Review: Romance; Applied Linguistics; Spanish: Fairclough & Beaudrie (2012)
EDITOR: Sara M. Beaudrie
EDITOR: Marta Fairclough
TITLE: Spanish as a Heritage Language in the United States
SUBTITLE: The State of the Field
SERIES TITLE: Georgetown Studies in Spanish Linguistics
PUBLISHER: Georgetown University Press
REVIEWER: Diego Pascual y Cabo, Texas Tech University
The fifteen chapters included in this volume address a variety of topics
pertaining to current research trends concerning Spanish as a heritage
language (HL) in the context of the United States. The introductory chapter,
written by Sara Beaudrie and Marta Fairclough (the editors of this volume),
lays the foundation for the remainder of the book by presenting a general
review of Spanish heritage speaker bilingualism in the US. As such, the
authors discuss broad topics such as the history of the Hispanic presence in
the US, the terms heritage speaker (or heritage learner) and heritage language
and Spanish as a heritage language. The chapter concludes by presenting the
scope and organization of the volume.
The remainder of the book is conveniently organized into four main units (and
an afterword), each one dealing with an important subfield of study within
Spanish HL research. Covering topics such as language policy, language
maintenance, and codeswitching, Part I (Chapters 1 to 4) offers a general
overview of the field. Part II (Chapters 5 to 7) focuses on current trends in
empirical research on linguistic aspects of Spanish as a HL. Issues such as
motivation, attitudes, and identity are analyzed in Part III (Chapters 8 and
9). Finally, Part IV (Chapters 10 to 13) focuses on pedagogical perspectives.
Below is a chapter-by-chapter summary of the remaining 13 chapters (and the
In Chapter 1, “Spanish Heritage Language Maintenance: Its Legacy and Its
Future”, Susana V. Rivera-Mills offers a comprehensive overview of the past,
present and future of Spanish HL maintenance and shift in the United States.
In her discussion, Rivera-Mills notes the heterogeneity and dynamicity of
Spanish speaking communities and makes a strong claim in favor of increased
interdisciplinary research to connect the social, ideological, political,
educational, and linguistic dimensions.
In Chapter 2, Jennifer Leeman explores the complex and multifaceted topic of
language ideologies and their relationship with other social phenomena (e.g.,
gender, race). Referring to the five levels of organization that characterize
language ideologies (Level 1: Language ideologies are linked to the social,
political, and economic interests of individuals/groups of people; Level 2:
Language ideologies are multiple and variable; Level 3: Speakers’ awareness of
language ideologies is varied; Level 4: Language ideologies mediate between
social structures and forms of talk; Level 5: Language ideologies play an
important role in identity construction (45-47)) identified by Kroskrity
(2004), Leeman specifically examines the extent to which (and how) dominant
ideologies (i.e., standard language ideology) permeate into the educational
system in the context of Spanish HL education in the US.
In Chapter 3, “Policy Planning Research for Spanish as a Heritage Language:
From Language Rights to Linguistic Resource”, Glen Martínez reviews previous
work on language policy/planning to illustrate how past approaches to Spanish
as a HL (i.e., as a problem, as a right, and as a resource) have influenced,
and continue to influence, current research and pedagogical practices. With an
eye on the future, Martínez points to several important areas that research
should address (e.g., the role of administration in the educational
integration of Spanish HL learners and their subsequent emergence as leaders
in the academic achievement of Latino youth).
In Chapter 4, “Key Concepts for Theorizing Spanish as a Heritage Language”,
Andrew Lynch questions previous theoretical assumptions that have long been at
the heart of previous studies focusing on Spanish as a HL, and presents a
discussion of theoretical constructs relevant to the future of the field
(e.g., diglossia, register, proficiency, agency, and generation). Such a
discussion is aimed at generating critical theoretical dialogues so as to
develop a working framework (and a mutual theoretical understanding,
therefore) across and within the different subfields of study.
