Comments & Discussion

Boston University moderates comments to facilitate an informed, substantive, civil conversation. Abusive, profane, self-promotional, misleading, incoherent or off-topic comments will be rejected. Moderators are staffed during regular business hours (EST) and can only accept comments written in English. Statistics or facts must include a citation or a link to the citation.

There are 6 comments on From Fallujah to BU, and Now on to Washington

  1. I’m a BU student and a Fallujah vet. Reading hero stories about Fallujah, like the one Sagredo just told, infuriates me. Hero stories only serve to glorify. Ask Sagredo about the civilian casualties or the families who had to flee Fallujah and wonder around in the desert. Those are the things that I remember about Fallujah, and we would all be better off to talk about those things and learn from them rather than to glorify our aggression in Iraq and with hero stories.

  2. I agree with the person who posted “Pointless hero stories”. I think a person who is trained to kill is not a hero, he or she is a victim and should not be glorified. I wish this propaganda would stop, and you would allow people to see that these men are going into a country that is not their own, to fight for an unjust cause and to cause all kinds of horrific casualties for civilians. Whatever condition they lived in the few months they are there, remember that the people in that country will suffer them more severely for years and years to come.

  3. “pointless hero” : A read of the story and I think you’ll see that this is not about making him a hero. This article is about a man who mentors students at BU. It tells what he did before he came here and what he will be moving on to. I’m sorry about your time in Iraq. However, if you want talk about the results of war, BU Today probably isn’t the forum. However, there are many publications that do fill that need.

    BU Today: Great Story.

  4. Pointless hero stories- First of all being in the military I would hope you know the respect you should give senior enlisted, especially a Master Sergeant. I would assume that BU Today approached Master Sergeant Sagredo to honor his time serving BU not to relive war stories. A hero is defined as someone with exceptional courage. I believe Master Sergeant Sagredo fits that title. This story does not glorify war by any means. His role is to show the kids he mentors the harsh reality of what they are volunteering to do. I believe every veteran is a hero. They sacrifice their lives to help protect your freedoms. If you think that defending Americans from the actions of terrorists is doing more harm than good, why don’t you fix the problem and we will see if the problem goes away.

  5. I am not sure why someone who has zero experience with anything military related like the person who submitted “I agree with the person who..” even thinks that he or she has any type of right to talk. You are so sheltered living in a place like Boston and going to BU, that you have no idea what the real world is like. There is a whole lot more to this war and what is going on than propaganda and the crap that is shown on television. You think television and newspapers show any accuracy to what is going on in the war? NONE is the answer. Even people who go over to Iraq and Afghanistan in the press do not know what is going on because they do not have all the information. You “I agree with the person who..” are so clearly brainwashed that you think you have any right or say anything or that your words have any merit. Your words mean nothing. Get a clue and think before you speak. No single person, especially a civilian has enough information to make a comment about a war situation. You just keep going on enjoying your comfortable life because you have no idea what it is like to be in a horrible situation like that.

    P.S. Marines fight for each other and to protect people like you because that is what your beloved new president tells them to do.

  6. I served with Sagredo in Fallujah ’04. He pulled an injured friend of mine from a burning track. He is as humble and selfless a Marine as I ever served with, and all the more deserving of a gracious acknowledgement of his service because of that. If you’ve got an axe to grind over Fallujah or any other of your personal experiences, so be it. There is no need to impugn another Marine’s character because of your own issues.

Post a comment.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *