on 10.14.2010 at 8:45 pm

    Religion in America

    My grandparents were Christians in Northern Ireland. She was Protestant, and he was Catholic. They had to flee after death threats. When I became of age, I volunteered and joined the Army, and I served as an 11B Infantryman. Most of my time in the field was in squad or platoon size operations. We would have discussions about what we were fighting for. It always came back to the “Bill of Rights”. To me the most important was “Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof…”
    What did our Founding Fathers have to say about religion:
    “Question with boldness even the existence of a god.” – Thomas Jefferson (letter to Peter Carr, 10 August 1787):
    “All natural institutions of churches, whether Jewish, Christian, or Turkish, appear to me no other than human inventions, set up to terrify and enslave mankind, and monopolize power and profit.” Thomas Paine, The Age of Reason;
    “Religion and government will both exist in greater purity, the less they are mixed together.”, John Madison;
    “Lighthouses are more helpful than Churches”, Benjamin Franklin

Post Your Comment

(never shown)