Boston University School of Law

 

The Constitutionality of Decolonization by Associated Statehood: Puerto Rico's Legal Status Reconsidered

Gary Lawson
Robert D. Sloane

50 Boston College Law Review (forthcoming 2009)
Boston University School of Law Working Paper 09-19

Abstract

International and constitutional law arguably collide in the legal arrangement between the United States and Puerto Rico. As a matter of international law, it is unclear that this arrangement conforms to customary international and treaty obligations. As a matter of national law, it is unclear that the Constitution permits an arrangement between Puerto Rico and the United States—short of separation (independence as a State) or integration (admission to the Union as a state)—that could conform to these international obligations.  In particular, the Appointments Clause and the Constitution’s voting provisions may well be in tension with contemporary international law relative to Puerto Rico. In this article, we seek, partly through an internal dialogue, to clarify several unacknowledged or underappreciated legal tensions in the U.S.-Puerto Rico relationship and to explore ways to resolve them. One of us adopts a plain-meaning, originalist view of the Constitution, which underscores the arguable constitutional defects in the current U.S.-Puerto Rico relationship. The other does not embrace originalism and therefore would not exclude resolution of the tensions between international and constitutional law by means of constitutional interpretation. We agree, however, that those tensions can no longer be neglected in a State committed to the rule of law and that several of the most troubling can be resolved—with a modest amount of political will and creativity—in a manner that effectively elides the oft-intractable debates in modern constitutional theory: substantive, even if not formal, international legal compliance can be uncontroversially established. Above all, we seek to reframe and facilitate a long-overdue discussion about how to reconcile U.S. international obligations toward Puerto Rico with the Constitution.

Size: 544 KB
Est. download time @ 28.8K: 18 seconds

Adobe Acrobat Reader v3.01 or greater is required to view this paper.
To obtain a free copy, click the button below

 

Suggested Citation:

Gary Lawson & Robert D. Sloane, "The Constitutionality of Decolonization: Puerto Rico's Domestic and International Legal Status," 50 Boston College Law Review (forthcoming).

 

GARY LAWSON Contact Information
Boston University School of Law
765 Commonwealth Avenue
Boston, MA 02215

Email: glawson@bu.edu

Phone: (617) 353-3812
Fax: (617) 353-3077

 

ROBERT D. SLOANE Contact Information
Boston University School of Law
765 Commonwealth Avenue
Boston, MA 02215

rdsloane@bu.edu

Phone: (617) 358-4633
Fax: (617) 353-3077

This article can also be found at the link below:

SOCIAL SCIENCE RESEARCH NETWORK