Introduction to International and Foreign Legal Research
While the process of legal research in any jurisdiction follows the same basic steps, US legal sources differ from foreign legal sources. There are also numerous helpful resources specifically for researching international law, including treaties, decisions of international and regional tribunals, as well as materials from the United Nations and European Union.
Regardless of the jurisdiction, it is best to start any legal research project with secondary sources. Secondary legal sources include treatises, loose-leaf services and law review articles. There are many international and foreign secondary sources.
This guide is a quick overview of some of the resources you may need to consult. In the course of your research, if you have any questions or would like to discuss researching a particular topic, please contact the reference librarians.
Researching International Law
Public international law differs from private international law. Private international law governs relationships between individuals; whereas public international law deals with the interactions between states or other international bodies. The sources of international law are international agreements, customary law, judicial decisions and academic writings.
If the materials you require are not available at any of the Boston University libraries, you can request many materials through interlibrary loan. Consult a reference librarian for more information.
Reference Resources
There are numerous resources at the Pappas Law Library to assist you with international legal research.
For an overview of international legal research or information about a specific topic within international law, take a look at:
- Guide to International Legal Research (Law Ref Desk KZ 1234 . G85 2004)
- Germain's Transnational Legal Research: A Guide for Attorneys (Law Ref Desk K 85 G47 1991)
- Accidental Tourist on the New Frontier: An Introductory Guide to Global Legal Research (Law Ref Desk K85 .A23 1998)
- Encyclopedia of Public International Law (Law Annex Ref JX 1226 E5 1992)
- Public International Law in a Nutshell (Law Reserve and Law Annex JX 3091 .B84 2002)
To decipher international, as well as foreign legal abbreviations, try:
- Bieber's Dictionary of Legal Abbreviations (Law Ref Desk, Law Annex, Law Reserve and Dictionary K 89 B53 2001) (easy to use in print, but also available through Lexis)
- Noble's Revised International Guide to Law Reports (LawRef Desk K 38 N63 2002)
- The Bluebook: A Uniform System of Citation (Law Ref Desk and Dictionary KF 245 B55 2005)
- Raistrick's Index to Legal Citations and Abbreviations (Law Ref Desk K 85 R3 1993)
- Guide to Foreign and International Legal Citations (Law Ref Desk K 89 .G85 2006)
- Georgetown Law School's research guide on deciphering international law Abbreviations and Acronyms which includes some of the suggestions above as well as other helpful sources.
- Please note, the ALWD Citation Manual does not address international and foreign legal citations
For citing international and foreign materials, refer to: The Bluebook: A Uniform System of Citation, 18th edition (Law Ref Desk, Dictionary, Law Reserve and Law Annex Ref KF 245 B55 2005):
- Rule 21: International Materials (p.168)
- Rule 20: Foreign Materials (p. 164)
- T.2 Foreign Jurisdictions (p. 243)
- T.3 Intergovernmental Organizations (p. 332)
- T.4 Treaty Sources (p. 334)
- T.5 Arbitral Reporters (p. 335)
International Primary Sources
Many of the primary documents you will encounter in the area of public international law will be international agreements. International agreements, including treaties, can be bilateral, between two countries, or multilateral, among several countries. In general, it is not difficult to find bilateral or multilateral treaties to which the United States is a party or other multilateral treaties. However, finding bilateral treaties to which the United States is not a party may be more challenging.
For treaties on a particular topic (i.e. environment, intellectual property, law of the sea, etc.), consult Treaty Resources by Topic and search the online catalog to locate loose-leaf services and books on the topic. Often, the text of important international agreements are collected in these publications. Many international organizations include the text of treaties relevant to their particular interest on their web sites.
Once a treaty is in force, internationally, it is binding on the parties. Within the US, treaties to which the US is a party are equal in status to federal legislation, i.e., becoming part of the "supreme Law of the Land." Note that there are a few differences between a treaty and an executive agreement.