In Chapter 5, “The Grammatical Competence of Spanish Heritage Speakers”,
Silvina Montrul provides a thorough overview of studies that examine knowledge
and use of Spanish heritage speakers from a formal linguistic point of view as
well as from a sociolinguistic perspective. Pointing to the similarities
(and differences) between HL learners and second language learners, the second
half of the chapter is devoted mainly to discussing classroom-oriented
In Chapter 6, “Pragmatics and Discourse: Doing Things with Words in Spanish as
a Heritage Language”, Derrin Pinto reviews studies that have focused on
pragmatics and other discourse-related phenomena. Some of the topics discussed
in this chapter are speech acts (e.g., direct/indirect requests, compliments,
responses, and expressions of gratitude), pronoun usage (e.g., ‘tú/usted’
“informal you/formal you”) and discourse markers (e.g., ‘nomás’ “just/only”;
‘entonces’ “so/then”; ‘tú sabes’ “you know”).
In Chapter 7, “Code-Switching: From Theoretical to Pedagogical
Considerations”, Ana Carvalho explores the social and linguistic dimensions
related to the alternation of languages within a single discourse or sentence.
Not only does she challenge the commonly-held misconception that views this
phenomenon negatively, but she also examines its social functions and
linguistic constraints to reveal its systematic and rule-governed nature.
Consistent with this premise, Carvalho advocates the need for a better
understanding among language educators (and researchers) of code-switching and
discusses the best ways to incorporate it into the HL classroom.
In Chapter 8, “SHL Learners’ Attitudes and Motivations: Reconciling Opposing
Forces”, Cynthia Ducar compares and contrasts the nature and the role of
students’ motivations/attitudes from a HL orientation, as opposed to a second
language orientation. After reviewing the literature on foundational
constructs, such as anxiety, attitude, and motivation, Ducar emphasizes that
in order to better understand these complex and multidimensional psychological
(and physiological) states, future research should aim to incorporate a
socioculturally informed perspective and to use more qualitative and
Chapter 9, “Identity and Heritage Learners: Moving beyond Essentializations”,
by Kim Potowski, examines some of the concepts that underlie theories of
identity-formation (e.g., performativity, hybridity, communities of practice)
to then explore the ways in which Hispanics in the US deal with or perform
being bilingual English-Spanish speakers. Potowski focuses her discussion on
the role that the (Spanish) dialectal variation and proficiency play in the
complex process of construction, perception, and negotiation of identities in
the Spanish HL classroom.
In Chapter 10, “Research on University-Based Spanish Heritage Language
Programs in the United States: The Current State of Affairs”, Sara Beaudrie
provides a comprehensive review of the field of post-secondary education
programs of Spanish as a HL across the United States. Although Beaudrie notes
that the interest and research focusing on HL education has experienced vast
improvement since the 1970s, she calls for the need to continue widening the
scope and methodologies of research so as to enhance our understanding and
better our educational practices.
In Chapter 11, “ Meeting the Needs of Heritage Language Learners: Approaches,
Strategies, and Research”, Maria Carreira elaborates on a variety of
theoretical as well as practical issues related to the teaching of Spanish as
a HL. After an initial review in which prior developments are discussed,
Carreira highlights the socioaffective needs of HL learners and provides a
realistic picture of the multifaceted task that is teaching Spanish as a HL.
Among others, Carreira discusses important topics such as mixed classes,
learner diversity, input differences, literacy and schooling, attitudes,
motivation, and identity.
In Chapter 12, Cecilia Colombi and Joseph Harrington shed light on the
specific needs (and challenges) that Spanish heritage learners are facing
nowadays in US educational contexts. Upon considering a number of theoretical
models (i.e., The Autonomous Model, The Ideological Model, Systemic Functional
Linguistics, and The Continua Model), Colombi and Harrington present an
overview of the sociocultural and linguistic perspectives that weigh in on the
development of (Spanish/English) advanced biliteracy in the US.
In Chapter 13, “Language Assessment: Key Theoretical Considerations in the
Academic Placement of Spanish Heritage Language Learners”, Marta Fairclough
examines traditional as well as current language assessment tools and
discusses their implications for HL research and education. Despite recent
advancements in the area of HL assessment (e.g., Blake et al. 2008; Fairclough
2011; Potowski et al. 2012), Fairclough concludes her chapter by calling for
the need for further research and development in placement procedures.
The volume closes with Guadalupe Valdés’ afterword in which, after briefly
summarizing antecedent chapters, she explores future research directions for
the field of (Spanish) HL education in the United States. Among other things,
Valdés focuses her attention on the complex and multifaceted nature that
characterizes this broad area of research to point out the significant
benefits that can be obtained by incorporating developments from all related
In the context of the US, the increasing interest in the study of Spanish as a
HL is of no surprise given that the Spanish speaking population has
exponentially increased both in number and in socioeconomic importance over
the last 20 years or so (e.g., Field 2011; Potowski 2010; Roca 2000; Valdés,
Fishman, Chávez, and Pérez 2006). Despite this growing interest, the field of
(Spanish) heritage speaker bilingualism remains in its initial stages when
compared to other areas of linguistic study. Evidence of this is the
relatively scarce number of volumes and manuscripts that are dedicated
strictly to current research on Spanish as a HL in the US (see e.g., Roca
2000; Roca and Colombi 2003; Roca and Lipski 1993 for most recent comparable
publications). In light of this, Beaudrie and Fairclough’s edited volume is
therefore a very welcome contribution, as it fills a much needed gap in the
Designed mostly as a reference tool for researchers and (graduate) students
alike, this book provides the reader with a comprehensive picture of research
trends on Spanish as a HL in the US. Although not a text-book, per se, this
volume could definitely be used in (under)graduate courses that focus on
bilingualism and Spanish in the US. Also, because it recognizes the central
role of education within the field, its content will be of tremendous value to
anyone who is (or is training to be) a Spanish teacher in the US. That said,
those expecting to find more about formal approaches to Spanish HL acquisition
will perhaps be somewhat disappointed since, with the exception of Montrul’s
chapter, the discussion of HL grammatical competency seems, to a certain
degree, muffled; especially in comparison to the other areas of inquiry with a
larger presence. This is perhaps the only shortcoming of this volume.
In my opinion, and to the editors’ credit, one of the strongest assets of this
volume is that it brings together a wide array of contributors (all top
scholars in the field) from different backgrounds and diverse interests to
successfully represent current research trends in a coherent fashion. Each
chapter guides the reader through a well thought-out (interdisciplinary)
approach to an area of major growth in this field and addresses questions that
(i) outline the current state of knowledge and (ii) offer future lines of
research (8-9). Furthermore, not only do these chapters offer important
insights into the history, development, and current state of the various
subfields that make up this emerging discipline (e.g., language
policy/planning, language ideologies, language assessment, pragmatics,
attitudes/motivations), but they also provide the reader with the necessary
background information to further explore and develop a greater understanding
of the issues that are of relevance to each of those lines of research.
Blake, R., N., Wilson, M. Cetto, & C. Pardo Ballester. (2008). Measuring Oral
Proficiency in Distance, Face-to-face and Blended Classrooms. Language
Learning and Technology 12 (3): 114-117.
Fairclough, M. (2011). Testing the Lexical Recognition Task with
Spanish/English Bilinguals in the United States. Language Testing 28 (2):
Field, F. (2011). Bilingualism in the USA: The Case of the Chicano-Latino
Community; [Studies in Bilingualism 44]. Amsterdam: John Benjamins.
Kroskrity, P. (2004). Language Ideologies. In A. Duranti (ed.), A Companion to
Linguistic Anthropology. Malden, MA: Blackwell.
Potowski, K. (Ed.) (2010). Language Diversity in the United States.
Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Potowski, K., Parada, M., & Morgan-Short, K. (2012). Developing an online
placement exam for Spanish heritage speakers and L2 students. Heritage
Language Journal, 9 (1), 51-76.
Roca, A. & C. Colombi (Eds.) (2003). Mi Lengua: Spanish as a Heritage Language
in the United States. Washington, DC: Georgetown University Press.
Roca, A. & J. Lipski (Eds.) (1993). Spanish in the United States: Linguistic
Contact and Diversity. Berlin: Mouton de Gruyter.
ABOUT THE REVIEWER
Diego Pascual y Cabo is Assistant Professor of Hispanic linguistics and
director of the Spanish Heritage Language Program at Texas Tech University.
His primary research interests focus on heritage language development and
second language acquisition.
LINGUIST List: Vol-25-767