There were two things Robert Brown promised himself he would not get caught up in when he was considering taking the job of president of Boston University. “One was what the Globe had written about the University and John Silber,” says Brown. “The other was trying to understand the place before I had to commit. It was too complicated for that.”
I made the transition
from complicated physical systems
to the complexity of the
— Robert A. Brown
The first item, Brown knew, was a requirement for anyone hoping to shepherd BU into the 21st century. Silber (Hon.’95), the University’s president from 1971 to 1996 and later chancellor, had been a walking lightning rod for the Globe, and seemed to revel in the philosophical clashes with the press and political opponents, not to mention his faculty. And when Silber stepped out of firing range, the Board of Trustees stepped in and gave the press something else to take potshots at: in 2003, the board paid former NASA director Daniel Goldin, whom they had signed on as president, $1.8 million to walk away just before he was set to begin the job. By the time a new presidential search committee started talking to Brown in spring 2005, many observers of higher education were not looking at Boston University as a model of executive leadership.
The second item on Brown’s short list of things to steer clear of presented a curious personal anomaly. Because while most leaders of billion-dollar enterprises want to avoid complexity, Brown, a provost and former chemical engineer and applied mathematician at MIT, is in love with it. An organization with 17 schools and colleges, 32,000 students, more than 8,600 employees, and a budget of $1.7 billion offered an irresistible opportunity for analysis and synergies.
“I have always enjoyed dealing with the complexity,” says Brown. “I made the transition from complicated physical systems to the complexity of the academic organization.”
At BU, however, there was more than physical complexity to deal with. There were politics, and the shards of unresolved issues were likely to pop up anytime, anywhere, like targets in a Whack-A-Mole game.
“There were dead cats everywhere,” Brown recalls. “And nobody wanted to bury them.”
Ultimately, he says, he dealt with the complexity by following Albert Einstein’s famous advice to physicists: “Things should be made as simple as possible, but not simpler.”
Where to, BU?
President Robert A. Brown took your questions about past, present, and future changes. Read his responses below.
It worked. Today, five and a half years into Brown’s tenure, the University has seen four years of record surpluses, money that has made it possible to put $172 million into building new dorms and renovating old ones, and $100 million into modernizing classrooms and labs. The University has increased financial aid to students by $32.8 million, bringing the total allocated to financial aid to $277.4 million annually. And his commitment to research and his efforts to build an infrastructure to support that research helped increase sponsored program awards by 33% from the time of his arrival, to $407.8 million in 2010. Alumni gifts have also set new records: prior to Brown’s presidency, the University had had only one gift of more than $10 million. Since he took office, six large gifts account for more than $60 million.
In September 2010, the many positive changes that Brown has brought to BU were officially recognized when the Board of Trustees expressed the hope that he would continue doing what he had been doing for another five years.
Brown said yes.
Story continues below...
carte blanche from the board
to replace anyone he wanted,
but he didn't do that.— David D’Alessandro
As Einstein might have recommended, Brown acted as quickly as possible, but not quicker. Just three months after occupying the eighth-floor corner office that looks across the Charles River at the institute where he worked for 25 years, he asked the heads of all departments to create a 15-page document describing the state of their department and where they wanted to go. And when those reports arrived, he told his deans to boil them down to a single 15-page document for each school. The goal, a new one for BU, was to create a democratically crafted roadmap to the future: a strategic plan.
Julie Sandell, Faculty Council chair from 2006 to 2008, says Brown’s first major move accomplished two important things. It yielded the outlines of a useful strategic plan, and “it showed that this was going to be a new era of cooperative efforts.”
“Dr. Brown realized very quickly that a plan that grows from the bottom up serves a number of purposes,” says Sandell, a School of Medicine
professor of anatomy and
neurobiology and associate provost for faculty development. “It would engage the faculty in thinking in a forward-looking way about how to take BU to the next step. It was a novel idea, that the faculty would have a collective responsibility in determining the direction of the institution. It was more of
a partnership than many faculty had experienced.”
In December 2006, 15 months after Brown came to BU, his strategic planning task force delivered a 33-page framework for the plan. It was posted on the BU website for all to read and for anyone in the University community to comment on. Brown asked for feedback, and he got lots of it, including several concerns about the speed at which he was pushing ahead.
“I knew it was going to be hard,” he says. “But I also knew that if you don’t start moving forward, you spend so much time wringing your hands over the past. You have to tweak or manage the process as it goes. You had to fix it as it moved.”