To look up any unfamiliar treaty jargon, try the treaty terminology reference guide from the United Nations. You can also consult helpful treaty research guides on the web:
- United States Treaty Research Guide from Boston University Pappas Law Library
- Non-US Treaty Research Guide from Boston University Pappas Law Library
- Finding a Treaty When You Have a Citation and Finding a Treaty When You Don't Have a Citation from Harvard Law School Library
- Researching U.S. Treaties and Agreements by Marci Hoffman, via Law Library Resource Exchange (revised 2005)
- Researching Non-U.S. Treaties by Stefanie Weigmann, via Law Library Resource Exchange
If you have the name of a particular treaty and it is a major treaty, it may be separately bound and held in the library. Search the web catalog.
Selective List of Helpful Electronic Resources to find treaties to which the US is a party, accessible through BU:
- TIARA Researcher (access through IP address) - includes the full-text of all US treaties currently in force as well as citations to print resources.
- To access this resource, select "Connect via IP Access" from the list of "Oceana Online" options. You will then be able to select Treaties & International Agreements on the next page.
- Lexis and Westlaw:
- USTRTY (Lexis): coverage is from 1783 onward
- USTREATIES (Westlaw): coverage is from 1788 to present
- HeinOnline Treaties and Agreements Library - includes many helpful finding aids, including the following:
- Treaties in Force - indexing tool (this is also available for free through the US State Department)
- Guide to Treaties in Force - guide to using the indexing tool
- United States Treaties and Other International Agreements (UST) (also available on Westlaw and Lexis)
- Treaties and Other International Acts (TIAS)
- Treaties and Other International Agreements of the United States of America, 1776-1949 (commonly referred to as "Bevans") - indexing tool
- International Legal Materials ("unofficial" treaty source), also available on Westlaw and Lexis
Customary International Law
For customary international law, derived from the practices of countries, look in secondary sources like treatises and other books.
International and Regional Tribunals
Some of the international entities which issue judgments or decisions include:
- International Court of Justice (ICJ), created by the Charter
of the United Nations, has jurisdiction extending to all states,
whether or not they are members of the United Nations. The predecessor
to the ICJ was the PCIJ, the Permanent Court of International
Justice. ICJ decisions are found:
- Reports of Judgments, Advisory Opinions & Orders (Law Annex JX1971.6 I54)
- Select recent decisions can be found in International Legal Materials in paper (Law Annex) and online through HeinOnline (.pdf) or on-line on LexisNexis (INTLAW:ILM) or Westlaw (ILM). Many links to sites that are used in compiling the contents of the International Legal Materials, are available on the Internet from the American Society for International Law.
- Westlaw has all ICJ decisions (INT-ICJ) from 1947-2000, with selected coverage from 2001 (see scope of coverage of this database)
- Lexis has ICJ decisions from 1948 to present, ICJ judgments from 1948 to present, and ICJ Advisory Opinions
- Cornell hosts an ICJ mirror site with most recent decisions
- Pleadings, Oral Arguments, Documents of the ICJ (Law Annex JX 1971.6 I52)
- Digest of the Decisions of the ICJ (Law Annex JX 1971.9 F66X T.7)
- Refer to the Harvard Law School ILS Reference Department guide to the ICJ and PCIJ
- European
Court of Justice and the Court
of First Instance are the judicial
arms of the European Union. Consult
the Pappas Law Library European Union Research Guide to learn
more about the courts
of the EU. You may also want to review European Union Law in a Nutshell, Law Annex and Law Reserve, KDE949 .F55 2005) or review the research portal on European Union Human Rights for selected materials on that topic.
- International Criminal Court
(ICC) was established recently by the Rome
Statute. While the ICC has not yet decided any cases, there
are already many background
documents, members elected and other information available.
Additionally, search the online
catalog to locate books which BU holds on the establishment
of the ICC.
- International Criminal
Tribunal for Rwanda was established by the Security Council
of the United Nations. It was created so that those persons responsible
for committing the genocide and other international humanitarian
law violations between January 1, 1994 and December 31, 1994,
could be prosecuted. Decisions are available online, as well as
bilateral agreements, and a searchable
database of public records. It has a very helpful page on
"links to other resources" that can also be used by
researchers. (Please note the site map is helpful to navigating
the web site as it has been designed by using frames.)
- Also available on Westlaw
- INT-ICTR (International Criminal Tribunal for Rwanda) (scope of coverage within this database)
- INT-ICT (International Criminal Tribunal - Combined) (scope of coverage within this database)
- Also available on Westlaw
- International Criminal Tribunal
for Yugoslavia was also established by the Security Council
of the United Nations through Resolution 827 (May 25, 1993) in
order to prosecute violations of international humanitarian law
that took place in the former Yugoslavia since 1991. Its web site
provides (yet notes they are "unofficial documents")
judgments, decisions, orders and transcripts pertaining to the
indictments it has already undertaken. Its site also includes
annual reports of the Tribunal's activities since 1994 as well
as back issues of the Judicial Supplement since 1999. The Judicial
Supplement is the monthly law review of the Tribunal which
provides summaries of judgments, orders and decisions of the Tribunal
which it feels are "significant to international humanitarian
and criminal law."
- Also available on Westlaw
- INT-ICTY (International Criminal Tribunal for the Former Yugoslavia - Cases) (scope of coverage for this database)
- INT-ICT (International Criminal Tribunal - Combined) (scope of coverage for this database)
- INT-ICTY-BLD (International Criminal Tribunal for the Former Yugoslavia - Basic Legal Documents) (scope of coverage for this database)
- INT-ICTY-ALL (International Criminal Tribunal for the Former Yugoslavia - Combined) (scope of coverage for this database)
- INT-ICTY-PR (International Criminal Tribunal for the Former Yugoslavia - Press Releases) (scope of coverage for this database)
- Also available on Westlaw
Regional and other organizations' courts and tribunals, including:
- Inter-American Court of Human Rights: reports of cases are available in print (Law Annex KDZ 579 I56 A82) and online through the University of Minnesota and through the World Legal Information Institute (1987- present).
- European Court of Human
Rights ("ECHR"): reports and decisions are available in
paper (Law Annex K3239.5 E97) and online through the ECHR's
web site as well as the World
Legal Information Institute (1960-present).
- Westlaw
- EHR-RPTS (European Human Rights Reports). Click here to review the scope and coverage of the EHR-RPTS database.
- HR-RPTS-ALL (UK Human Rights Reports All). Click here to review the scope and coverage of the HR-RPTS-ALL database.
- Lexis
- Human Rights Cases (coverage from 1960-)
- Westlaw
- World Trade Organization issues documents,
including Panel and Appellate Body Reports.
- Westlaw
- WTO-DEC (WTO and GATT Decisions). Click here for the scope and coverage of this database.
- Westlaw
The United Nations
Learn more about the structure and work of the United Nations, its main bodies, see a diagram of the UN, its publications and databases, visit the News Centre and more at the information-packed UN web site.
Search the BU online catalog for books about the United Nations and its various bodies, such as:
- Yearbook of the United Nations (Law Annex JX 1977 .A1 U53)
- Basic Documents of the United Nations (Law Annex JX 1977 A15 U5)
- United Nations Commission on International Trade Law Yearbook (Law Annex JX 1977 .A1 U46)
- Yearbook on Human Rights (Law Annex JX 1977 .A1 U54)
- UN Chronicle (Mugar JX 1977 .A1 F64) which serves as a newsletter for the
UN.
Finding United Nations Documents
- UN documents fiche collection (Law Micro) 1946-1950 and from 1976- present. Also, Trade (UNCTAD) documents 1976-present and Human Rights documents 1986-present. Mugar has the complete core UN microfiche collection (Mugar Micro Fiche).
