THE CENTER FOR WAR, PEACE AND THE NEWS MEDIA AT NEW YORK UNIVERSITY APRIL 29, 2002

William Dowell on why Le Pen has the French and just about everyone else in Europe so worried.

Mikhail Pogorely on why Washington has more to gain from engaging in trade with Moscow than from pushing missile defense

Miriam Pemberton: Under the guise of 'national security,' the U.S. endangers its system of checks and balances

SITE

CONTENTS

SEARCH


Understanding What Happened

Deciding Which News Reports Are Reliable
The Brookings Institution and Harvard held a panel discussion with leading journalists specialized in the Middle East and national affairs, including Robin Wright, Glenn Frankel, David Shipler and Todd Purdum. The theme: How do we know what we are reading in the news about Israel and Palestine is true? (Brookings-Harvard, April 24, 2002)
Ariel Sharon Wins Points with Israelis, But Is Beginning to Feel the Pressure
After last week’s 5-hour meeting with Saudi Arabia’s Prince Abdullah, President Bush laid down the law to Sharon over the weekend. The result: Arafat will go free, his status as a hero confirmed. Ha’aretz reports that the pressure coming from Washington was brutal (Ha’aretz, April 29, 2002)
A Roadmap for Outside Intervention
Both Israelis and Palestinians can inflict unspeakable agony, but neither is capable of victory. With passions inflamed all around, help may be needed from a third party to stop what is turning into a downward spiral of destructiveness. The International Crisis Group analyzes the pros and cons of international intervention. The International Crisis Group (ICG, April 10, 2002)

The Politics of Verticality
Israeli architect, Eyal Weizman, argues that to understand the conflict in the West Bank , it is necessary to see beyond conventional political boundaries. In fact, it requires a 3-D map. The separate world of Arabs and Israelis turns that into six dimensions. To understand what is going on now, it is necessary to grasp the significance of the mountains and hills which provide islands of "Biblical identity" and the aquifers deep below the West Bank which are battlefields as much as the rivers of sewage that flow from Palestinian and Israeli settlements. Weizman painstakingly maps and photographs the overlooked vertical dimensions of the conflict. (Open Democracy, April 29, 2002)
Saudi Arabia's Conflicted Motivations
It is no secret that many Saudis feel anger and humiliation at Israel’s attacks against an Arab population, but Riyadh needs U.S. protection against Iraq and Iran, and it needs to keep the oil flowing to support its flagging, over-extended economy. Two new reports from the Center for Strategic and International Studies analyze Saudi concerns over its own security and the War on Terrorism, and its search for foreign investment and diversification of its economy. (CSIS, April 24, 2002)

Dispatches from the West Bank
"…I will never be able to forget the people whose stories I listened to, or the sounds and smells that accompanied a kind of destruction I didn't know was possible: I now know the smell of death and what it is like to realise that you are standing on top of rubble under which people lie buried…" --Jennifer Loewenstein on Jenin. Whatever the rationale for the recent fighting, anyone who saw the aftermath was likely to be shaken by the experience. Cairo's Al-Ahram published a sampling of reports from the siege. (Al-Ahram, April 20, 2002)



Le Pen and Europe

What If Le Pen Were to Win?
The second round in France’s presidential elections will take place next Sunday, and while Jacques Chirac is expected to win hands down, secret government polls which have been privately circulating on the internet indicate that extreme right politician Jean-Marie Le Pen could be more of a threat than most people realize. UPI senior news analyst Michael Sieff explores the unthinkable and takes a hard look at the voting patterns that have some analysts concerned.(UPI, April 25, 2002).
France Has Quietly Joined the Rest of Europe. Le Pen Wants to Reverse that Trend
The first casualty of a Le Pen victory would very likely be France’s integration into the European Union. Philip Gordon and Sophie Meunier take a look at France’s "globalization by stealth." (LeMonde –in English—April 16, 2002

U.S. Diplomacy
New Directions at Foggy Bottom
In a wide-ranging speech to the Foreign policy Association, Richard Haas, head of the State Department’s Policy Planning Staff, says that we have entered a post-Cold War period in which transnational challenges intersect with traditional concerns. Faced with a multiplicity of threats, Haas sees his role as one of moving in one direction, not many, and of developing a doctrine that will help establish a unified set of basic priorities. (Richard Haas, US State Dept. April 22, 2002)
How Much Will It Cost?
Colin Powell told the Senate Appropriations Committee that the administration will ask for a budget of $16.1 billion for U.S. diplomatic operations and foreign aid, and another $5 billion to fight terrorism. Powell gives a detailed breakdown on who gets what. The International Atomic Energy Agency will get $50 million to counter nuclear terrorism. Afghanistan will cost $140 million. Colombia will get $730 million to fight drugs, and another $98 million to protect its oil pipeline.