In September 2007, Brown unveiled Forging Our Future by Choosing To Be Great. The plan was unabashedly ambitious. It outlined ways to make it easier for students enrolled in one college to study in another; it called for improvements to dorms and classrooms and for the recruitment of 100 new faculty for the College of Arts & Sciences. Several of the professional schools were targeted for growth. The School of Management was slated to hire 20 new faculty, the School of Law would begin a capital campaign for an expanded and fully renovated facility, with a dollar-for-dollar match in funding from the University, and the College of Fine Arts would expand and renovate. The plan also established that undergraduate student financial aid would keep Boston University accessible to qualified students regardless of their economic status, and it cited as a priority an effort to make faculty salaries and benefits competitive to attract the best teachers, scholars, and researchers. It included new opportunities for alumni, such as mentoring programs to connect students to the professional world and a revamped career counseling system to provide broader resources for BU graduates.
The price tag was as impressive as the plan: $1.8 billion over 10 years, with annual commitments growing to $225 million per year. But during the many months that the faculty had been honing the plan, Brown and BU’s executive leadership had been exploring ways to pay for it.
“Bob was an instant expert in financial matters,” says
Joseph Mercurio, the University’s executive vice president. “In a very short time he had a thorough understanding of our financial operating model.”
Most of the funding of the plan—60 percent, it was decided—would come from operations and from debt financing. Mercurio says Brown’s modifications to finances, which include a greater reliance on data-driven financial analytics, have allowed the University to double—to $100 million a year—the money transferred to academic programs, student services, and building.
“Some of the money we were able to transfer came from the elimination of units that were not core to the University, like the Tyngsboro campus,” says Mercurio, “and some of it came from fine-tuning things.”
Savings from those efforts, Mercurio says, will pay for projects such as a new
$52 million business management system, making wireless internet access available all across campus, creating a new
$65 million student services center on East Campus, and a renovation of the School of Law tower. Alumni giving also is playing important new roles, such as in the development of the $38 million residence for students at the School of Medicine.
Mercurio says the majority of the University’s forward motion has been guided by one of two notions introduced by Brown. One is the strategic plan; the other is the virtuous circle concept, often applied to business: a closed system of events in which each benefits the next. In the practical case of BU, says Mercurio, it means if the University does well, it reinvests in itself, which leads to its doing better, and reinvesting more.
At the beginning of the 2008 fall semester, three years into the new era of Bob Brown, BU had completed the two best fiscal operating years in its history. University leadership seemed comfortable with the new president, who, to the relief of many, had made no substantial personnel changes.
“Brown had carte blanche from the board to replace anyone he wanted,” says trustee David D’Alessandro, a former Board of Trustees chair and the chair of the search committee that recruited Brown. “But he didn’t do that. He recognized the enormous talent from previous administrations and didn’t bring in any of his own people.”
At least, he didn’t bring in any of his own people to fill top administrative posts. Brown did and does very often seek advice from one of his oldest and wisest friends: his wife, Beverly. “She’s my best friend, my confidant,” says Brown. “We talk about work-related things all the time. She’s really come at this as a partner and immersed herself in BU.”
Beverly Brown is the unpaid director of development for BU’s Center for Global Health & Development. They have two grown sons and live in the 160-year-old Gothic revival mansion known as Sloane House. On summer weekends, Brown says, the two head to their house on the Cape, and as often as possible, to the Ocean Edge golf course in Brewster. “We’re blessed,” he says. “Bev and I have a lot of things we like to do together.”
By mid-September 2008, the University leadership was confronted with something that hadn’t been factored in to the strategic plan: the economy, threatened by an ocean of bad mortgages and dangerously leveraged banks, was about to fall off a cliff. Most university presidents watched nervously, unwilling to make any move that might signal doubt about the fiscal soundness of their institution. Brown didn’t wait. On October 1, he announced that the University would put a freeze on the hiring of new employees and on commitments to capital projects whose construction contracts had not been nailed down.
Less than two weeks later, the Dow Jones industrial average tumbled 18 percent and the Standard & Poor’s 500 fell more than 30 percent in five days of trading.
“That was a case where Bob was a real visionary,” says
Robert Knox (CAS’74, GSM’75), a 13-year veteran and current chair of the Board of Trustees. “He managed the crisis better than most, if not all, peer institutions.”