- AccessUN: This
Internet database, secured by IP address, is accessible at
all BU computers. It is also accessible off-campus to all
BU faculty and students through the proxy
server.
- Search AccessUN to find UN document numbers for use with the fiche set (see above) or find select full-text documents. (Does not include full-text of treaties, but provides citations to the United Nations Treaty Series, or UNTS.)
- Covers documents issued 1946 through present.
- Harvard Law School's ILS Department has prepared a guide to using Access UN with valuable information regarding using search terms, connectors and the most helpful fields by which you can search.
- UNDOC: Current index: United Nations Documents Index. (1979-1996) (Law Micro JX1977.A1 U45)
- UNDEX. United Nations documents index. (Mugar Reference X JX1977 .A2 ) Series A, B, C (1974-1979)
- United Nations documents index: cumulated index, (1950-1962) (Law Annex Ref JX1977.A1 U42 1974)
- United Nations Documentation Centre includes documents for the General Assembly, Security Council, Economic and Social Council, as well as selected documents from the Secretariat.
- Use a search engine such as Google, and search by UN document number.
United Nations Document Research Guides
- United Nations Documentation Research Guide from United Nations Dag Hammarskjöld Library
- United Nations Documents Symbols System from the Harvard Law School ILS Reference Department
- How to Find United Nations Documents from the Harvard Law School ILS Reference Department
- United Nations Documents and Publications from the Jonsson Library of Government Documents at Stanford University
The European Union
The Europa web site and the Pappas Law Library European Union Guide are helpful resources for learning about the EU. Also, the European Commission Delegation in Washington provides a helpful A-Z Index to European Union web sites. The EISIL (Electronic Information System for International Law) web site also provides helpful information regarding the European Union, with persistent links to its primary documents, brief explanations regarding these documents, and to helpful European Union-related web sites.
- Finding EU documents (part of the BU Law Library's research guide on European Union Research)
Other EU research guides which can be of assistance include:
- Guide to European Union Research from the Harvard Law School ILS Reference Department
- The European Union at a Glance from Europa
- The European Union from the University of California at Berkeley
- Research Guide: European Union Legal Materials from the Arthur W. Diamond Law Library at Columbia Law School
- LLRX.com guide - European Union Law: An Integrated Guide to Electronic and Print Research by Marilyn J. Raisch
- European Union Legal Materials: an Infrequent User's Guide, from Duncan Alford, available on NYU Globalex
Locating International Secondary Sources
- Books: Use the BU online catalog to search for books and loose-leaf services related to international law.
- Periodicals: To find the location of periodicals, including law reviews and newspapers, search the BU online catalog for the title of the journal or newspaper, i.e. Harvard Law Review, New York Times, etc.
You can verify or locate citations to legal periodical articles by searching:
- Legaltrac: An index of law review articles from 1980 to present. Also on Westlaw (LRI) and LexisNexis (LGLND). This database indexes English-language articles from countries such as the US, UK, Canada, Australia, New Zealand, and Ireland. It consists of mainly abstracts but does contain some full-text articles.
- Index to Foreign Legal Periodicals: This database, secured by IP address, is available from any computer on the BU campus. The IFLP indexes articles about international and comparative law of countries other than United States, British Isles, and British Commonwealth.
- Hein Online (BULaw only) provides access to many older, as well as current, law journal volumes in full-text which are NOT available on LexisNexis and Westlaw. Articles are in Adobe's .pdf format.
- Legal Journals Index (LJI): This index is only available on Westlaw. Coverage is from 1986 to present. This index provides "references to or abstracts of articles from more than 430 legal journals published in the United Kingdom and other European countries or covering topics pertaining to the laws of the European Union and its member states" per its scope note.
- Full text law review databases on Westlaw and LexisNexis. However, please be aware, the date coverage of law review articles varies greatly. (Always check the source information or scope screen corresponding to the particular database.) Some helpful databases include:
- Tip: search the full-text of law review articles on LexisNexis and Westlaw to locate or verify a citation or quote.
