Red Versus Blue (and Purple) States and the Same-Sex Marriage Debate:
From Values Polarization to Common Ground?

77 University of Missouri-Kansas City Law Review 416 (2008)

Linda McClain


What is the role of courts in circumstances of “values polarization”? The framing of this question brings to mind, but differs from, some familiar inquiries about the judicial role in circumstances of conscientious moral disagreement or  value pluralism and debates about  liberty, morality, and community. Using the conflict over whether civil marriage should extend to same-sex couples as an example, I contrast two recent analyses of values polarization and its implications for finding  agreement, Ronald Dworkin’s book, Is Democracy Possible Here?, and June Carbone and Naomi Cahn’s project,  Red Families v. Blue Families. Dworkin’s strategy is to identify shared principles about human dignity that will make a national debate possible; Carbone and Cahn instead point to two diverging patterns, or models, of family life in red and blue states and two differing regimes of family law – and family values, and suggest how federalism might help in reducing polarization.  As a crucible through which to test these two interpretive projects and their view of the judicial role, I discuss the recent opinion of the Supreme Court of California, In re Marriage Cases (2008), in which the court ruled that California’s constitution required opening up civil marriage to same-sex couples. I contrast the ongoing controversy in California over civil marriage  with the pathways that Oregon and Washington have taken on the issue of marriage equality. I conclude that discussion of values is likely unavoidable in developing and adjudicating family law. I consider whether President Obama’s rejection of the red state-blue state dichotomy and his appeal to “values we hold in common as Americans” signal the beginning of the end of values polarization.

Keywords: Marriage, liberty, courts, values polarization, same-sex marriage, Ronald Dworkin, moral disagreement, dignity, responsibility, family values


Size: 204 KB

Adobe Acrobat Reader v3.01 or greater is required to view this paper.
To obtain a free copy, click the button below

Linda McClain Contact Information
Boston University School of Law
765 Commonwealth Ave
Boston, MA 02215
Phone: 617-358-4635
Fax: 617-353-3077

Presentation and Publication Information:

Linda McClain, "Red Versus Blue (and Purple) States and the Same-Sex Marrige Debate: From Values Polarization to Common Ground?," 77 University of Missouri-Kansas City Law Review 416 (2008).

Social Science Research Network Electronic Paper Collection:

Click here to close this window.