Journal of Electrostatics
  Online Review Form

Use this on-line form to submit technical reviews to the Journal of Electrostatics. Written commentary is of far greater value than mere "yes" and "no" answers.

If you have difficulty filling out or submitting this form, please send e-mail to the Editor.

Login:


Reviewer Infomation (not shared with the author):    
Name:
Affiliation:
Telephone:
Fax:  
E-mail:
   
About the paper you have reviewed:
        
Manuscript Number:
Title of Paper:
Authors:

 Your Review - General Criteria:
Is paper in scope of the journal? YES NO
Are the objectives clearly stated? YES NO
Does the paper represent original work? YES NO

Does the summary accurately reflect the contents of the paper?

YES NO
Is this paper clearly written and well-organized?   YES NO
Are the figures of journal quality? YES NO
Are the references adequate and in the correct form?   YES NO
Are the grammar, spelling and punctuation adequate? YES NO
Is this paper likely to be of special interest to the journal readership? YES NO

Key word request:

         

Overall Rating:
Select a rating for this paper from 1 to 6 against others in the Journal of Electrostatics.
         

Recommendation:
Select your recommendation for this paper.
         

Written commentary



Journal of Electrostatics Main Page