Asia
China's Heir Apparent Makes First Trip to U.S.
Hu Jintao, who is expected to replace Jiang Zemin, as president of China next fall, is spending the week getting to know the U.S. Hu is expected to try his hand at jousting with the Bush administration over Taiwan. Relations with China had seemed to be improving in the wake of September 11, but a series of gaffs by U.S. politicians have cooled the atmosphere.Bates Gill at Brookings provides background on Hu. (New York Times, April 29, 2002).
Chinese Missiles Pointed At Taiwan are a Point of Contention
The American Foreign policy Council reports that the Chinese have been massing missiles along the Taiwan Straits, and that the U.S. is getting ready to play a more active role. (American Foreign Polciy Council, April 24, 2002)
The Official List of Party Leaders
provides a complete, if somewhat glowing, biography of Hu, as well as his placement on various party committees. (Chinese government, 2002)
But Can He Control the PLA?

You Ji at the National University of Singapore enumerates Hu’s less visible connections within the Party structure and asks how Hu will handle China’s People’s Liberation Army. (National University of Signapore, February 19, 2002)

Shifting Technologies Spell Trouble for Asian Economies
Singapore and Malaysia cashed in on a high-tech boom that demanded intelligent, but low-cost labor. Trouble is that electronic parts are becoming much cheaper and so miniaturized that they are too small to be built with human hands. The next generation of electronic hardware can be built more efficiently by machines. Companies like Seagate, which manufactures computer disk drives, are shutting down their factories and firing workers by the droves, with potentially disasterous results for local economies. (By Neel Chowdhury, The Far Eastern Economic Review, May 2, 2002)

After Taking a Nose Dive on Wall Street, AOL Hoped to Recoup Its Losses in China. Don't Hold Your Breath
Hooking China up to the Internet sounded like a good idea, especially with AOL’s business in the U.S. turning into a Wall Street pariah. But Steve Case and Gerald Levin didn’t count on Beijing’s nervousness about the internet, and in a complex market they failed to commit sufficient management expertise. And the internet is not the only problem area. Time and Fortune sell less than 2,000 copies in what should be one of the world’s biggest markets. (By Ben Dolven in Shanghai and Alkman Granitsas in Hong Kong, The Far Eastern Economic Review, May 2, 2002)

South Asia

Pakistan Gets to Choose Musharraf for Another Five Years
GMT used to signify Greenwhich Mean Time. The joke in Pakistan these days is that it really stands for General Musharraf Time. The general, who originally said he wanted to turn Pakistan into a democracy, now wants to prolong his tenure for another 5 years. On Tuesday, voters will get to cast their ballots in a referendum which will confirm both the general’s plans to hold on to power and pakistan's stability. Thanks to Musharraf’s acquiescence in the destruction of the Taliban, the West is likely to remain silent about the general’s decision to put democracy on hold. Syed Saleem Shahzad reports from Karachi in the Asia Times. (Nadeem Iqbal, Asiatimes, April 26, 2002)



DO WE REALLY NEED A FREE PRESS?

A gathering of international journalists specializing in Central Asia was slated to take place at the relatively swank, Regent Hotel in Almaty, Kazakhstan on April 26. Nice gesture except that Kazakhstan’s president Nursultan Nazarbayev had just shut down the city’s leading independent newspaper, the Globe, for asking one too many embarrassing questions. It would be reasonable to think that the closure had something to do with recent oil finds in the Caspian Sea, which are expected to boost Kazakh oil production to more than a million barrels a day in the next few years and the fact that a billion dollar slush fund financed by foreign oil companies mysteriously appeared in a secret foreign bank account. That story was quickly dubbed "Kazakh Gate." The Globe, however, was ordered to stop publishing—not for reporting on Kazakh Gate, but because it had failed to print the name of its publisher clearly on the mast head in two issues, and because it had reported inaccurately that it was appearing on Wednesdays and Thursdays, when it actually hit the newsstands on Tuesdays and Fridays. While its paper edition is effectively KO’d, the Globe still appears on the internet in both Russian and English. Nurlan ABLYAZOV, notes in an editorial written from Moscow, that when enough money is at stake there is no incentive for a ruler with absolute power to relinquish any of it. And that goes for the Western interests as well. As long as the oil flows smoothly, why be concerned about legal technicalities at the local level? Especially, if there are no newspapers to report them. Check out the Globe and Ablyazov’s letter from Moscow.



The European Press Network provides access to a wide assortment of European Media Resources and lively foreign reporting. It's reachable at http://www.epnworld-reporter.com/, or by clicking on the logo above.


REPORTING ETHNICITYAND
OTHER DIVERSITY
ISSUES
by The European
Centre for War,
Peace &
The News Media
click here

 

The Journalists' Essential Field Guide to Afghanistan
by Edward Girardet

click here

NYU FIRST
09/11 8:48AM: Documenting America's Greatest Tragedy

click here