Comments & Discussion

Boston University moderates comments to facilitate an informed, substantive, civil conversation. Abusive, profane, self-promotional, misleading, incoherent or off-topic comments will be rejected. Moderators are staffed during regular business hours (EST) and can only accept comments written in English. Statistics or facts must include a citation or a link to the citation.

There are 10 comments on Rock from Axl to Zep

  1. Rock died with Guns’n’Roses in 1990? Seriously?!?! What about Nirvana, Soundgarden, & The entire Seattle scene? What about Rage Against the Machine? What about the new genres of Electro House and Indie Dance that are coming out of electronic music?!?!? Mr. Davis should put his ear back tot the ground like he did in 1975 and GET WITH THE TIMES. I just can’t agree that rock is dying with so much energy surrounding it. As long as we have tragedy (and believe me, there’s more to come!) there will be rock. PS – If my vote matters, Mr. Davis, do the Debbie Harry book. She was awesome. As for new folks, you should really check out the French electro rock scene. You heard it here first! – Peace.

  2. Guns n’ roses? the last of the hard rock albums? i think you need to take another listen. please. for your sake. and p.s., i don’t give a flying whatever about axl’s farts. thanks.

  3. don’t even DARE calling Nirvana rock n roll man. they are one of the biggest piles of s**t to land on music and are the reason music fell in to the pit its in now!

  4. chinese democracy? what kind of ridiculous title for a cd is that?

    that smell isn’t axl’s farts, it’s gonna be the smell of shit coming from a hefty pile of unsold gnr junk.

  5. Despite Zeppelin’s denial to the contrary, a case for them as a heavy metal act can be made, particularly since the band spawned so many metal groups. The cultural and musical context in which Led Zeppelin performed and produced has changed dramatically, and the definition of metal has fractured and evolved. When I was growing up in 1980s, all my metalhead friends were obsessed with Zeppelin and the musicians among us emulated them musically. Ultimately, it’s probably too hard to classify Zeppelin one particular way or another, a testament to their enduring appeal.
    — Caleb

  6. Great article, Caleb! I would, however, quibble with this sentence: “Even concerts have become passive — and expensive — forms of entertainment, with popcorn and concessions, rather than a communion, rooted in rebellion, between artist and audience. ” That may be true in mainstream rock, but there are still *plenty* of exciting small-time rock ‘n’ roll shows in local clubs, not to mention a thriving scene of (often literally) underground hardcore punk rock shows in basements, warehouses, rented VFW halls, etc., in which there are zero barriers between artist and audience. Nothing groundbreaking, as that’s been the case for 30 years, but it’s no less exciting for those kids who get into it each year. See scenes from one in this video, for example: http://www.myspace.com/basement_brigade

  7. But please for the love of god don’t say rock ended with Axl. Get out of that Arena rock mentality and follow the other comments’ advice. Real rock was created outside the Arena, anyway.

Post a comment.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *