Doing Library Research

Skill Set 8: Evaluating and Revising Search Results

Number of Questions by Topic in Project SAILS Survey
# of Questions Topic
   
   
   
   
   

Focus of SAILS questions:

  1. Appropriateness of resources
  2. Narrowing and expanding results
  3. Using bibliographies to find more information

Comments

  • SS 8 does not have enough content to stand as its own module
  • Combine with SS 4 (Types of Finding Tools) and SS 1 (Developing a Research Strategy)

Outline

  • Selecting and Evaluating Resources
  • Search Strategies: Narrowing and Expanding Results
  • Bibliographies

A. Selecting and Evaluating Resources

1. See SS 4 "Types of Finding Tools. Integrate into discussion the answer to the question: What type of resource should I use? Use UCLA's "Flow of Information" chart (http://www.library.ucla.edu/libraries/college/help/flow/hint.htm) as a starting point - perhaps expand to include types of authors etc (see http://www.lib.duke.edu/libguide/select_table.htm).

a. Visual No. 1

Report of Event

Time Frame

How to Find

Radio/TV/Internet News Services

Seconds/minutes

TV News Indexes; Web Search Tools

Newspapers (print)

Day / Days+

Newspaper Indexes

Magazines (print)

Week / Weeks

Periodical Indexes

Journals (print & electronic)

6 months +

Periodical Indexes; Bibliographies

Books

2+ years

Library Catalog; WorldCat; Bibliographies

Reference Sources -- e.g. Encyclopedia; Handbook (print & electronic)

ave. 10 years

Library Catalog; Virtual Reference Shelf; Bibliographies

**Use Captivate to show website navigation to find above mentioned research tools.

b. Visual No. 2

Information Timeline

Present

Day

Week

Months

Years

Arrow

Web

Newspapers

Popular Magazine

Scholarly Journals

Reference Sources

Books

B. Search Strategies: Narrowing and Expanding Results

1. See SS1 - Developing a Research Strategy - Identifying your topic. Expand discussion of keyword searching to obtain desired results. Include discussion about selecting keywords by using concepts?

Concept One

Concept Two

Concept Three

recycl*

domestic

waste*

reuse

household

refuse

a. Visual No. 1

  • Boolean Searching (See Show Me: How Do I Search? )

b. Visual No. 2

Cheat Sheet for Expanding or Narrowing Results

Too many results?

Too few results?

Add another keyword to your search using the connector AND

Have you misspelled or mistyped any search terms?

Limit your search by: language, year of publication, journal title, or publication type

Use synonyms and alternative words joined by OR

Focus your search by using the database's thesaurus or index

Truncate your search terms to pick up variant spellings

Is the database you are using is appropriate for your search topic? (Link to eresources by subject)

C. Bibliographies

1. Use bibliography to find related resources.

2. How to read a citation

D. Visual

1. Elements of a citation appearing one by one

 

 

     
771 Commonwealth Avenue  |  Boston, MA  |  02215  |  617-353-3710  |  Boston University
Boston University Libraries