Locating news articles:
- Search newspapers which the BU libraries hold using the online catalog, searching for the title of the newspaper (i.e. The New York Times)
- You can locate newspaper articles on Westlaw and LexisNexis.
- The BU libraries subscribe to World News Connect, a very current source for news from across the globe.
"Alphabet soup": IGOs (international or intergovernmental organizations) and NGOs (private organizations)
- IGOs:
Intergovernmental Organizations include:
- UN: United Nations (organization chart)
- OAS: Organization of American
States
(organization chart) - COE: Council of Europe (list of member states). Please note that the Council of Europe is different than the European Union.
- IOM: International Organization for Migration (organization chart)
- WTO: World Trade Organization - deals with the rules of trade between nations (organization chart)
- WIPO: World Intellectual Property Organization (organization chart)
- ILO: International Labour Organization (organization chart)
- UNCITRAL: United Nations
Commission International Trade Law (what
is it and what does it do?)
- NGOs: Non-Governmental
Organizations include:
- Amnesty International (what is it and what does it do?)
- Human Rights Internet (what is it and what does it do?)
- Human Rights Watch (what is it and what does it do?)
- International Committee of the Red Cross
- ICC: International Chamber of Commerce (what is it and what does it do?)
- See the alphabetical listing of NGOs from Duke University. It lists information such as each NGO's subject of interest, continent and country of location, as well as applicable IGO affiliation(s).
Researching the Law of a Foreign Jurisdiction
Some additional helpful web sites for international and foreign research include:
- New York University's Globalex Guides
- LLRX.com Resource Center - International Law Guides
- LLRX.com Resource Center - Comparative and Foreign Law Guides
- Foreign and International Law from the University of Chicago D'Angelo Law Library
- Law from Around the Globe from the Legal Information Institute at Cornell Law School
- ASIL Electronic Resource Guide from the American Society of International Law.
- Guide to Researching Foreign Law on the Internet from the ILS Department of Harvard Law School Library
- Foreign and International Law Resources: An Annotated Guide to Websites around the World, from Harvard Law School's ILS Department (scrolling to the bottom of the page takes you to an alphabetical linked to countries around the world)
- World Legal Information Institute includes databases of international courts and tribunals, as well as databases of case law, legislation, treaties, and law journals, from 547 databases among 86 countries. It also includes 21 international databases. WorldLII is a single-search web site that allows a researcher to search the databases included within the following Legal Information Institutes (LIIs): AustLII; BAILII; CanLII; HKLII; LII (Cornell); PacLII, and AsianLII .
- EISIL (Electronic Information System for International Law).
- Intute: Law
- GLIN: Global Legal Information Network at the US Library of Congress
- Confinder (Constitution Finder) to find online constitutions in the native language of the country and translated versions (from University of Richmond).
- Web Sites of National Parliaments (Washington University in St. Louis) to find legislation.
Helpful print resources for foreign legal research include:
- Foreign Law: Current Sources of Codes and Basic Legislation in Jurisdictions of the World, Law Ref Desk K38 .R49 1989 (commonly referred to as "Reynolds and Flores"). (This is the print equivalent to the Foreign Law Guide, which is accessible by BULaw-affiliated individuals, by IP access).
- Germain's Transnational Legal Research: A Guide for Attorneys (Law Ref Desk K 85 G47 1991) (Chapter V)
- Martindale Hubbell International Law Digest, KF 190 .M375 2004
- Guide to International Legal Research, Ref Desk KZ 1234 .G85 2005 (see chapter 5, Research by Geographic-Geopolitical Region)
- Constitutions of the Countries of the World, Law Annex K 3157 B53
If you are conducting foreign legal research, you may also want to review the web guide on Comparative Law, by Paul Norman, available at NYU's Globalex site.
Last updated: May 2007