I think BU is the only
major university that has received
a ratings upgrade in that time by
both major rating agencies,
Moody’s and Standard & Poor’s— Robert Knox
The recession of 2008 and 2009, the worst beating handed to the stock market since the Great Depression, would cost most universities dearly, but unequally. Ironically, the schools with the greatest endowments (and therefore the greatest dependence on endowments) were hardest hit. Harvard, for example, whose endowment (reduced from nearly $37 billion to $26 billion) supported a third of its operating budget, was forced to eliminate almost 300 jobs, freeze salaries, and put on hold plans to expand its campus in Allston. At BU, where the far more meager endowment (down from $1.2 billion to $916 million) provided less than 4 percent of the operating budget, Brown navigated the downturn deftly, with minimal pain and with a mathematician’s precision. He avoided across-the-board salary cuts, froze salaries of $150,000 or more, and capped salary increases for those earning less than $150,000 at 2 to 3 percent. Following the advice of seven task forces that had been charged with cutting $10 million from the $1.9 billion budget, the University pulled 125 job postings. It also closed the Sargent Center for Outdoor Education in New Hampshire, as well as University Computers.
“When you look at Bob’s tenure,” says Knox, “you see truly astute financial management. I think BU is the only major university that has received a ratings upgrade in that time by both major rating agencies, Moody’s and Standard & Poor’s.”
That astute financial management comes to Brown painstakingly, and as he says, painfully. “The most depressed I get annually is the time of year I see the budget proposals,” he says. “Everybody comes in and says, ‘If I had this incremental amount of resource, I could do X, and I could be better.’ And they’re all right. The question is how to prioritize things.”
One of Brown’s most visible—to prospective students— priorities has been a limit on tuition increases. In the last two years, he has kept the rise to 3.73 percent, the lowest increase in three decades, and a likely influence on the increasing number of applicants for slots in the freshman class. During his tenure, applications for undergraduate admission have jumped about 30 percent, from 31,851 to 41,509, an all-time record. That matters, says Brown, because tuition and fees account for about 46.6 percent of the University’s total revenue, while auxiliary services such as dining and housing bring in about 16.1 percent. Sponsored research contributes about 23.9 percent.
New People, New Ideas
“I’m a great fan of private higher education,” Brown says. “I love the self-containment of it. I love the idea of working between the leadership of the University and the faculty and the board. There’s no governor, there’s no legislature, there’s nobody else. If you can figure out a financial model that can get you where you want to go within those constituencies, you go.”
In fact, Brown has done more than figure out a financial model within those constituencies; he’s reconstituted the most influential of them, the Board of Trustees, working closely with longtime members, such as Knox, D’Alessandro, and Alan Leventhal (Hon.’09), another former board chair, to identify and recruit new trustees.
“Today more than half of the 41 members are new to the board,” says Brown. “We have a lot of people who have had past associations with the school and some who were not involved at all. Commercial real estate developer Steve Karp, one of the most successful businessmen in New England, is now the chair of the budget and finance committee. I can say I have the privilege of being a president with one of the best boards in the country, because they put the time and energy into it and they are aligned in trying to making the University better.”
Brown has put similar energy and discernment into his search for deans, appointing 14 of 19 deans, and bringing in such highly regarded leaders as Kenneth Freeman to the School of Management and Benjamin Juarez to the College of Fine Arts. Last fall,
he recruited Jean Morrison as provost, luring her away from the University of Southern California, where she had been executive vice provost
for academic affairs and graduate programs, as well as
director of the USC Women in Science and Engineering program.
“Hiring Jean Morrison says a lot about where the University has come under Bob’s leadership,” says Knox. “I don’t think there’s a chance in the world that someone of her caliber would come here if she were not fully convinced that we have an amazing organization, and an ability to become an even greater organization in a reasonable period of time.”
Working with deans and the Faculty Council, Brown has also made progress narrowing the historic gap between the salaries of men and women. Faculty Council chair Adam Sweeting, a College of General Studies associate professor of humanities, says Brown’s willingness to share all data on salary ranks and gender has helped to reform the relationship between the faculty and administration.
“There is a transparency and a sharing of information that is greatly appreciated,” says Sweeting, lauding Brown’s launch of joint initiatives between the Charles River and Medical Campuses, such as the Center for Global Health & Development, the Center for Neuroscience, and the University Honors College. “He thinks very strategically about academic programs and how to make the University an even better private research university.”
Brown also recognized a few governance holes that had never been filled. And so, for the first time in BU’s history, the University hired a vice president for research, a chief investment officer, and a chief information officer.
D’Alessandro, a longtime observer of BU, former chair, CEO, and president of John Hancock Financial Services, and the author of three books on executive leadership, says Brown’s achievements in his first five years cover the waterfront: he’s worked in impressively collaborative ways with the faculty, he’s diversified the Board of Trustees, he’s expanded the University’s footprint both physically and academically, and he’s made BU a more desirable destination for incoming freshmen. Most notably, he says, in economically uncertain times, Brown has set the University on a sound financial course.
Brown is more modest. He insists that the DNA needed for much of the progress made was here long before his arrival. “My sense of BU, and that hasn’t changed at all since I arrived, is that the faculty have always had a great desire to have the institution be more recognized than it is,” he says. “They have always wanted to be recognized for the quality of this institution and the quality of what we do. My bringing that alignment together was really trivial.”
In the wood-paneled office where Brown will map out BU’s journey for the next five years, a stuffed toy cat sprawls on a windowsill, facing out across the Charles River. The cat, he says, was a gift from a colleague who heard Brown remark shortly after his arrival on the dead cats everywhere that no one wanted to
bury. Today, with this one floppy exception, the dead cats are buried. ■
You Asked, We Answered
Readers took advantage of our invitation to ask President Robert A. Brown about the future of Boston University. Here are some of those questions, along with Brown's responses.
QDr. Brown, Does the University care that its student body has less than 3 percent Latino and African American students? And if so what are some of the ways more outreach to these communities is being handled?
— Gabrielle (CAS’04)
For the record, our undergraduate student body is almost 11.5 percent Latino and African American today and this segment of our student body is one of the fastest growing. We are working to recruit and support an ever more diverse student body by investing in recruiting and student success. Come back and see the construction of our new Center for Student Services which is coming up on Bay State Road to support the increased services we are offering. (You also can watch the construction online using the live camera feed)
QPresident Brown, While I was fortunate enough to live in the Student Village my junior and senior years, I was shoved into a three-person room in West Campus my freshman year that should not have fit more than two. My sophomore year, I lived in a brownstone with mice, broken windows, toilets that constantly broke, cracking walls and floors that looked like they were caving in. I realize that BU is working to constantly improve the housing situation, but those living arrangements were miserable. Shouldn't the money current students spend on tuition go to repairing the rooms students live in versus creating new rooms for future students? I asked that question every day in my four years at BU and would love to finally have an answer.
— Debbie (COM’06)
Thank you for your email. My first reaction is that I wish we could have fixed the problems with the rooms you lived in during your sophomore year. I am surprised that our housing department was not responsive to your complaints and I will investigate so we might do better in the future.
With this said, the reality of a university housing system is that there will always be a spectrum of housing quality, ranging from brand-new units (like the high-rises on West Campus) to those units that badly need renovation. Each year we work to renovate existing housing, both by renovating our brownstones and by renovation of our larger residences. Last year we completed the renovation of Rich Hall on West Campus and Towers on Bay State Road. We also totally renovate a brownstone each year. This summer we will do Sleeper Hall and another brownstone, as well as many other renovations in our housing system.
We will try to do a better job of balancing these total renovations with maintenance of our other residences. I hope this response helps answer your question.
QCan you please eliminate vocational majors like advertising, public relations, and anything in SMG? They aren't intellectually stimulating. They don't provide students with anything except the vocational training necessary to become a corporate systems manager or corporate propagandist. And the people who pursue these degrees are vacuous and materialistic and almost always from New Jersey.
— Ezra (CAS’11)
As an engineer (chemical engineering) by training, I have a hard time accepting your statements about what is intellectually stimulating or vocational. I am a tremendous advocate for a broad-based general education. However, I also believe that professional education is a way to train a person to think critically, without generalizations, and to make cogent, fact-based arguments. I hope you leave Boston University with these skills.
QAre there University-wide plans to help grow and improve the College of Communication, one of the best communication programs in the country?
— Jason (COM’07)
Great question. The College of Communication just completed a comprehensive strategic plan aimed at keeping its position as one of the premier programs in the country. The plan focuses on how to organize the College and curriculum to continue our strengths in the traditional fields while recognizing the revolution in communication caused by new media and technology. I expect the details of this plan to be shared with alumni and friends in the months ahead.
QPresident Brown, You have done a tremendous job over the past 5 years. I remember reading the BU One strategic plan in its entirety my senior year and feeling so energized and proud of my school. From the branding to the campus developments to the faculty, everything looked up. I charged into the workforce waving the BU flag whenever possible. The manner in which you handled the recession only unified your alumni base even more - something BU hasn't really been known for in the past. Know that you have a lot of us out there ready to go to bat for the University. My question for you is concerned with the large-scale, ongoing campus development plan you are working on with CBT Architects. I believe it was coined the "Central Ellipse" at one point. I realize this was a very long-term project, and very ambitious. But that really is one of the biggest steps in unifying the BU campus and community. If there was ever a time to really keep the ball moving, it is now. — Blake (CFA’08)
Thank you for your words of support. We are working to continue to unify the Charles River Campus, following much of the work that was begun with the planning in 2007-2008 about how to redevelop the space adjacent to the BU Bridge. Hopefully, with the economy coming back (albeit slowly) we will have the opportunity to advance these plans in the years ahead. Equally important is the very long-term vision for how to develop the campus and I do think we have this plan pretty well laid out.
QWhat are your plans for athletics beyond hockey? The hockey program is prolific and Jack Parker does and amazing job that everyone can be proud of. There are certainly other sports and coaches who do amazing jobs. However, national recognition is still very much lacking for our sports programs; even hockey is very, very regional. We don't hear much out here in Los Angeles. I'd like to know if there are any plans to make basketball a higher priority (getting into a conference with real competition) or perhaps, and I say this realizing the chances are next to nil, bringing back football? Thank you very much for your time and consideration.
— Brian (COM’97,’99)
If you follow BU student athletics you will see that we are working to have high-quality programs in all the sports in which we participate. Also, we have been investing in our men’s basketball program in particular, including moving a number of their games to Agganis Arena. We saw some of the dividends this year with the team winning the America East championship and playing in the NCAA tournament. Our women’s ice hockey team played for the national title too. We will continue to work to elevate our program, but we will keep the focus on the student aspect of the program. I was very pleased when our men’s basketball team was cited as having one of the highest graduate rates of any team participating in the NCAA tournament.
QPresident Brown, BU's rise as a research institution has been remarkable over the past few years in terms of quality, breadth, and funding. I've often thought that the University's profile would be raised significantly if it could become a member of the Association of American Universities. I understand that membership is by invitation only, but I wonder if BU is being seriously considered for membership? If admitted, how might that impact the University? Thank you, and I look forward to your response.
— Steven (SMG’75)
Unfortunately, this is not an issue that the University has much control over. We make our case through the quality and impact of what we do in research and education. I think our case is compelling, but it is up to the member institutions of the AAU to make this determination.
QWhat other modernization/renovation plans are in store for the BU campus in the next 5 years?
— Ben (CGS’13)
ABen, The new major project that we will launch is an expansion and renovation of the School of Law campus, which will hopefully start in the summer of 2012. We also are in the planning stages for an expansion of the College of Arts & Sciences, but the fundraising for this project will need to advance to make this project a reality. In addition to these major buildings, we will continue to invest in renovations of classrooms, offices, laboratories, and residences all across campus.
QIs there any reasonable chance of "Clarissima" being restored as the school fight song and "Boston University Hymn" its alma mater? Dr. Silber unilaterally changed those things during his tenure. ("Clarissima" is now being used, at a slower tempo, as the University's alma mater. It was played up-tempo as the fight song, along with "Go, BU," which is still in use.) Thank you.
— Scott (CAS’82)
AScott, This is not an issue that has generated much attention. In fact, I don’t recall anyone else bringing it up. It does not seem to be a burning issue.
QThe one area in which this school can improve its service to the students I believe is in the area of transportation. Too often it's taken for granted that the BUS runs late, or sometimes does not come at all. I think that with all the money we provide the school the least they can do is make it much easier on us to get around campus. Put more money into our transportation system, and it would go a loooong way in raising student satisfaction. Everyone takes the shuttle every day. It shouldn't be too much to ask to make our transportation reliable. Just look at the MBTA. They're the example of what not to do. Are there any plans to do this? — Fang (CAS’12)
AFang, Every year we put more funding into transportation, but we don’t seem to make any headway with student satisfaction. It might be that we cannot control Boston traffic or, possibly, that as we put more resources into the system, student expectations just increase. We will look at this again.
QDr. Brown, What would it take for Boston University to reinstate FCS/Division I-AA football to the athletic program, even if it were at the nonathletic scholarship level, similar to the Ivy League and Patriot League? — Gani (CAS’87)
A Gani, I don’t think this is in the cards, as the cost of such a program is very substantial and all indications are that the impact on the BU community would be small. For what it is worth, it is not fair to call a program in an institution that meets full financial need a “nonscholarship program,” as the average level of financial aid per athlete still may be very high. Financial aid, whether in the form of athletic scholarships or “need-based aid” is still a strong recruiting tool.