• Cynthia K. Buccini

    Cynthia K. Buccini Profile

Comments & Discussion

Boston University moderates comments to facilitate an informed, substantive, civil conversation. Abusive, profane, self-promotional, misleading, incoherent or off-topic comments will be rejected. Moderators are staffed during regular business hours (EST) and can only accept comments written in English. Statistics or facts must include a citation or a link to the citation.

There are 11 comments on Howard Zinn on Obama, and the Promise

  1. Let’s be honest, anyone could have won that election on a “change” platform following the Bush administration. It’s kind of sad to see very little change happening in Afghanistan and elsewhere.

  2. Let’s be realistic: what do those of you think Obama hasn’t done anything, imagine is possible in so short a time? Do you think it’s all up to him? Do you really think you can turn this mess around in a few, short months? Do you not realize that in order for any of the good changes he promised to come about, we all have to participate? God, I’m sick of hearing all this whining while everyone just sits on their duffs and waits for change. That ain’t the way it works.

  3. That’s an embarrassingly short sighted comment. Do you even go to college? Here’s some “change”:

    1) guantanamo is closing
    2) reforming healthcare (see: $19 billion appropriated in stimulus to help implement an electronic medical record system. Establishing Health IT infrastructure cannot be understated.)
    3) rebranded america (see: nobel, and Muslim relations)
    4) renewed PR from the White House (see: new media efforts including online Q&A, blogs, social media interaction, weekly video addresses)
    5) reinvested in transportation (see: 260,000 jobs created for 2500 highway projects approved)
    6) aided education (see: instituted $2,500 tax credit to help debt-burdened families afford college tuition. 5 million families will save $9 billion)
    7) aided Pakistan (see: $5 billion in aid commitments to fight internal radicalism to snuff out Taliban control before it gets worse)
    8) Signed Omnibus Public Land Management Act, the largest conservation effort of the past two decades.

    Meanwhile, Zinn is too much of a Marxist/Idealist to acknowledge those achievements in the early-going.

  4. Shortsighted, basically your list of “accomplishments” either haven’t actually happened yet (such as your first two listed) or were funded by increasing the national debt. Obama’s Nobel prize is interesting seeing as how the nominations were due last February. But I do agree Obama has much to offer in the way of relations with the muslim world. Let’s hope he succeeds.

  5. I feel good about these views being expressed in this forum. People can choose to physically go out of their way to expose themselves to the ideas that may come up in this forum, just as people can make the (much less meaningful) choice to be exposed to right wing/conservative perspectives (which are continuously given center stage in major mainstream news + opinion sources).

    It’s (not so) puzzling that even though everyone I know who has spoken with me or within earshot of me is in favor of a single-payer, free to all people, health system, and is strongly for peace and an end to violent armed occupations, neither of those issues are meaningfully represented or discussed in mainstream, consolidated media. (is it 5 or 4 companies that own all of it now?)

    thanks for reading.

  6. “Zinn, a longtime antiwar activist, has been critical of Obama, saying he has not delivered on his rhetoric. ”

    How can you expect anybody to deliver on rhetoric? It’s rhetoric!

  7. Zinn is right to make the point about Obama’s appointments; just look at who he inherited from the Clinton administration. Summers and Geithner, people who were instrumental in overturning depression era regulations including Glass-Steagall in 1999, that eventually led to the disaster that it is today. Geithner is basically a man for Citi more than he is Treasury Secretary.

Post a comment.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *