Comments & Discussion

Boston University moderates comments to facilitate an informed, substantive, civil conversation. Abusive, profane, self-promotional, misleading, incoherent or off-topic comments will be rejected. Moderators are staffed during regular business hours (EST) and can only accept comments written in English. Statistics or facts must include a citation or a link to the citation.

There are 12 comments on “New College” to Replace UNI

  1. The demise of the University Professors Program was unexpected and unfortunate–we’re still waiting to hear the full story of how it came about. While I am not a UNI student, I believe this is undoubtedly one of the university’s great losses.

    Undergraduate students with interdisciplinary aspirations now have New College–but what is to come of UNI graduate students?

    – Abdur-Rahman Syed (PhD Program, Philosophy)

  2. As a parent, the description of the New College program strikes me as ‘watered down’ and not worth the money. The appeal of a UNI education was it’s uniqueness, prestige and respect within the private sector. The New College program won’t be nearly as powerful nor garner the higher starting salaries and better job positions that come with a UNI degree.

    And why would a student choose to take on the additional burden of the New College program (thesis, etc) when similar programs are available all over the country? Why would world-class professors want to come to BU as part of this program?

    A BU education is valuable in itself, but the point of graduating with a powerful degree like UNI was to be more marketable and present added value in the working world. That concept seems to have been lost with this “New” program. Now it’s just education for education’s sake.

  3. A minor detail in an over-all informed article,
    the adhoc committee evaluating UNI did not call for its disolution.
    Nevertheless, the honors program will encompass at least some of the principles UNI stood for, albeit in a watered-down form.

  4. Actually I heard from a few UNI students that it was pretty worthless. They said the students and professors constantly evoked an elitist attitude and that employers didn’t understand the degree. Most of my friends who were in UNI switched out because of this.

    This new college may alleviate some of those issues though.

  5. In my opinion, New College sounds too green; the name suggests a program that is inexperienced. I graduated BU in 2006 and know several people that had a positive experience through UNI. Sadly, I did not know much about the program while I was applying to BU, but once I heard the name “University Professors Program,” it sounded catchy and sophisticated. When I read about “New College,” I thought it would be a more appropriate replacement for BU Academy than for UNI. The name is a downgrade and the program may be as well.

    If BU is going to introduce any new programs for honor students, it needs to be comprehensive. Make sure that employers know the significance of the degree. When you apply for a job and have “Harvard” or “Yale” written on your CV, you look impressive. When you have “New College” written on your CV, you look like you didn’t study for the SATs.

    Andrey Ostrovsky- CAS ’06 MED ’10

  6. The original New College at Oxford is notable for a huge mound it sports, where the dead from the plague are buried. While this obviously does not have a substantial impact on the quality of the education offered at the new New College, it does make one curious about the motivations behind deciding to co-opt that name.

  7. As a UNI graduate student, I cannot comment on the the new undergrad college. However, what strikes me is that there is absolutely no mention in the new plan about the graduate education which, I believe, has always been an indespensable part of UNI and one of the core features that attracted both excellent students and faculty to UNI. Due to their multidisciplinary basis, UNI’s Ph.D. alumni have been very successful in their job search – you can just go to the UNI website to find out. If the graduate component is taken away from the New College’s agenda, the new school will immediately loose a part of its uniqueness, attractiveness, and appeal. Besides, a multidisciplinarity in the graduate education is very difficult to achieve if you are pursuing your Ph.D. in an “ordinary” departement. Abolition of the UNI’s graduate program is, therefore, a great loss for both the BU students and broader BU community.

  8. I do not understand why BU dissolved a successful college, but continues to operate the College of General Studies. CGS significantly decreases BU’s prestige and contributes to an embarrassing 59% acceptance rate.

  9. I’m sad to hear of UNI being dissolved. I got my PhD from UNI as a European student and was told that it was for exceptional students; the program had a number of problems, not least in the fact that there was not enough program-centred co-ordination of intellectual activity, and there was no guidance given on career development or on translating what one had achieved for people less broadly educated; while the research was long and incredibly arduous and I lived like a penurious church-mouse, I was supported throughout by the marvellous staff. However, over the past 18 years as I have lived in 5 countries, I have realised that I received at UNI one of the most superb educations (sic) that I could have received anywhere in the world. I studied under leading individuals in about 8 departments in three universities, and learned a breadth of interdisciplinary knowledge and skills that no-one else has whom I have met in my work since. UNI was a beacon of intelligence in education. It is deeply saddening that it is losing its graduate program and being reduced to high-volume undergraduate studies; that it will be interdisciplinary is really not the point. There is room for both a UNI and a ‘New College’.

  10. I received a Ph.D. from the University Professors Program and I am proud to be associated with this Program and the University. Having this kind of Program, which is separate from other University departments and schools, allowed me to be creative and interdisciplinary in my scholarship and allowed me to interact with other departments and schools within the University. The UNI faculty are outstanding scholars with international recognition. Another strength of UNI is the ability to grant degrees from the Program. A BU degree is greatly respected, but a degree from the University Professors Program gives a scholarly distinction, which has enhanced the overall reputation of BU. My experience has been that my degree is recognized and greatly respected by employers and other academic institutions.

    I am very disappointed with the termination of this Program and hope there would be a reconsideration of retaining it in addition to an expanded honor program.

  11. why is that always the departments that are supposed to change the conventional ways of thinking are the ones to be shut down? the only one department that was open to all kinds of students and learning is now closed and no one was asked. why?

  12. The New College sounds as if it loses the intellectual rigor and integrity prevalent when I was a student, driven by a group of world class professors and motivated students. If that sounds elitist, it is. UNI was not your 500-student-in-a-lecture-hall-taught-by -a-T.A.-program – it was for those interested in a serious pursuit of the intellect, founded in the Classics while cast in the modern, with the freedom to grow to the future, as opposed to just getting a degree from a great university. Throughout my career at BU, I did far more in-depth work than your average student – by design – and had PhD level relationships as an undergrad with my program professors, who drove me to excel, rather than punching my class sign-up sheet and pushing me into the standard ‘majors’ route. Your moder undergrad degree, even from top schools, is just the minimum entry price for the professional career world and there is very little differentiation in actual real world performance dependent on which school you attended.

    I think it is tremendous that the Honors program concept is being expanded – UNI did suffer from being small and exclusive – but we earned that right through our prior academic performance. Face it, many people just don’t perform academically, so why should they get the same academic benefits? It is very much that way in the post-University world. It would be ideal if the New College – which is a ridiculous name – retained the same intellectual discpline and required when I was a student but it sounds like a watered down version designed to make make more people feel ‘special’ by letting more parents say their kids are in the ‘Honors’ program and thus effectively, lower the standards. If we are all ‘unique’ then none of us are, because standards are not just lower, there is nothing to compare them to. And to make it worse, let’s wrap it all up in a series of highly emotive, non-offensive nor disciplined linguistics to describe courses and programs that are fluff to the ear and milksop to the intellect. What a travesty.

Post a comment.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *