Comments & Discussion

Boston University moderates comments to facilitate an informed, substantive, civil conversation. Abusive, profane, self-promotional, misleading, incoherent or off-topic comments will be rejected. Moderators are staffed during regular business hours (EST) and can only accept comments written in English. Statistics or facts must include a citation or a link to the citation.

There are 12 comments on Be Bobby Flay, Not Chef Boyardee

  1. Using a knife sharpening rod, I have sharpened hundreds of knives, dull from watermelons and misuse (doin’t use the cutting edge of your knife to scrape the cutting board, use the back edge). IMO – Counter top knife sharpeners are a waste of money and counter space.

    However, I gotta agree about the All-Clad stainless. Great balance, thick layered for even heating (although the copper core has a better pouring lip on the saucepans). And I also agree about knife sets: an 8-inch Chef’s knife, a Bread knife, and a paring knife (in that order) are are the knives you really need.

  2. Is this really what we want to teach young people who would like to cook themselves a healthy meal – that if they can’t afford to spend $1000 on kitchen supplies that they shouldn’t even bother? Don’t get me wrong, I’m not opposed to being the proud owner of a $130 food processor, a $200 standing mixer and a $190 skillet. When I hit the lottery I’ll buy them for myself. In the meantime, I’ve been cooking for myself and my family for years without any of the above. Shame on Chris Kimball for forgetting that healthy food can be cooked in the humblest of kitchens with a little care and creativity.

  3. I agree with the first comment. The article is absolutely ridiculous. It imbues upon the reader the idea that good food can only be prepared using expensive kitchen tools. In one memorable line,

    “Buy something substantial; you’ll burn your food if you don’t have a heavy saucepan or skillet.” As if it were impossible to not burn food in an expensive, heavy saucepan, or vice versa, impossible not to have a properly prepared meal on a cheap pan.

    Perhaps in a world where everyone had the benefit of wealthy parents and hedge funds, this would be reasonable advice. The entire article simply lists various, expensive kitchen items.

    The good chef, or cook for that matter, is not dependent upon expensive tools, but genuine sill.

    Disappointing, to say the least.

  4. Ok, here’s the problem. This guy is rich. He’s clearly totally disjointed from reality. He doesn’t look that old, but he’s apparently already forgotten what it’s like to be broke. I rode my bike to Watertown and rode back with a box of pots & pans which I bought for $28. It took like three hours, but it was cheaper than at Bed Bath & Beyond. I got 2 nice non-stick frying pans and 2 decent boiling pots. Oh no, they have plastic handles…….?! And $28 for a knife? Just steal one from the dining halls.
    Don’t be a snob. It doesn’t take good cooking utensils to be a good chef. It just takes creativity, herbs, and time. (I’d much rather have bayleaf & garlic & basil & thyme than some $150 frying pan…)
    Cheers.

  5. these are ridiculous suggestions for a college student. All someone needs are a few good pans and some spatulas (and etc) and a baking dish. Thats all I have used for the four years I have lived alone throughout college and grad school and I make amazing meals. Recently I added a crock pot which is GREAT because I can cook without having to actually do anything except throw things in. I don’t think this was even mentioned! The big problem here is that the life of a college student wasn’t even taken into consideration. And they are charging 25$ to hear this crap! Something that is common sense, buy everything at the store except a bread machine.

  6. Perhaps knife sharpeners have come of age; I’ve never found one I’d care to sacrifice a good knife to. I taught myself to build an edge with a sharpening stone, and I highly recommend at least trying it, starting with an inexpensive blade – you’ll probably ruin the knife, but if you keep going, you’ll get the edge back, and better than ever, through your own efforts….kinda like learning to fish, it’s a skill that lasts a lifetime & improves with age.

    As for Kimball’s big-ticket recommendations: don’t think of it as one big ticket: only buy what you need, but get the best you can afford; if you can’t afford All-Clad, get a good cast-iron skillet & learn to take care of it (hey, you’re learning to cook – taking care of your tools is a prime piece of that). Get one good knife, and learn to use it – it’ll be awhile before you really need another. Food-processors and stand mixers are upstream, not at all pressing or urgent for almost everyone.

    Relax, take your time, enjoy yourself: with the right attitude, cooking is only slightly less fun than eating!

  7. How much do you spend a week on beer? Give me a break. Can’t afford $28 for a knife so you encourage people to commit petty larceny? GET A JOB.

  8. I think he is probably correct in the idea of getting one or two pans for college…but the idea of paying that amount is insane. LOL… I think I would put that money to good use buy stocking my fridge and going to Savers or the goodwill to find a pan until I am out of college and can get something better.

  9. I take exception to his recommendation for a knife sharpener as well, except only because that one is SUPER expensive. You could have the sharpest knives of any college kid and only spend $20. http://tinyurl.com/3oem6r

    Sorry, but I’ve seen at least 10 times the number of knives dulled by people using a rod vs. a knife sharpeners. Holding that 20 degree angle simply takes too much practice.

    Also, the people I know with sharpening rods simply don’t use them enough. Those people often have dull knives while those of us that use the SUPER convenient, fast, and fool proof knife sharpeners have consistently sharp knives.

    I’ve been using the same knife for 15 years with the same sharpener and my knife is almost always sharper than any knife I find in the kitchen of my friends. Why? Because I sharpen it every single week.

    I’m not against people using rods (my father still does and my restaurant friends, of course), but for most normal people, counter top knife sharpeners end up being the best way to go.

    I’m open to others opinions.

    http://foodies.blogspot.com

Post a comment.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *